Lisa F.Verified
All the Brownies were good! Gifted a couple to my daughter; she loved them also! Fast delivery, packed nice and they tasted delicious! Eat warmed up or straight out of package! Make a very nice gift for someone!
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Order Protect
Daniel S.Verified
Loved all the fall flavors! The brownies were huge lol so i was able to share some with my parents and brother. Thanks for a great product 🤙Keep up the good work and God bless 🙏
Order Protect
Anne S.Verified
There’s just so much cookie butter and Biscoff. It’s amazing. I’ve had to very jealously guard them. My brother, who is not a big sweets consumer, said he could eat a whole brownie after I shared part of one with him.
The Ultimate Biscoff Bundle
Kathy P.Verified
There's nothing like being able to pick your own mega-huge brownies. The first time I ordered, I got a company-selected batch. Since I'm a chocoholic, I wasn't too pleased with some of their choices. So, I built my own order the second time and got plenty of chocolate. Now I'm happy 😊.
Build Your Box
Jodi M.Verified
These were delicious. Very rich so paired well with vanilla ice cream 🍨. Heat them up in the microwave for 20 seconds- and you will have a heavenly experience. 🥰
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Christopher M.Verified
One of best brownies I've ordered online! Recieved them, threw them in the air fryer for 5 mins...was like they were fresh out the oven. The Mr. Buckeye brownie made me rethink life choices it was that good!
Build Your Box
Keith J.Verified
I would send some pictures but I ate it already. It was delicious and every bit as good as the pictures. I will order it again and highly recommend it! YUM!😋
Terrifically Twix 4-Pack - January Flavor of the Month
Miranda B.Verified
Ordered and had sent to my work. Cut in to smaller pieces and shared with my entire shop. The guys loved trying a new flavor each day. Definitely a great pick me up for the day when everyone is ready to go home and put the tools up for the day.
Fantastic Four Pack
Heather S.Verified
I cannot even begin to explain how delicious and how perfect all of our goodies were. I can’t wait to order again. The brownies were scrumptious. The cookies were delicious. They were packaged perfectly, and the presentation was amazing!
Holiday Bundle Pack
Lacey Y.Verified
Delicious but just a ton of brownies. Would be perfect for a party or teenage sleepover!! I ordered them for me but ended up having to share because of the massive amount of deliciousness. 10/10 would definitely recommend!
Order Protect
Leonard T.Verified
The brownies are delicious. Rich but delicious. One of them is enough for four people. 😂 I’ve put the rest in my freezer to enjoy at a later date, probably after dinner with friends so I can introduce them to this decadent treat!
Order Protect
Timothy S.Verified
They were delicious unfortunately I did not take photos before we ate them. The arrived in a good amount of time. I personally loved the one with the fruity pebbles and strawberry pop tarts, my wife really loved the churro one and the Cookie Monster and PB Paradise were really good. I will post pictures next time we order
Order Protect
Travis S.Verified
Brownies were fantastic as were the peanut butter cookies. Highly recommend. Pro tip: Keep the brownies in the fridge or freezer for a couple of days for the flavors to develop more.
Perfectly Peanut Butter Cookies
Donna F.Verified
Sent an order to some friends for a Christmas present, I accidentally chose the shipping to my own address and as soon as I emailed Buckeye informing them of my error, they responded within minutes and corrected my mistake! Talk about excellent customer service! My friends who received the goodies LOVED them as well!
Order Protect
Patricia L.Verified
The free brownies were amazing!!!! The flavor. The everything!!! But unfortunately the 4voack of brownies I ordered I did not like. Especially the pop tart one. I still have 1 big brownie that I froze. But if I order again I will definitely just order the free brownies that were sent to me. Those were unbelievable!!
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Timothy M.Verified
You better keep appley ever after in the line up if you know what’s good for you, kapeesh? and my biscoff was definitely buttered. Will order again, I love you.
Build Your Box
Dawn M.Verified
This was a great box. It did not last long, but the variety was great for the family. These will be fun for a ice cream and brownie bar. I will definitely try another box soon, especially since the super bowl is coming up.
Limited Edition New Year’s Surprise Box
Luis S.Verified
Each brownie I got was absolutely delicious. I brought 1 to work and decided to share it with my coworkers and they all loved it. Would definitely by again if I wasn’t currently trying to diet.
Build Your Box
Diego M.Verified
What’s not to love about Buckeye brownies?! Seriously. I love every brownie I’ve ever tried from them. My most recent order was their Fall Favorites box. I didn’t have one favorite over the other. They all were unique and delicious in their own ways. But if they really want me to choose the coolest brownie from that pack, it was the Twix one. Goodness, the crushed Twix pieces scattered throughout the top of the brownie really hit the spot! I look forward to getting from Buckeye brownies again in...
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Sarah S.Verified
They worked with me on a short time table and allowed me to pick up at the shop rather than waiting for shipping. They were timely and kind and the brownies were great.
Order Protect
Isaac A.Verified
Bought some brownies as a gift for my Wife and Daughter that have to eat gluten free. I would have attached a picture but they were gone quicker than an unattended dollar bill! I couldn’t believe how delicious it was for being gluten free, usually gluten free tastes like chalk on cardboard but these brownies were as good as, well brownies! I got the meat sweats just looking at how delicious they looked in the box the drool was flowing from my mouth and then the taste exploded!!!!! Made me feel l...
