Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Visit store
Janna J.Verified
The Fudge Brownie Cups were an amazing addition to an already amazing limited month box! I personally found them to be a bit heavy for my liking, but the rich, chocolatey goodness and that lava-cake like flavor will be a total hit for anyone who is into desserts like that. I also got really lucky and managed to get these for free from a promo code, which I'm really appreciative about!
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Christian D.Verified
Overall the dark knight is my new favorite, the gift is a 9/10, snickerdoodle is a 8/10, the cookies and dream is a 8.5/10, but that dark knight, that dark knight is something else, ♾️/10
Build Your Box
David S.Verified
Loved every single of the brownie 4 pack,so much so that I bought the same 4 pack over again.And just received the Mint Chocolate brownies yesterday.I ate one eight out the box,put it in the microwave to warm it up,2 minutes later,all gone,yummy.Nexr time I'm putting some Vanilla Ice Cream on it Oh,I also received the fudge brownie cups for free,ate one,very delicious,I gave the rest to friends who really liked them,and said they would place an order in the near future from Buckeye Brownies.Over...
Fantastic Four Pack
Gregory G.Verified
The cookies were nicely packed and none were broken when I opened the package. The brownies were in excellent condition when I opened those packages. And the flavor and consistency was exquisite.
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
Elizabeth R.Verified
The brownies were great but I enjoyed The Classics the most probably because they were smaller. Overall, both were very tasty and I will buy again (against my better judgement (calories)).
Order Protect
Dominique G.Verified
Some mailing issues but not the stores fault they were delicious me and my coworkers tore into them like animals lol nonetheless again very satisfied and can't wait to put in another order I hope you guys do a Christmas themed box when it comes around
Order Protect
George C.Verified
Many questions on these brownies on if they are worth trying an online brownie, well they are well worth ordering. My friends and family enjoyed all of them but the pumpkin and mvp was a huge hit.
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Ben V.Verified
Order often! I have EOE, a literal whey allergy. These brownies are amaaaaaazing!!!!!!!! Nothing else out there like the Buckeye vegan brownies!!!!!! I share them with my friends and they love them too!!!!!!
Order Protect
Gregory G.Verified
When my order arrived I couldn't wait to taste them. I thought they are the best cookies and brownies I ever tasted. I will definitely be reordering again in the future.
Order Protect
Jordan F.Verified
Great brownies. Great Experience. The difference in each brownie is awesome. It would definitely be a great holiday or birthday present. Was worried the quality would dwindle from shipping, glad I was wrong. 10/10
Limited Edition Back To School Box
Jennifer L.Verified
I rarely write reviews but I feel like I have to say something about these brownies! They are all flavorful without being overly sweet. My favorites in this box are the Campfire Crunch and Strawberry Crunch Cake. This was the second box I’ve ordered and they haven’t disappointed! Will definitely be ordering more flavors in the future!
Limited Edition November Box
Kevin W.Verified
I’m in a cut right now getting ready to be shredded for Halloween, but at the end of my last cut I ordered these and crushed one immediately it was so fantastic and everything I needed and hoped for t minus 25 days until that Twix brownie is my victim.
Order Protect
Chris C.Verified
The brownies were so amazing that I realized I need an accountability partner to help me pace myself with the following order, instead of finishing the entire box in one weekend. I'm missing those brownies like a '90s R&B song reminiscing about someone special.
Order Protect
Shanna M.Verified
This was my favorite out of a limited-edition variety pack. I was so grateful they had a four pack! S'mores are my favorite, and the peanut butter texture was perfect for it.
Peanut Butter S’mores 4-Pack - July Flavor of the Month
Dale C.Verified
The delivery was flawless. Communication was excellent when I called for clarification. The staff put me at ease. Now… onto the brownies. I got one of each and they were devoured by my. Crowd of 30. I have a sweet spot for Ohio because my son and daughter in law went and met there. Now I have another SWEET SPOT for Buckeye brownies. Go Bucks and go Buckeye Brownies
Order Protect
Moises C.Verified
Third pack I've gotten from you guys.. And me and my family just love them!!! Ofcourse we each have our different opinions on which one is the best out of the pack, but regardless, they're always a hit!!! Definitely ain't our last pack.. & we can't wait to see what the following months will bring! 10/10, 4 stars, 2 thumbs way up!!
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Cornelius P.Verified
Everything was perfect. I really enjoyed the biggest brownies I have ever seen and eaten in my life! I really enjoyed Triple Berry Pie and Crazy Caramel Pecan. Campfire Crunch and Peanut Butter Perfection were great but those two are my favorites. Thank you Buckeye Brownies for a truly awesome brownie experience.
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Zachariah H.Verified
It was absolutely amazing from the no bake bombs to the box my brother loved his gluten free brownies too 10/10 im get some more for the winter time
Limited Edition Back To School Box
Dallon M.Verified
All these flavors that they keep pumping out, just keep me coming back to get more and more boxes. The cornflake cornbread was by far one of my favorite ones I’ve had in a long time and then the milking cookies brownie was a great combination of Oreos and chip ahoy’s.
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
Stephen B.Verified
The Limited Edition Summer Celebration Brownies were awesome. Seamless service from ordering, kept informed with shipping details until the box arrived. Flavors were awesome. If you didn’t order one or two of these boxes you truly missed out! Highly recommend Buckeye Brownies and the order protect additional feature.
Limited Edition Summer Celebration Box
Joshua E.Verified
These brownies are FIRE! My order took longer than expected, and when I reached out Zack responded quickly and was a great help. My whole family loves the brownies and chocolate chip cookies warmed up. Everyone should try Buckeye Brownies!
