Michael G.Verified
I had to mute the video because they were so good i slipped out a curse word while saying i finished the entire brownie in 1 sitting 😂😂
Top tier brownies. Best I've ever had
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Order Protect
Dominique G.Verified
I absolutely loved snickerdoodle and chill absolutely delicious and goes well with milk the MVP was a powerhouse of chocolate richness and crunchy Oreo goodness will definitely order some more another time 💖
Pick Two
Nicholas C.Verified
I'm more of a chocolate person. But I wanted to try something new.
I was surprised that my favorite was the Churro one.
It took me a few weeks to eat them all 😀. Kept some in the freezer while I had a brownie every week, sometimes two a week.
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Julie M.Verified
The dark night is by far my favorite, but each brownie is amazing sooo. I tried hiding it from husband and he found then :(. Oh well, I guess I will have to order more.
Order Protect
Maureen S.Verified
Sent as a gift and when I spoke with my friend she was beyond thrilled!! She was sooo happy and excited as she had guests from out of town and the brownies were a huge hit!!! She couldn’t say which was a favorite! Thank you!!
Order Protect
Mark H.Verified
We all loved the brownies! Wish you had sent this request before today because they are all gone. No pics or video possible. We thought the Oreo would have been our favorite but, the sprinkle was first, snickerdoodle second, peanut butter was third. They survived the trip to Arkansas, box was slightly crushed but the product was ok. We will order again. The crunchy strawberry looks good!
Fantastic Four Pack
Sasha G.Verified
I loved every one of the brownies I received and they came out great when I microwaved them while they were covered with a damp paper towel to add moisture.
Order Protect
Christopher T.Verified
The experience bundle absolutely blew my mind into orbit. Crazy delicious treats at maximum freshness. The owner kindly timed the shipping so that the goodies arrived on the day of my debut bodybuilding show. Absolutely murdered them afterwards. 10/10 experience which I will repeat in a few weeks.
The Experience Bundle
Brooke G.Verified
The brownies were moist and fresh and very flavorful...they were a big hit at work too! My order ended up being returned to sender for some odd reason but customer service quickly took care of it and sent out a new order very quickly
Fantastic Four Pack
Melissa T.Verified
The brownies are super huge and so good. I was excited to see that you can freeze these, so I left 2 out and popped 2 in the freezer so we can have them at a later date. I will definitely order again
Order Protect
Erica P.Verified
I have no pictures or videos to show cuz me and my 15 yr old devoured them. They were delicious. I had commented on a tiktok post that I was getting them for my bday instead of a cake. Shout out to Zach for sending me a 15% off coupon for my bday. Excellent company
Order Protect
Kevin M.Verified
Buckeye Brownies were delicious... we had the animal cracker brownie pack and shared it with my family. They loved it and so did I.
Was a great thing to look forward to at dinner and chat about with family. Enjoyed every moment!
Order Protect
Sherry W.Verified
your brownies are delicious. so moist and just 1 or 2 bites is all you need to satisfy your craving. Gave some to my son and daughter-in-law and they went crazy for them. will definitely order more.
Order Protect
Deborah B.Verified
The Mr. Buckeye was my mom’s favorite, and she literally HATES peanut butter cookies or baked goods. It was so good, it literally won her over. She told me to order a box of just those.
Build Your Box
Amanda M.Verified
So delicious! Strawberry cheesecake was the best, of course. Churro was next best. Lemon could have been stronger, but that’s my taste buds. I’m very tempted to get all strawberry cheesecake next order
Build Your Box
Brian S.Verified
I ordered brownies and these. Brownies were overrated but these were not. Soooo good! Will definitely be ordering more of these and likely will order for client events too! So good!
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
Avery B.Verified
I can’t even give you guys pictures to get the discount me and my friends ate them up🤣, they were so good each flavor was amazing in its own way and i couldn’t even imagine how you guys came up with these flavors i will be buying again my trainer is upset bc i was supposed to cut back on my sweets but i do not care with these brownies they were just amazing 10 stars all across the board
Order Protect
Legina S.Verified
I waited to receive them, when they finally came in I was excited to open it, those brownies were big so I shared them with my sister, some she wasn't impressed with only like two of them, when I finally got a chance to try them I went to the snickerdoodle one and oh my goodness very tasty and moist, next I tried the oreo one I wasn't impressed with that one, then the nutterbutter one, it was ok,the last one was the sprinkle one also very tasty, didn't receive my free ones I used the FREEBROWNIE...
Order Protect
Susan K.Verified
We enjoy our Buckeye Brownies. Being that we are both Diabetic we need to be careful. My wish is that O could indulge daily. I work as a caregiver and we have a lunch a couple times a week so I share my Buckeye Brownies. Everyone loves them.
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Michael L.Verified
My son and his college roomates absolutely loved the brownies and cups. What a great care package to.send when your college student misses home. They were fresh and a hit with all the guys!
Order Protect
Beth B.Verified
These are the most DELICIOUS brownies I have ever tasted!!! The flavors are so creative and unique ... they are truly one-of-a-kind!!! I've ordered from Buckeye Brownies several times and they always arrive in perfect condition ... and they NEVER disappoint!! I have tried them both fresh and after being frozen for a few months ... and either way, I can't think of one bakery that even comes CLOSE to this kind of ooey, gooey goodness!!!
