Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Visit store
Debi B.Verified
The sweets came in perfect condition. Delicious, soft, and perfect. We cut them into fourths and put 3/4 of each in the freezer. Then we split the last 1/4 of each between the 2 of us over the next few days. I gotta tell you - they were SO good and plenty to share. My favorite was the strawberry cheesecake. I will be buying more!
Limited Edition Summer Celebration Box
Ashley H.Verified
I send my friend a sweet present every year over Christmas. I decided to send Buckeye Brownies to her and her husband. My friend loved the treat because it was a cross between a cookie and brownie ( texture wise). I will definitely buy Buckeye brownies in the future.
Pick Two
Connie D.Verified
The taste was out of this world 🌎. I am hooked on these and have ordered more. Two boxes more plus your delicious brownies. I’m giving it few away at Christmas but I’m choosing my best flavors for me. So mouth watering. Love these a lot.
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Lisa M.Verified
These brownies are the best!!! I can't wait to order again. I can't take a photo or video because they are long gone before the survey came out. Thank you!
Order Protect
Larry P.Verified
I certainly enjoy your brownies! I’m thinking this is my 4th order. I share with my friends and they rave about them and have gone on to order for themselves!
Build Your Box
Marisa W.Verified
I get these and freeze them. So easy to cut smaller pieces and enjoy them a bit at a time. They are huge! Always an interesting combo of flavors. I like the fruit flavors and unusual flavors the best.
Limited Edition Summer Celebration Box
Jody S.Verified
I kept seeing advertisements for buckeye brownies on instagram and it got the best of me. They looked amazing. The order took a week to ship( they are made fresh to order so no brownies are sitting in store somewhere) and arrived the next the day. These things did not disappoint. They are huge! Each brownie is individually wrapped so no worries about them drying out. You can keep them in the fridge for a week or freeze them for three weeks. You can heat them up in the microwave, heat them in th...
Order Protect
Dexter V.Verified
Im not sure why im rating order protect, but im assuming this is my second order i got for my gluten free wife. She loved the flavors but wishes there were more to choose from. Funfetti was her favorite
Order Protect
Patricia F.Verified
Sent to my sister for her Birthday. She was thrilled, said they are delicious!!! Thank you and everyone involved Wishing all a very Happy healthy and safe Holidays Stay safe Patti F
Order Protect
Adam A.Verified
My wife and I loved your brownies! Great flavor and texture. My favorite is the Fruity Pebble one any wife’s favorite is PB Chocolate. We will definitely be ordering more.
Order Protect
Pat M.Verified
Thought I had died and gone to heaven. The taste , texture and smell of these brownies were out of this world. I microwaved mine and they were so warm gooey and delicious . The brownies are my cheat treat .
Terrifically Twix 4-Pack - January Flavor of the Month
Cameron C.Verified
The brownies were a bit more on the “dry” side.. I’m not for sure if it was due to it being possibly a mixture of cake batter ? Or maybe a little overcooked. I was expecting more of a “fudge like texture” to it. The complementary Oreo fudge cups were absolutely delicious though! They were definitely gooey!
Order Protect
Daniel Dehoff D.Verified
I've only eaten 2 of them cause they are so big' but the 2 i have eaten were incredibly delicious especially warmed up and with some vanilla ice cream and I can't wait to try the churro and fruity peeble ones! I will definitely be ordering some more from this site!
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Christopher R.Verified
This is by far my favorite box. Even my "least" favorite of this box is still amazing. The gooeyness of the centers are particularly noteworthy. You won't regret this box.
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Christopher H.Verified
Loved my order! My only problem was that the brownies are so rich that I knew I would get in trouble with a sugar overload if I didn't share them, so I shared them with my family members :) Everyone really enjoyed them.
Build Your Box
Savannah C.Verified
I LOVE these brownies! I keep them in the freezer and whenever I need a sweet treat I pull them out and let them thaw and they are just like they are fresh! They are soooo gooey and delicious!!
Build Your Box
Errol K.Verified
ABSOLUTELY LOVE the cookies. My first encounter with the brownies was not good, because I'm a texture person. Warming them for about 20-30 seconds changed that/ But the show stopper for me were the peanut butter cup brownies. Mom absollutely loves those. I'm a repeat customer for sure
The Experience Bundle
Erica S.Verified
the back to school box was to die for!!! the cosmic brownie warmed up brought back my childhood days and mixed with vanilla ice cream….my oh my 😍 love these brownies! 10/10 recommend and the customer service is outstanding always. very responsive and attentive to detail / orders. they make each bach with TLC .
Order Protect
Catherine C.Verified
This last box two of the brownies were very dry. Occasionally this happens but not to the degree of the strawberry and pecan one we got. Even though they were warmed up it didn’t help. Otherwise was good!
Order Protect
Bryan S.Verified
What a good flavor!! I hope they make this flavor again. One of my favorites FORSURE! Good brownies all around, you can’t go wrong, but this one is *Chefs kiss*.
Magical Mint 4-Pack - December Flavor of the Month
Debra T.Verified
They were very well packaged and moist. Pretty designed and tasty. You can’t eat one in a single sitting. Will be ordering again, need to try more flavors especially red velvet.