Order Protect
Dawn C.Verified
I made the order for my grandson. He really enjoyed the brownies, his mom cut them up so he could share with his friends. It was a hit with his friends. So overall the brownies were delicious. Thank you very much!!!
Order Protect
Brittany M.Verified
Bought it for my mom (67 & has cancer) and my niece (6 & well, 6) who both crave sweet treats and brownies. I wish there was a way I could tip you guys after the fact, bc it's truly a blessing to see my mom and my niece enjoy the moment & indulge in a treat together. Thank you for bringing us together! 🥹❤️ It means the world to me!
Build Your Box
Natalie B.Verified
Got these brownies as a gift for my girlfriend who loves a good brownie and to say these were a hit would be an understatement! Each brownie was so delicious and not crazy sweet, which was great. We will definitely be ordering more!
Build Your Box
Brock B.Verified
I bought the fathers day brownie set for my Dad. His absolute favorite candy in the world is Butterfingers and his love for brownies is well documented. He text me the day after Fathers Day to say that these are the most delicious brownies he has ever eaten! My Dad is the sort of guy that has everything he could ever want, until I introduced him to Buckeye Brownies!! Incredible product and service that helped me deliver a great experience for my Dad.
Order Protect
Jane B.Verified
Yummo! These delicious sweets arrived so beautifully boxed,wrapped, confidently cradled in their nests. Unfortunately I don'have pics because I unboxed the brownies and put them in my freezer. My favorites are the two blondies, one with white chocolate and the other with cinnamon. They all are very sweet to my pallette. A little goes a long way. I will no doubt buy more in the future.
Order Protect
Asia B.Verified
I’ve been eyeing these brownies for over a year and finally splurged on the Memorial Day flavor box. They are so so good! And waaaay bigger than I thought I shared them with a bunch of people and everyone loved them. Definitely a very special sweet treat :)
Order Protect
Hjördís Þ.Verified
The brownies are without a doubt the best I have ever had. It’s the third time I have ordered them. I will definitely be ordering again. Wasn’t cheap getting them over here all the way to Iceland but worth every penny.
Order Protect
Wayne E.Verified
Every time I’ve ordered buckeye brownies they’ve never missed with the presentation and flavor. They are absolutely the best tasting brownies I have had and for the size you get they’re amazing.
Tasty Tagalong 4-Pack - May FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Israel S.Verified
All four of the brownies in the Fantastic Four box were delicious. I heated them up for six minutes instead of the five minutes that is recommended. They heated up perfectly. I’ll definitely try another box sometime soon.
Fantastic Four Pack
Customer photo review of Build Your Box
Leezette G.Verified
I have came to the conclusion that I am not thrilled about the blondie base. But the almond flavor saved it. The cookie monster is in the freezer. I have to tackle the others first. Cookies and cream awesome. The one with the chocolate pop tart in the middle excellent. I have a new respect for pop tarts. I am losing no weight this summer.
Build Your Box
Joan B.Verified
The brownies were delivered timely from the initial shipping notice. All four flavors ordered were delicious but the Buckeye Brownie was top notch…but I just have to add GO BLUE!
Order Protect
Devon T.Verified
The brownies I picked for my order were loved by my family! My brother is a huge fan of the Snickerdoodle & Chill and my mom loved the Coffee Cake Crumb.
Order Protect
Antoine L.Verified
Most people say Gluten Free doesn't have any taste as like the other brownies. They'd be dead wrong. The Gluten Free brownies has as equal taste as their standard and specialty brownies. You can never go wrong with switching things up once in a while and these did not disappoint.
Gluten Free Box
Sara C.Verified
Found this company through social media and opted to purchase the Experience Bundle for my husband as part of his birthday present. He loves chocolate and peanut butter, so this pack was a no-brainer. He raved about every item in there! And he ended up freezing some of the cookies and no-bake bombs to eat later on. I’ve recommended you guys to several friends and family and I’ll definitely be ordering more in the future!
The Experience Bundle
Christopher R.Verified
I love building my own box. Sometimes there's one brownie in not interested in so being able to replace it is prefect. Or I find one that is too good to not get multiple of.
Build Your Box
Daphne M.Verified
The Bundle was a gift for my niece and she said everything was delicious. However, I was a little disappointed in the amount of time it took from order date to delivery, which was eleven days.
The Experience Bundle
Chasidy G.Verified
This was an EXPLOSION OF AWESOMENESS in your mouth!!! I'm ordering more!!! I bake all the time and love what I bake but what I bake has NO comparison to these brownies!!!
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Cassandra M.Verified
In our experience, which I do have a video that I will be posting to Tiktok soon, but too big for here. The buckeye brownies are actually better microwaved. Why? Bc it made them soft and gooey and I love soft and gooey brownies! Now how do I know that I like them better that way, because the very first one we tried, the MVP (the oreo one) we baked it in the oven for 5 minutes as it suggested. It was soft and the flavor was there, but it didn't hit out of the ball park for me or my husband. My so...
Fantastic Four Pack
Michelle W.Verified
Got it for the muffin brownie, but the cookie dough one ended up being my favorite. I love the poptarts baked into them. The muffin one did have some actual blueberries in it, but I think more of the blueberries would have made it better. The crumble on top overpowered the blueberry flavor a little for me. The fruity pebbles one wasn't as fruity tasting as I hoped it would be and very sweet. Chocolate peanut butter was really good. Enough peanut butter to not be too sweet. Cookie dough was amazi...
Limited Edition Celebration Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store