Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Rhonda B.Verified

We sent several boxes as Christmas gifts to customers and friends. They all had great things to say about the brownies. They loved that it was different flavors in the box. Big enough to share with everyone. Customers service was excellent. Response time to emails was superb.

Add A Custom Note

Blake L.Verified

Everything tasted great. It arrived quickly and I am very happy with what I got. With that stated I am someone who has to watch my sugar intake and your products are something I can’t have a lot of. I’ll order again at some point but it may be a while.

Order Protect

Christine A.Verified

This was a Christmas gift for my daughter in law, whom is from Ohio. She still has family in the area, but only sees them occasionally. She absolutely loved receiving these!

Order Protect

Jason S.Verified

I would show pictures of the brownies but they didn't last long enough. Our favorites were definitely the Mr. Buckeye, Ted Velvet, and the Triple Berry Pie. They were so thick, rich, and delicious. The Buckeye Brownies are top notch!!

Order Protect

Jason S.Verified

Each brownie is exceptional , i try to pick a favorite which i do until i try another flavor then that becomes the new favorite. Highly recommend any and all products.

Order Protect

Customer photo review of The Gift 4-Pack

Heather Smith 1.Verified

This is a winner everytime I order it. Moist and tender. Perfect flavor. Beware though!! It is possible to eat the whole thing🥴

The Gift 4-Pack

Christian B.Verified

I was surprised on how well it held together being shipped, and I was very pleased with the flavors. My favorite was the campfire crunch I believe it was. Thank you so much for making this possible.

Order Protect

John P.Verified

These brownies are the bomb. So so good and they had the just right amount of sweetness that wasn't overwhelming like most brownies I've eaten in the past. They had the perfect moist to dry ratio in my opinion. The flavor was out of this world literally the butter finger one is my favorite and tasted exactly like what a butter finger brownie should taste like. Two thumbs up and 100 percent satisfied with my order. Will definitely buy more in the future. Thank you for the craftsmanship too the ...

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Customer video review of Limited Edition September Pack

Nery T.Verified

Loved it! Will def order again? Is it possible to get the Peanut Butter & Jealous as whole instead of a slice?! Soo so good!

Limited Edition September Pack

Susan H.Verified

One of my fav boxes! I really love the Pumpkin Crumb Cake and Terrifically Twix. Such great flavors. Appley Ever After was really good. I enjoyed eating that one too. Cookies and Dream was good and on the sweeter side. The Pumpkin Crumb and Appley Ever After taste great with a side of vanilla ice cream. Looking forward to the next box of flavors.

Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box

Mary H.Verified

Man oh man these brownies do not disappoint. They are huge! Flavor is on point. Popped it in the microwave for 30 seconds. They were so delicious. The Dark Knight was my favorite but just barely.

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

James R.Verified

Cookies and cream cups were excellent warmed up 15 seconds my Autistic son ate all three of them. I actually like the chocolate brownie base better the blonde brownie. But they are the best brownies I ever had. Can’t wait to I go see my family in Ohio I’m going to stop in and buy more. Thank you for making my little boy so happy. I talks using his iPad and said daddy more please. 😊😊👍🏼❤️

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Deborah W.Verified

The Brownies were delicious....especially when heated in the microwave for about 25 seconds. My husband was amazed at all the different layers of his favorite candies and cookies in them. Needless to say, the box didn't last long at our house. I would rate them a 10 out of 10....!!!

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Jose O.Verified

Awesome brownies! Got the MVP and Mr Buckeye! Eat it straight out of the box and it was amazing! Then put it in the microwave for like 12 seconds and game changer!!!!! Microwave ones with a glass of cold milk is a must!!!!

Pick Two

Melissa P.Verified

I have ordered three times, and my daughter's have really enjoyed them. I am a truck driver and live alot of my time on the road so I was hoping with my last order some would've been saved so I could try the brownies that they've raved about, but sadly 😥 no, they had no will power.

Order Protect

Susan H.Verified

Carnival Cravings Box - Loved: Buckeye Bombshell, Double Trouble, and Churro Caramel Cream. These were a perfect blend of each ingredient. I enjoyed every bite of them all. Ok - Circus Animal. The blondie base was great but the sugar topping was too much. It was a beautiful looking brownie - just way too much sweetness on top that I wound up picking off. I love these brownies and I'm looking forward to trying another 4 pack!

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

Susan K.Verified

We share our Buckeye Brownies with everyone and everyone loves each and everyone of them. Wish I had a Buckeye Brownies Store, I could sell them easily. I am a caregiver and we have meals at my work and I quite often take one or two 1/2 pound Brownies to share. We LOVE them.

Limited Edition November Box

Bernadette B.Verified

I'm always excited to open the box to see which brownies I ordered. The next thing I do is take each of them out of the bag and cut two edges off, taste them, then return the large piece to the more roomy bag.* I liked the one with the M&M's on the top best. It was an all-dark brownie and perfectly moist. What was that one called; I'll order them again.? *When my next box comes, if anyone is with me, I'll do a video showing how I open, unwrap, taste the brownie before I return the large piece ...

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

Jerry S.Verified

Honestly really great, My experience was a bit sour at first as my original order was missing but I contacted the owner and they made it right ASAP. The flavors were great but man the customer service is unheard of amazing business. My favorite was the MVP.

