Hector R.Verified
Amazing they taste like a rainbow explosion lol. Warm em up in the microwave with ice cold milk doesn't get better than that, will definitely order again
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Fantastic Four Pack
Alya A.Verified
The best time of the month is when I receive the long-awaited package from Buckeye Brownies! Loved the flavors!
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
Stephanie S.Verified
Super delicious! Shipping was fast and brownies arrived in perfect condition. My family was so happy to get such a special treat we could all enjoy!
Gluten Free Box
Geri B.Verified
I love, love, love, these brownies! I can’t wait to try more flavors! My favorite is the s’mores and peanut butter brownie!
Build Your Box
+4Jeffery H.Verified
These were fantastic brownies! I will definitely order again, so if you're looking for something that's delicious you should order these brownies. Jeff Hom
Fan Favorite Bundle Pack
+1Lee G.Verified
No one makes brownies quite like these! They taste just as good thawed as they do fresh. I will be ordering a different selection once they're gone.
Fan Favorite Bundle Pack
Kayla V.Verified
The brownies were amazing! They were delicious warmed up or just how they were! 10/10 would defiantly get again.
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
+1Kailey L.Verified
Amazing! The packaging was so cute and the brownies are so gooey. They’re not super sweet everything blends together really well.
The MVP 4-Pack
Ivan W.Verified
Loved them all as expected! I'm glad you all love peanut butter as much as I do. I definitely made the right decision ordering two variants of that.
Order Protect
Logan Y.Verified
I've only tried the peanut butter and Cookie Monster ones so far and they are amazing!! Excited to try the biscoff and blueberry muffin ones!
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Mariely V.Verified
I liked the brownies. It would be nice if they were a little sweeter since they taste a little bland. Other than that, they are pretty great.
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Lisa B.Verified
Brownies traveled from Ohio to Florida and had no problems. They were delicious and decadent. I would not be hesitant in shipping the brownies long distances.
Order Protect
+2Emily O.Verified
These are the best brownies I’ve ever had. The Muffin Madness was extremely next level amazing. They all were truthfully. 100/10 recommend
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Timothy M.Verified
It was orgasmic, appley ever after is one of the top 5 best things I’ve ever put in my mouth.
Order Protect
Michael F.Verified
Your Brownies were my Daughter's First Treat after she won her very first NPC Bikini Competition. The first bite blew her away and every bite after was true bliss.
Build Your Box
Laquisha J.Verified
My family and I loved them especially the bugs bunny that was our top favorite please make them again 😝😝😝😝
Build Your Box
Dustin V.Verified
The Cosmiz Craze and Milk& Cookies are phenomenal. Cosmic craze is the best fudge brownie Zach has ever made. The crust was even soft which no other brownie he has made is. Perfect fudge flavor! Milk & Cookies is the perfect cookie and oreo combo.
Limited Edition Back To School Box
Dustin V.Verified
All brownies are good but Cosmic Craze and Milk & Cookies are phenomenal. Cosmic Craze is the best crust I've had from Buckeye thus far. It was soft and moist just like the center making it perfect in texture, and the fudge flavor was top notch.
Limited Edition Back To School Box
Leigh Ann S.Verified
This was our second order! They are so wonderful! Never overly sweet in my opinion! Pairs well with a glass of milk!
Order Protect
Ivan W.Verified
They are killing it with these Blonde cups. The lemon ones from the summer was fantastic. These are top notch as well!
The Classics - Pumpkin Roll Blondie Cups
Ryan M.Verified
Was excellent. Should keep all brownie types open to the store as I will not be ordering again till those brownie flavors are back. But overall amazing
Order Protect
Justin G.Verified
Such an amazing treat and happy to support a fellow buckeye, can't wait for my next Febuary box to get here, numnumnumnum
Pick Two
Mary S.Verified
Sent these to my daughter as a little surprise... her and her BF LOVED them. They cut them in half and froze one half. Thanks for a great product!
Order Protect
Dan H.Verified
I think they were better this time around. Shipping seems to take a while. I prefer to choose my own or maybe the option of one whole brownie. I find myself wondering what $60 worth of homemade brownies would look like comparatively.
Build Your Box
Todd B.Verified
Three of the brownies were great. A little crispy around the edges, but once i warmed them up in the microwave they were excellent. One arrived a bit dried out. The flavor was still great and if it had been a little fresher It would have been a 5 star hands down.
Order Protect
John J.Verified
So I had very high expectations for this product and went back and forth with myself thing is it really worth it are they really that good and finally I pulled the trigger. First shipping was a little longer than I expected but finally they brownies showed. Couldn’t wait to dig in. So dig I did and let’s just say I was disappointed. To me and sorry to say not worth it. Not say they were horrible just not for me. Some a little dry and lacking flavor. I’m happy so many others enjoy them and honest...
Order Protect
Autumn E.Verified
This is our first time ordering and since we are vegan the options are limited but we are so grateful there *are* vegan options. My only complaint was the Oreo ones were fairly dry. The top cookie portion was fine but the darker Oreo base was just okay. The snickerdoodle are amazing though! Next time we will definitely get more of them!
Vegan Box
Lydia R.Verified
They were all amazing! The NY Cheesecake one is one of my new favorites! Such good flavors and the topping was so delicious! The PB Perfection is already one of my top choices as well! Really good variety! I enjoyed them all!
Limited Edition New Year’s Surprise Box
Justin H.Verified
Package was a gift. Well received and certainly being enjoyed. Hopefully not all at the same time, but that’s not up to me.
Order Protect
India E.Verified
Any box that includes Ted Velvet is an automatic 5 stars. I enjoy the different holiday pack variety every year and would recommend.
Limited Edition Holiday Pack
Barbara H.Verified
Love the build a box. I was able to get exactly what I wanted. Can't wait to place next order.
Build Your Box
Briana B.Verified
I got my mom a box of 4 for Mother’s Day and she loved it! She even shared with my siblings LOL!
Order Protect
Frederick E.Verified
One of the brownies I think the carrot one started to grow mold on it. Not blaming anyone just wanted you guy's to know that once delivered these definitely need to be put in a fridge. The self life that you have on you're website isn't that accurate. Lesson learned for next time all in all not bad. I loved the chocolate and peanut butter cups they were the best!
Fall Favorites Bundle
+1Crystal M.Verified
They are very delicious and fresh. Even when I freeze them and eat them later. I love the texture and taste. Each bite is flavorful.
Order Protect
Leezette G.Verified
This peanut butter cup was so good, I wanted to take the one I gave away back. Instead we ordered some more. 🤗🤗🤗
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
Adam M.Verified
The Birthday Buckeye Brownie box was amazing. All the brownies were great, my two favorite were cookie monster and peanut butter paradise!
Order Protect
Jack T.Verified
These were awesome! With all the hype around Dubai Chocolate, these were the best variation ive had! Cant wait till they come back!
Limited Edition Pistachio Box - CLOSEOUT
Brandon B.Verified
Second order and got two different boxes, the other was the m&m closeout box. Both were spectacular. I was a particular fan of the Cornflake Crunch!
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
Dustin V.Verified
The Fudge cups bundle is a good different option from the brownies. If you want a more tradition brownie texture with oreo or PB flavor, this is it. Very moist and taste great. Downside, they don't hold up as well through travel and are smashed some.
The Classics - Fudge Cups Bundle
+1Shanna M.Verified
This is my favorite girl scout cookie, so I had to try it. It was delicious. The only thing I would have added was a layer of brownie at the bottom. I hope this becomes a regular menu item!
Scout’s Favorite 4-Pack - June Flavor of the Month
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store