Gluten Free Box
Gregory S.Verified
The holiday pack brownies might be the main character, but cookies and cream fudge brownie cups are the star of the show in my opinion! All of it is just delicious! Will return to try another pack again!
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Jennifer W.Verified
It took it awhile to arrive, so I didn't get them in time for Christmas, but my husband really enjoyed them. The brownies where really big and dense. The chocolate based ones were really sweet. I could only handle a little piece before getting sugered out. The blond based ones were my favorite. I could taste little notes of the different flavors that was in it. Overall a very tasty treat.
Fantastic Four Pack
Chelsea M.Verified
This was my first time ordering. We really enjoyed all the brownies though we all agreed that Thicker than a Snicker didn't quite taste like a snickers. It had a heavier nutty flavor. Still, we were happy with what we got. Butterfinger was my favorite. My kids loved the dark knight. I'm hoping to try Twix (my favorite candy bar) but I think I saw it was just a temporary flavor? I saw a strawberry crunch one for November. We plan on trying that.
Order Protect
Jennifer M.Verified
I appreciated the option for rush baking & shipping so my order arrived in time for a birthday celebration. The 4 pack box is very neat and contains instructions on how to store the brownies. Each brownie comes individually packaged in a clear, resealable plastic slip that displays each flavor nicely. Brownies were substantial & very delicious.! Definitely meant for sharing or enjoying small bites over time.
Rush Baking
Brando F.Verified
All the Brownies tasted phenomenal. Favorite was definitely the Buckeye because I'm a huge fan of Reeses and peanut butter. Just ordered a costumized order of Brownies from you guys! And I can't wait to try them!! Thank you guys so much for all you do!! Keep it up!! 😊❤️
Fantastic Four Pack
James W.Verified
No Bake Buckeye Bombs deliver exactly what you want from a quick, indulgent treat. The classic peanut‑butter‑and‑chocolate combo is rich without being overwhelming, and the no‑bake method keeps things wonderfully simple. The texture hits that sweet spot between creamy and fudgy, and they hold their shape well despite the soft center. If you’re looking for a fast dessert that feels homemade and decadent with minimal effort, these are an easy win.
Order Protect
Sean S.Verified
This was my second time ordering from Buckeye brownies, this time I ordered the cookies and of course the brownies again as well!!! Delicious and will continue to order from Buckeye brownies! They always deliver with care and on time!
Order Protect
Pat M.Verified
I don’t know how you do it but it just gets more delicious each order just when I think you’ve done the best you surprise me with another outstanding brownie way to go Buckeyes
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Michael J.Verified
My order arrived just in time for the holidays and everyone loved the brownies. The Buckeye Bombs were a big hit as well. Will definitely order again in the future.
Order Protect
Laurie U.Verified
The round chocolate brownie cups were the best of all the brownies! The squares were okay with the peanut butter and orea brownies the best of the four. I ordered 6 more of the round brownie cups!
Order Protect
Laurel C.Verified
Ok so my family at first were not sure of these brownies we followed all
Of the directions but still I was the only one happy. So now I warm them for a longer: till you can see the frosting or sugar if anyone top start to remelt. Ok now they are all on board and want more we will be ordering more for sure
Order Protect
Sherry R.Verified
Amazing brownies! Gave to my son for a Birthday Gift. Packaging was perfect for a long trip to Cali., they even arrived two days earlier than expected. Good experience with Buckeye Brownies, thank you!!😊
Order Protect
Sam M.Verified
These are maybe the best dessert I have ever had in my entire life. Bought extra boxes just to gift them to friends and family. 5 stars. 2 thumbs up. 100% rotten tomatoes. Dentists agree? These are the best brownies (cakes/cookies?) ever made! | laughed. I cried. I probably gained weight? Seriously though these are ridiculously good. If you're a cookies and cream person, Just add them to your cart. Do it. You will not be disappointed
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Geri G.Verified
The brownies came packaged well the flavor was amazing at every single one and I enjoyed him thoroughly. I had a stroke in July and this is the only thing that taste good since then thank you very much.
Order Protect
Jordan M.Verified
I got these brownies for my boyfriend, and we both ended up really liking them! Definitely took a few days to finish eating only one of them, but very delicious and stayed fresh in the freezer.
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Everette M.Verified
Really enjoyed the brownies! My least favorite unfortunately was the Appley Ever After. Didn’t get a lot of apple. Kind of dry. But it’s my fault because I should’ve warmed it up. Probably would have a different experience. Overall, I give the Fall line up an 8 out of 10. Excellent!
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Buffy N.Verified
Brownies were exactly as described! Very soft and delicious. I cut them into fourths and ate a 1/4 at a time. I heated it for about 20 - 30 seconds and it was warm and gooey and like heaven.
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Marissya D.Verified
The order came well packaged and there was SO much! Everything has been delicious, and I’m thankful for the heating instructions they provide so we knew how to best warm some of these up! I had to email their customer support as well and they responded quickly and helped with my questions!
Order Protect
Amy G.Verified
This company goes above and beyond to make sure you get exactly what you ordered. For me even getting the wrong shipping address, they made sure I got what I ordered and fast delivery. Brownies are amazing and worth the money. Go try it yourself.
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store