Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

First time ordering these and was SO impressed! Super soft, giant and delicious! Will definitely be ordering again! SOON 🙌🏽

I enjoyed it very much.My favorite out the box is the cupid cake.I can’t wait for my next order to get here.

Got these for my husband's birthday! He LOVED them! We tried the cookie monster brownie together and it was so good! Would highly recommend!

The brownies were very good. I always put ice cream on them now after I warm up for a better tasty experience, which I enjoy very very much.

They are an Experience, One Of the Reasons Why I am leaving other sweets Alone. Delicious is An understatement Thank You And May God Continue To Bless You

The pistachio was amazing and vey flavorful. The pb smore, hella nutella, and butterfinger were a must for me to get again. These are def among my favorites.

Been wanting to try Butter finger AF for sooo long now an it did not disappoint, one of the best peanut butter brownies I’ve had yet.

You all know what you're doing. Size, taste, creativity, it's all worth the wait for the brownies to be shipped across the country.

All 4 brownies were spectacular. They were way bigger than expected and took us several days to eat. We preferred to warm them up. Would order again

My son loved his birthday gift .It got delivered on time and they said everyone in his family loved the box of brownies .

Huge & delicious!! I wish they had better descriptions but I will take my chances on ordering them blindly because they’re so good!

These were delicious! So gooey when warmed in the microwave just like right out of the oven. Definitely recommend will not disappoint!

It was so delicious and worth it. Would definitely recommend and purchase again. Cant wait to try a new flavor 😋

I love anything with chocolate marshmallows and peanut butter and I love the cutting edge flavors buckeye always have 👌😋😋

Loved it! We will definitely be ordering from you guys again. Your brownies are going to be our wedding and groom’s cakes.

I’ve yet to try everything but I absolutely loved the Oreo fudge brownie cups I will definitely order those again!

Build your own box is perfect when you're indecisive, or if you just found one brownie you absolutely love! PB SMORE SHOULD BE A MAIN STAY!!

I took these to work to share because they are so big. Everyone enjoyed them and I especially loved the snickerdoodle and chill. Definitely my favorite.

I've only tried the pistachio blondie so far the rest are frozen for now. My god it was delicious. I'm can't wait to try the rest.

These were the best brownies I've ever had. They were just as good in day three as day 1. Worth every penny

Ted velvet are my favorite so far. Bottom left in the picture. Ended up ordering 4 pack after getting the single!

Ok, so every big like bigger than I expected so happy about that I'm definitely going to buy some more!

Take a second and imagine the best possible brownie you could ever think of… buckeye brownies are 10x better than that. Completely unreal, it’s an experience having these.

My favorite one was muffin madness I give it 10\10 then butter Biscoff I give it 10/10 cookies monster 8.5/10 peanut butter paradise 8.5/10

Zach was amazing with updating my shipping They all tasted amazing. I can’t wait for the Christmas holiday bundle ! I recommend them to everyone Thank you zach !

These strawberry cookies are amazing! I actually ate one direct from the freezer. It was still good and just melted in my mouth.

Absolutely loved this cups, plus I was shocked to see just how big they really were. Love tye soft middle and thick outer layer!

The brownies are very original. They’re moist, very huge and they all taste delicious. I got the limited edition valentines box. Well worth the money.

Great quality brownies and very filling! Super sweet and yummy and great texture! Love the build a box! Favorite was definitely the MVP !!

I love the build a box!! I can try some of the new flavors while avoiding the ones I know I probably won't like. These brownies are amazing!!!

My build a box was amazing as usual!! Can't wait to see what flavors they come up with next. Hopefully a girl scout cookie inspired box.

So delicious. The Lemon really surprised me! I knew it would be good, but I didnt know it would be THAT good!

These are the real deal! Still soft and delicious even after shipping! I don’t know how they do it, but it’s done right!

The v day 4 pack was pretty solid but i did prefer the brownie based flavors over the blondie based.

Totally delicious, I shared a square with family and friends. I brag about your brownies and how delicious they are!

Delivery was quick. Huge, tasty and very delicious with some icecream on top. Sat down and ate all four at once. Worth price! Gotta try the other flavors now.

For my first time ever ordering buckeye brownies it was phenomenal, the cookie Monster and Peanut Butter brownie were my favorites. A bit expensive tho!

So far these are the best brownies ever! Second time enjoying these , I freeze about half of them for a rainy day!

Loved having the option to pick flavors i wanted to try instead of being forced to spend money on a box with most I wouldn't be interested in trying

It was amazing start to finish my favorite is the peanut butter with chocolate sprinkled with reeses pieces!!! This will now be a monthly treat to myself going forward!!