Build Your Box
Veronica W.Verified
All of the brownies are delicious 😋 I love how moist and chewing they are. My favorite is the one that has Almonds in it. You should bring that flavor back.I want more!😍🤩
Limited Edition Black Friday Box
Andrew W.Verified
This is my FAVORITE flavor. Something about Apple crisp on a blondie just works so well. A few minutes in the oven and I could eat a 4 pack in 1 sitting.
Appley Ever After 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 10/28
Karen S.Verified
I ordered the Buckeye Brownies for my better half. He has been talking about them since seeing them on Instagram. Build a box is great as you can pick 4 brownies of your choice. He loved them. He was in brownie heaven. I don't like brownies but these were good. I utilized the rush baking as I waited til the last minute. They were here before I expected. The customer service was great. I really appreciate the company caring about my order and my satisfaction.
Build Your Box
Heaven L.Verified
Absolutely shareable at 1/2 a pound! Flavor throughout the entire brownie and heated up for less than 20 seconds was epic flavor bomb!! Will be ordering more, and the Oreo brownies just wow!!
Order Protect
Gwen M.Verified
This was my second order from Buckeye Brownies, so I knew what awaited me. I loved the pumpkin and apple brownies the best, but Twix and Oreo were great too. I shared them with a friend who called them delectable!
Order Protect
Susan H.Verified
Love the S'Mores Brownie cups!!
The chocolate was one of the best I've ever had. It had such a creamy taste to it. It tasted like condensed milk or cream was blended with the chocolate. I could just eat a bowl of it alone. This is a brownie that I wish was permanent in the store.
The Classics - S’mores Fudge Brownie Cups
Antoine L.Verified
I wish the S'mores Fudge Cups didn't have to go away just like the Campfire Crunch Brownies do, but I totally get it.
The S'mores Fudge Cups (just like Campfire Crunch Brownies) are an imstant hit and I can't wait until the S'mores Fudge Cups come back some day soon.
Maybe Buckeye Brownies will offer a deal one day bringing back the S'mores Fudge Cups and OG Campfire Crunch at the same time and offering up a package deal called "S'mores At Your Door" and get both 1 3-pack S'mores Fudge Cup and...
Order Protect
Chester V.Verified
I’m really sorry but these were not nearly as good as they looked. Very doughy, dry, and bland. Some of the flavors didn’t even work together. Hopefully it was just an unfortunate set.
Order Protect
Xavier B.Verified
First time trying out Buckeye Brownies and I'll definitely be getting another box. I got the Pumpkin Pie, Dark Night, Apple Pie, and the Twix flavors. My favorite had to be the Dark Night! I would absolutely recommend these brownies to friends and family!
Build Your Box
Antoine L.Verified
The S'mores Fudge Cups are the both the best and second best thing to come out since the OG Campfire Crunch 1/2lb brownies.
I wish the S'mores Cups would remain permanent, just like I feel the same way about the OG Campfire Crunch, but I get it. Buckeye Brownies has to keep the options open and bring new stuff and it's not like The S'mores Cups (just like Campfire Crunch) won't make a comeback because I have no doubts it will.
Anything S'mores related will forever be number one.
The Classics - S’mores Fudge Brownie Cups
Ruth H.Verified
My order came in perfect. Plus my free cookies. I’m using mine on Christmas platters this year. My Grandson are gonna love them. I’m freezing mine until closer to Christmas. However I did slide mine in freezer bags for extra protection. It took everything I had not to grab a bite. ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Order Protect
Alan G.Verified
The brownies came fast and like a brownie should look and feel. This was not my favorite flavors this time around. My favorite so far are from the forth of July mix.
I would still recommend theses though.
Order Protect
Dennis S.Verified
I was introduced to your brownies at one of Dave Leibermans shows. I have bought some for myself and sent a care package to my daughter who is away in college.
We both love them!
Order Protect
Noah H.Verified
I gotta say, I really enjoyed this back to school brownie pack! My second time having Buckeye Brownies and you guys keep killing it everytime! 2-0! My favorite out of this entire box is definitely the Milk & Cookies brownie! It's like a giant cookie explosion in the best way possible! Imma definitely have to snag that Christmas pack when it drops for the holidays!
Limited Edition Back To School Box
K H.Verified
Mr. Buckeye will probably always be my favorite but the Churro brownie was to die for and I'm glad to see it is offered again on this month's Build a Box. The only complaint was that the white topping all fell off immediately when unwrapping.
Build Your Box
Eric L.Verified
I opened my box and it smelled so good. It was great condition and tasted delicious. I still have a couple left. Also there so big I did not expect that.
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
Jacob D.Verified
Brownies were delicious. I live 500 miles from where they're made, and popped em in the microwave for a few seconds and they were perfectly ooey-gooey delicious brownies. My expectations were admittedly a little too high, but still nearly met! The only downside with shipped brownies is there's no way to guarantee they're super fresh. Mine were good, but can't guarantee with shipping that all will be that way!
Limited Edition Black Friday Box
Justin K.Verified
The no bake peanut butter cup cookies are SO GOOD. Warm them up in the microwave for like 20sec and then let them stand for a minute or two and they’re so gooey and delicious. Love these.
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Lacey K.Verified
Long time customer. The brownies freeze well so I just heat one up when the craving hits. Worth every single penny! Tried at a bodybuilding competition years ago and have been addicted ever since.
Order Protect
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store