Ann O.Verified
A1
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"Simply the best brownies!!"
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsSee product reviews
Jessica M.Verified
Highly recommend
Purchased item
Order Protect
"10/10 would Recommend worth every penny!!"
Jorden H.Verified
Brownies were too sweet for me and didn’t have the flavor I was looking for fudge cups were great.
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Brownie fudge cups were good gave two to my c..."
Luke F.Verified
They weren’t as good as I expected to be honest. I think they were a bit dry. Not sure if they were in the sun too long when they got delivered.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"To be honest, they were pretty dry. Not sure..."
Christopher P.Verified
It was great
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Only had one brownie so far but it was great"
Ira N.Verified
The flavor was a disappointment
Purchased item
Limited Edition February Box
"Theyre very bland...the taste doesnt match th..."
Tyler S.Verified
N/a
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Super good, ton of food! Shared with friends..."
Randall W.Verified
Easy
Purchased item
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
"Excellent! Yum yum! I already recommend to ma..."
Tupric S.Verified
10/10
Purchased item
The Ultimate Cookie Cake
"10/10 would highly recommend .!!!"
Riann R.Verified
So good, they were gone in 2 days
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"They're absolutely great. I don't have any pi..."
Tiffany J.Verified
The flavors weren't very good.
Purchased item
Limited Edition February Box
"They were to gooey. Couldn't tell what the fl..."
Katrina A.Verified
it was great
Purchased item
Order Protect
"it was awesome!!!!! LOVE IT!!! my children lo..."
Gary B.Verified
🥰
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"🥰"
Matt J.Verified
I thought the snickerdoodle was decent and the rest of them I was underwhelmed. I thought they were a little dry and not a ton of flavor. For what I paid, way overpriced. Maybe it was a bad batch or shipping conditions weren’t right. It would be hard for me to justify the money spent on what I felt was mediocre. I have no problem spending $40+ at local bakeshops that I frequent but this missed the mark.
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"I thought the snickerdoodle was decent and th..."
Preston G.Verified
👍
Purchased item
Limited Edition February Box
"Good gone"
Ralph D.Verified
Very long delivery despite adding rush
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"Bad"
Frank F.Verified
Well packaged and tasty
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"Very tasty"
Tasha S.Verified
It was great!
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"Really good brownies but underbaked. Microwav..."
Marienne M.Verified
Love!
Purchased item
Limited Edition Pistachio Box
"I've always loved your products! I look forwa..."
Stephen S.Verified
Overpriced and seemed under cooked honestly
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Wasn’t what I expected. Honestly overpriced"
Valerie A.Verified
Shipping and prep time isn’t accurate.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
"It took a while for the brownies to get here..."
Marie A.Verified
The site was easy to navigate and descriptions were good.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
"My family and I were so ready to love these b..."
Marcus J.Verified
Could of tasted it better
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"Could tasted better"
Biva D.Verified
All in all a great first experience!
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Each variety was unique and delicious. It too..."
Daniel K.Verified
They are well made and taste wonderful.. not too sweet, just right !!
Purchased item
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
"The cookies tasted great !!"
Rolando G.Verified
They were delectable.
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"These were the best brownies I have ever had...."
Marcus W.Verified
10/10
Purchased item
Hella Nutella 4-Pack - February Flavor of the Month
"10/10"
Joey T.Verified
Easy and straightforward
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Amazing flavors, texture, and overall experie..."
Devon B.Verified
Other than my brownieand packaging being crushed it was good
Purchased item
Order Protect
"My box was smooshed with a part of the seal b..."
Mark H.Verified
Easy to order! It’s always the wait till we get to enjoy them!!
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"The brownies were incredible!! Each flavor wa..."
Annalee B.Verified
Very easy to find everything I wanted to order, good flavor options.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"All of the brownies tasted amazing and the st..."
Emma P.Verified
Expensive but tasted good especially after being warmed up
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Didn't taste good, chalky"
Cindy V.Verified
Website could be easier to visualize the different varieties and flavors
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Everything a-ok!"
Wendy M.Verified
Packaged great, showing each individual brownie.
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Everything was a hit !! Delicious and certain..."
Jennifer M.Verified
Very easy to navigate the site and place an order.
Purchased item
February Bundle Pack
"Absolutely delicious!"
Kirsten J.Verified
Easy order and payments.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Shipped quickly, baked to order. Changing sel..."
Joyce M.Verified
Just took too long:)
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"The snickerdoodle and oatmeal cream pie were..."
Kim D.Verified
Everybody has different taste so you just have to find yours!!
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"I love the pb brownies and I really need to s..."
William W.Verified
The brownies just were not good at all
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The brownies were not good 😭😭"
Ramona B.Verified
Very easy
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The order came quickly and everything was del..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsVisit store