Tamiya A.Verified
These were so good and fresh. Reminded me of a childhood dessert that my mom made called peanut butter delights.
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Ivan W.Verified
PB Paradise remain undefeated. I will say that the Pebbles and Cream surprised me. That cookie dough on it is underrated.
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Alexus B.Verified
The Brownies were delicious, not too sweet . Tastes more like a cake than brownie but it was still tasty. The portion sizes are huge and communication with the seller was amazing. 🩷 I’ll most likely try new flavors in the future.
Fantastic Four Pack
+2Tammy H.Verified
I loved the no bake bombs, and the peanut butter fudge brownie cups! We are the Biscoff brownie. And I have to say I did not care for that.The brownie was dry and not much taste. We also ate the PB temptation brownie. We like that one better. But I also thought that was a little dry too. The other 2 brownies are in the freezer for now. I am sure I will order again soon.
Order Protect
Kevin L.Verified
Great service, amazing taste on most of the brownies. Luscious Lou and cookies Monster were my favorite followed by the sugar almond. I look forward to next months box and hopefully the strawberry short cake brownie come back in the future as well as luscious Lou And Cookie Monster.
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
+1Julie B.Verified
Delish! Received this as a gift in December and have shared the wealth for Valentine’s Day with friends and family!
Order Protect
+1Nicole J.Verified
They are so addictive and good they have never let me down. If you have never tried them, run and not walk to order them!!
Join The Buckeye Club!
Katelyn M.Verified
So soft and sweet! Just as chocolatey as I expected and then some! Was able to split one with my son and he also loves them!
Oreo Cheesecake 4-Pack - November Flavor of the Month
Christian D.Verified
Ted: 10/10
PB: 9.5/10
Snick: 8.5/10
OG: 8/10
Thanks for the help whenever I submitted my address information wrong as well!
Build Your Box
+1Kimberly S.Verified
While the peanut butter and the smore's flavors were absolutely yummy the cookie and cream tasted more like a diet brownie, the flavor just wasn't great. It wasn't terrible just Not a sweet treat I was expecting.
The no-bake peanut butter bombs were absolutely delicious though!!
Build Your Box
Lea M.Verified
We order for staff pick me up. Everyone was able to find something they loved. Was fun trying each flavor.
Order Protect
Trisha K.Verified
Bigger then I expected, soooo good cookie monster was my favorite, just ordered a 4 pack of just cookie monster.. love them highly recommend 💓
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
+3Brianna S.Verified
9/10 I haven’t tried all flavors just yet but with the ones i did try, they were amazing! A tad bit on the sweet side but they are brownies. I recommend some milk with a warm piece right after dinner. Will buy from them again.
Order Protect
+1Heather C.Verified
These brownies are huge! Great flavors. Definitely a lot of sugar, but they are so large you can cut them into 4’s and they are still satisfying. Love the variety pack.
Black Friday Box
Daniel S.Verified
Best Blondies ever!! Can’t get enough of Cupid’s Cake..please make it year round..
Thanks, Daniel and Marion Shanle 😋
Build Your Box
Vernard D.Verified
Love it I had it for my bday gift which was July 1 it was very good and very peanut buttery.i will order again
Order Protect
Anton J.Verified
I had them once before but I can’t remember what they taste like but I plan to dig into these after my bodybuilding competition!!
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Casie Y.Verified
Customer service was amazing! When the box arrived we weren’t expecting it to be as heavy as it was. To us, we definitely feel like you’re getting your moneys worth. We can’t wait to see what other flavors they surprise us with!
Limited Edition September Pack
Chriszanne G.Verified
My initial order was cancelled because product ran out last week. However, it made it on time this week before Valentine’s Day!! I am very pleased!
Order Protect
Antoine W.Verified
I truly enjoyed all of the products I have purchased. And looking forward to all the new wonderful products coming soon.
Order Protect
Samantha B.Verified
This summer box was much better than the fantastic four. The hot fudge sundae is a little too sweet for me, which means it’s REALLY sweet. The chocolate on top is just a little much. Overall, my favorites are the strawberry cheesecake and the lemon. I thought the chocolate chip muffin one was a bit dry. I really wanna like these so bad, I’d love a thicker, higher quality brownie/blondie and less cookie dough. The thickness of the cookie dough makes the brownie extremely dense and a little bland....
Order Protect
+1David K.Verified
This was my second order and I was pleased with both these are good right out the box or warmed up.
Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
+4Lenin C.Verified
So good, especially heating them up and add some ice cream to it. I’m an Oreo person so i top the tuxedo as first.
Limited Edition September Pack
+1Kash B.Verified
i ordered the fantastic four pack and the valentine’s day special pack and so far the gift brownie is my favorite it taste like a huge sugar cookie with alot of sprinkles and oreos the vanilla ones i rate it like a 7 out of ten i still have so many brownies to try
Order Protect
Anele S.Verified
This might be a hot take, but the Very Cherry was my favorite! It all came in good; I put it in the freezer for, like, a month, and they were fine when I thawed them and ate them.
The only thing I wish is that the Peanut Butter S'mores had more peanut butter flavor to it.
Other than that, banger brownies.
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Brittany P.Verified
They shipped pretty quickly. Great products! Very tasty although they weren’t quite as ooey gooey as the ads, but still solid!
Order Protect
India E.Verified
Bought as a birthday gift for my brother and he really enjoyed them. I enjoy the build your own box and look forward to it.
Build Your Box
Danielle S.Verified
Got a box to share with the co workers. Loved the cupids cake but that peanut butter snores one spoke to us 10/10
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Florence V.Verified
The peanut butter s’mores was amazing!! By far my fav with the crispy caramelized chocolate base and pb cookie dough. The Nutella one sadly didn’t taste much like Nutella, more like almond. I liked the blondie bases alright, but I knew going into it Im more of a chocolatey than vanilla person. Order arrived quickly and in good condition.
Order Protect
Noah H.Verified
I gotta say, I really enjoyed this back to school brownie pack! My second time having Buckeye Brownies and you guys keep killing it everytime! 2-0! My favorite out of this entire box is definitely the Milk & Cookies brownie! It's like a giant cookie explosion in the best way possible! Imma definitely have to snag that Christmas pack when it drops for the holidays!
Order Protect
+2Myung J.Verified
I liked 3 out of 4 of the flavors and have 2 favs. I didn't like the cherry one. I'm very particular in cherry flavors and this was not it for me. The strawberry was good and had a good amount of strawberry flavor. The oreo (sorry i forget the actual flavor name) and pb smores were my favs. I don't like pb much and this one wasn't overwhelming with pb flavor. I love smores and oreo anything!! You can taste each flavor/ingredient and was so soft and chewy! Yum!
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
+1Nicole C.Verified
Sooooo good! I did not share ONE BITE with my husband lol. They stay moist, and they are SO GOOD!!!!! Will buy again!
Order Protect
+4Satyajit R.Verified
I bought the valentines pack. Shipping was fast. Out of all the brownies in the pack , my fav was pb& s’mores. 7.5/10. All other brownies were Cupid’s cake 7/10. Hella Nutella 7/10 & very cherry 6/10.
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Laura M.Verified
Was sent as a gift. She loved them, individually wrapped and easy to freeze and keep fresh. Super duper yummy and gooey! The buckeye brownie is insane!! We will order again!
Order Protect
Carol W.Verified
I loved each brownie. They are so delicious. I can hardly wait for my next order to arrive. I didn’t know that you might need pictures, and all of mine have been eaten.
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Bassir S.Verified
Great 4 out of the carnival cravings box my favorites has to be the churro caramel cream the and double trouble but besides that the entire limited edition line up was amazing especially oven heated, very much happy with the results and look forward to buying it again
Order Protect
Robin H.Verified
Good taste. My local usps held up delivery so not as fresh as they should have been. I would definitely try half pound brownies if I knew they were shipping through another service.
The Classics - Fudge Cups Bundle
Hali P.Verified
The ordering and delivery process was great and went smoothly. The flavors are delicious too. It seems like the brownie bases are missing something. I don’t know how to explain it, but like sugar or something wasn’t added so if you eat that part alone it’s just kind of bland. The Nutella one is my favorite! The Oreos mixed in made it crunchy and I’m obsessed!
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Darrin M.Verified
Absolutely DELICIOUS!!! So THICK and Decadent! 😜 "Grandma's Cobbler" (Blueberry) is my favorite piece!
The different samples are fine, but
I really wish that I could get a WHOLE pie of the "Cobbler."
Limited Edition Cheesecake Box
Michael G.Verified
Everyone was a hit. No complaints. Even for the prices it’s worth the hype. Can’t lie ima be adding some more stuff to my cart asap.
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store