Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

I got to dig into one so far, but they have been amazing, will be having one this upcoming weekend after my wrestling tournament Friday!!

The brownies were the bomb!!! I’d love to see more chocolate and peanut butter combos from you in the future!

Best brownies we have ever had. Wish Dark knight was a permanent flavor but love that yall change it up monthly. Can't wait to order again!!!

Great experience. I love the ooze on the Mr buckeye & the mvp, it’s my favorite so far, cant wait to try the Cookie Monster.

Cookie Monster and the chips ahoy brownies were top notch. I have not tried the duchtchess delight but I’m sure it will be just as good. 10/10

This is my second time ordering Buckeye brownies & they are twice as nice! The Cookie Monster brownies is outstanding! Whenever I want something sweet buckeye brownies is the way!

The Buckeye brownies were outstanding. I have to say I prefer the brownie over the blondie but wow!!! Delicious! And Huge!

Very delicious. Nice balance of brownie, cookie, and M&Ms. Reminds me of Easter. I would get this flavor again.

How many ice cream with my brownie needs to taste me so much better but every time I order I always ice cream with itI’m

I highly recommend this brownie. From the crunchy candied pecans to the savory spices in the mix and flavorful brownie all and all it's delishhhhh.

Absolutely amazing!!!! Gets better every time I’ll never stop buying these!!! Zach you are a genius keep up the amazing work!

I can’t say how delicious they are without you actually buying them yourself. I would not recommend anything if I didn’t like them myself.

The best choice for after my bodybuilding show. Ate all four of them in a week between my boyfriend and I. Definitely gonna get them again

The Packaging was gorgeous!! I loved the brownies! They tasted fresh and moist and my order came quick with no issues. :)

Bought these for my husband for his birthday and he LOVED them! They are so thick and absolutely DE-LICIOUS!

Ordered these brownies for me and my girlfriend to try for the first time and they were amazing! We are definitely ordering some again soon

It was a super awesome experience! We loved the variety! Bugs Bunny was our favorite, but they were all delicious!

Loved the cheesecake if this s*** especially the blueberry. I couldn't get enough of them I wish I had more of them. Thank you very much buckeye brownies

Got my order i got the Limited Edition Cheesecake Box and No Bake Buckeye Bombs and they look good can't

Fantastic flavor, quality product. These brownies exceeded every expectation Inhad going in. Definitely will order more brownies, or any product you offer. Excellent packaging and shipping.

The cake was delicious! I am definitely going to be ordering from here again and would encourage everyone else to as well!

My son saw you on Instagram and had to try these. We LOVED them and can’t wait to try some other flavors.

Lowkey made the video for the discount but I have bought the monthly boxes back to back. They’re such good flavors

The lemon cups is one of the best things I've ever tasted from Buckeye Brownies. I wish that would be kept as a permanent menu item.

These brownies are something special, and I mean a good special. I ordered the lemon haze, and snicker doodle chill. The lemon haze was my favorite. I'm officially hooked.

Huge Buckeye Brownies fan. The monthly rotating flavors makes me need a new box every month. Cannot say enough great things about Buckeye brownies. Customer for life.

The Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups are AMAZING! I could have eaten all of them at once and not shared one bite with my husband for his birthday :D

This lil brownie cups- well, they’re huge they cover my whole palm- are absolutely delicious! They his a sweet craving like nothing else. They’re just super yummy scrumptious.

Amazing and worth the wait! So soft and so fresh! Absolutely a hidden gem, thanks TikTok and IG for letting me know. It's right here in Ohio too.

All four were amazing. These are so dangerous but in a good way. We have yet had a brownie we didn’t like. We keep coming back for more.

Already eat 3/4 of the brownies out of the box and it’s only been like 2 weeks haha. Best Brownies and Blondies out there.

I have ordered this package before and loved it. My intention is to pass this box around to a few friends! I’m sure they’ll enjoy these Buckeye Bombs!

These brownies were fantastic. All 4 brownies brought something different to the table. It took us days to finish them off. They're huge. Absolutely loved them

What a great product! Only order this if you love absolutely massive brownies. 10/10. Shipped fast and packaged professionally. Valentine’s Day came early this year

Ordered 2 boxes of brownies, which are amazing...the order arrived late so they refunded me shipping cost. But also sent ne another batch of brownies which was awesome.

Absolutely insane they are always amazing so delicious and the perfect dessert for a cheat meal i love you guys!

Great assortment of flavors! A must try! I would recommend the UPS delivery and above when ordering and I also selected rush baking.

First time trying out Buckeye Brownies and I must say, I’m very impressed 🔥 Favorites were Campfire Crunch & Peanut Butter Perfection 😋

My wife was very happy with the results. Everything was absolutely delicious! It was a nice surprise she got for Valentine’s Day.

The brownie are truly delicious best i ever had. This was my first experience with Buckeye Brownie it was truly amazing the best 10/10