Fantastic Four Pack

Benjamin E.Verified

Purchased the original 4 pack of brownies after I had been eyeballing them for the last year. Recent hype on tiktok influenced me. The brownies arrived quickly, I was happy with shipping. Shared the brownies with my girlfriend. We followed the instructions and put them in the oven at 350 for 5 minutes, stored the rest in the fridge untill ready to eat. Flavors were great but disappointed that the brownies were dry.

Fantastic Four Pack

Denise L.Verified

The best my package was lost and I wrote the company and with no hesitation they sent me a new package thank you so much we will be ordering again

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

Sharon S.Verified

They were delicious and my grandchildren loved them with ice cream on top. My six year old loves the one with all the sprinkles. My favorite was the chocolate chip. Will certainly be ordering again. Thank you for a delicious experience

Order Protect

Erika K.Verified

Favorite of all 3 orders yet! Although your Sweetie Pie is only a seasonal item, I encourage you to extend that season- it's sublime & the best of all your flavors! Will be ordering again soon!

Build Your Box

Deborah B.Verified

The food was fresh and delicious as always. The no bake buckeye bombs are hands down, the BEST in the world!! They are my absolute favorite. Love your products, and the way they are packaged and received in a timely manner!!

Order Protect

Cale M.Verified

Absolutely love y’all’s brownies!! There needs to be a milk option lol, or ice cream!! Also , you guy’s seasonal brownies should be available year round if requested they are so good💕

Holiday Bundle Pack

Shelby G.Verified

THE best brownie of my life. Everything was perfect from chocolately goodness to the gooey marshmallowness and the crunch of the golden teddy. ABSOLUTE PERFECTION. There wasn't a bite that had me reconsidering, is this too much? No. PERFECTION. Its saying... BUY. BUY. BUY.

The Classics - S’mores Fudge Brownie Cups

Reninson M.Verified

Only tried the oreo brownie and split it with my brothers and we loved it a lot. Wasn’t too big of a fan for the sprinkles one but i still liked it. the rest i out away but i will 100% be going back to the snickerdoodle and peanut butter brownies down the road!

Fantastic Four Pack

Jonathan R.Verified

I always order my post show Buckeye brownies well in advance that way I know they will be there waiting for me at the finish line😏 I open my freezer each and every day (sometimes more than once) to gaze upon their beauty. I will feast here soon on Oct 4th and enjoy every bite, every crumb, and every finger lick that is acquired while consuming a Buckeye brownie

Order Protect

Anna G.Verified

It was better than I imagined they would be. All of the videos I saw, they looked so good. Mr. Buckeye was my favorite with the MVP being a close second. They were delicious right out of the box but even more so after being heated up. I can't say enough good things.

Fantastic Four Pack

Dewayne B.Verified

In a sense I was a little disappointed, since the brownies have regular cookies and pop tarts in them, heck it would of been better if buckeye had there own recipe for pop tarts and cookies they put inside there brownies, that's the only issue I had!!!

Order Protect

Anthony G.Verified

Buckeye Brownies are an excellent brownie well made and delicious can't say anything bad about them the company is also very good when I had a delivery problem Zach the owner got back to my complaint right away I highly recommend this company and their brownies

Order Protect

Kyle D.Verified

I bought your birthday bundle for my mom's birthday, and we're still eating them. They are so good. I think the Cookie Monster was my favorite, with the MVP being my 2nd favorite. They came shipped in tact, and very tasty. Thank you so much! :) - Kyle

Buckeye’s Birthday Bundle

Jamal A.Verified

Best Brownies Ever! The Snickerdoodle and Chill with the white chocolate was surprisingly my favorite and I am more of milk chocolate to dark chocolate type of guy. Will definitely buy from here again.

Fantastic Four Pack

Michael G.Verified

I had to mute the video because they were so good i slipped out a curse word while saying i finished the entire brownie in 1 sitting 😂😂 Top tier brownies. Best I've ever had

Order Protect

Mercardo Z.Verified

Exactly as advertised, delicious buckeye brownies, not too sweet and not too bland. They were by no mean "fresh" because of shipping (of course) but they were good, and they store easy as well. The size is also nice and definitely worth the price, will be buying again.

Order Protect

Mary H.Verified

First time ordering these brownies. They are delicious. They are also huge! I took them to an event with a group of friends. They all loved them! Everyone had a different favorite. It's nice that you get a variety of flavors in a box.

Order Protect

John S.Verified

The product arrived in perfect condition on time. I froze them for a few days and the ate The Gift first. I warmed it in the oven after defrosting and it was amazing! I was afraid it would be too rich and sweet but was pleasantly surprised when I took the first bite. Great mix of flavors and great texture. After eating the first brownie I went back to the website to order more.

Order Protect

Dominique G.Verified

I absolutely loved snickerdoodle and chill absolutely delicious and goes well with milk the MVP was a powerhouse of chocolate richness and crunchy Oreo goodness will definitely order some more another time 💖

Pick Two

Nicholas C.Verified

I'm more of a chocolate person. But I wanted to try something new. I was surprised that my favorite was the Churro one. It took me a few weeks to eat them all 😀. Kept some in the freezer while I had a brownie every week, sometimes two a week.

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

Maureen S.Verified

Sent as a gift and when I spoke with my friend she was beyond thrilled!! She was sooo happy and excited as she had guests from out of town and the brownies were a huge hit!!! She couldn’t say which was a favorite! Thank you!!

Order Protect

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store