Order Protect
Lesley M.Verified
Absolutely loved the circus animal brownie, it was absolutely elite - it should be a regular flavor. The cookies monster is solid, we’ve had it once before so knew it was a good choice. I really liked the double trouble and buckeye bombshell too, usually we really like 2 of the brownies and the other 2 are just okay but this whole box was fire. We loved these flavors!
Order Protect
Veronica B.Verified
They arrived in perfect condition. My husband thoroughly enjoys them. To me they don’t taste like a brownies at all and super duper sweet way too sweet for me. It was a gift and he loved them.
Order Protect
Dawn M.Verified
Wow, just wow. These brownies were so good. I love that you have different boxes, so you can try different varieties at one time. HUGE, these are super thick, but moist.
Order Protect
Janna J.Verified
Absolutely LOVED this limited edition box for November! I originally came across it from people reviewing it online, and oh my goodness it had every brownie/brookie flavor I'd ever dreamed of. Great out of the package, phenomenal when warmed up. Each bite hit me with nostalgia, and that's really what I want in a dessert! Amazing, would definitely order more if I wasn't trying to diet LOL
Limited Edition November Box
Jerry S.Verified
Honestly really great, My experience was a bit sour at first as my original order was missing but I contacted the owner and they made it right ASAP. The flavors were great but man the customer service is unheard of amazing business.
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Robert S.Verified
I am very pleased with the service and the quality. There was an error and with a quick response they resolved it quickly and made it right. Very happy with the taste and presentation of these brownies. I will absolutely be buying plenty more for them. Thanks so much buckeyebrownies.
Santa’s Surprise Bundle
Tina M.Verified
All of the brownies were good but my family and I personally loved the animal cracker cookie brownie.Absolutely delicious with the right amount of sweetness. There was a good balance going on because you didn’t just taste pure sugar, it was just right.
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Michael D.Verified
Omg they were so good, put them in the microwave for about 20-25 seconds and they come out so soft and chewy. I will be ordering these again! Thank you Michael Daniels
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Alice B.Verified
My order arrived yesterday!!! Yea !!! I opened it and was amazed. My friend and I had one of the brownes the one with the oreo. I am sure the rest are also good. It will be a while before I finish them. There amazing and delicious.
Order Protect
Cindy G.Verified
The brownies are the best gift for anyone. This is what I do for gifts. The one box goes to my son in the UK. I believe this is my3rd year. THANK YOU
Build Your Box
Alberto S.Verified
I average an order of 1 box of Buckeye Brownies every 4 to 6 weeks wish I could 2 boxes a month they are that good but I'd blow my diet. Otherwise the Brownies are so good my mouth waters like Pavlovs dogs / a psychology reference to learned behavior when I see the ads on social media as I love Buckeye Brownies. And the owner Zack is a great guy as I've met him at some bodybuilding events I've participated in.
Build Your Box
Brad H.Verified
Great presentation and portion size and delicious! I do not eat sweets often but there was a video on FB about the Berry/4th of July Box and was so excited to get it! Brad H
Order Protect
Bradley G.Verified
The reeses cup brownies were very good. They are good if you eat them straight from the package but better if you heat them up for about 10-15 seconds. I recommend everyone try them.
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
Jeanne P.Verified
Don’t even think about eating it without heating it up! This is the most delicious brownie I’ve ever had!!! One brownie has been my and my husband’s dessert 2 nights in a row! This lasts a long time (or at least it should😂)
Order Protect
Natalie V.Verified
PB Paradise and Butterfinger were absolutely delicious! Sorry, I ate immediately and didn't think to take a picture first. Sorry. Thicker than a Snicker is in the freezer; it will be a birthday surprise for my husband. The Dark Knight is also being saved for a later date. I bought these last year and loved them. So, I had to purchase again. Thank you.
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Harold T.Verified
Overall very good. The coffee cake brownie tasted more like a coffee cake than a coffee cake does. excellent! The chocolate Oreo brownie was quite decadent, also excellent! The strawberry shortcake was the only one that fell a bit short🥹 I was actually most looking forward to the strawberry shortcake, brownie so that was a little disappointing. I will definitely order again in the future, cake being my drug of choice🤙
Build Your Box
Quinton H.Verified
I am from Columbus, Ohio born and raised! Ever since I heard about Buckeye Brownies via Instagram….I NEEDED TO HAVE THESE BROWNIES! I purchase Brownie s from them every three or four months and give them to my coworkers who fell in love! My one co worker she LOVES AND CRAVES the SNICKERDOODLE AND BISCOFF BROWNIES!!! She drinks them with coffee and sits on her balcony!
Rush Baking
Rasha A.Verified
Hi Buckeye Brownies team, I wanted to share some feedback about a few flavors I recently tried! The Pumpkin Crumb Cake wasn’t really my favorite — it was a bit too thick and didn’t have much flavor. The Apple-y Ever After was okay, just not quite to my taste. On the other hand, the Cookies & Cream was definitely my favorite! I just wish it had more Oreo crumbs mixed on the inside rather than mostly on top. The Terrific Twix was also really good — I just wished I could taste a bit more of the ...
Rush Baking
Lawrence H.Verified
My fiance and I ate them all before we go the review email so there’s no pictures or videos, but we liked them all. I LOVED The Gift and he LOVED the Buckeye. We are going to order more so we can try all the flavors 😃
Rush Baking
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store