Casey B.Verified
Amazing brownies. The flavor and consistency is out of this world. Have a little bit of an obsession with them and would order monthly if calories didn’t exist… Highly recommend.
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Build Your Box
Anthony H.Verified
Haha sorry they were a little too good didn’t get to take any pictures or videos unless you wanted a picture of the empty box or crumbs in my beard 😁 definitely will be ordering again.
Order Protect
Omar G.Verified
Your brownies are the best, and even I ve’ order this 4 piece custom to italy with an extra bill to pay it for, it was totally worth it, I’m sure that the next special month flavour will be amazing too, so keep doing it palese 😂
Order Protect
William C.Verified
The brownies were amazing. Our favorite was the almond blonde. It tasted like a bear claw but just the filling yummy. The Dutchess delight was also amazing. Ordered the father's day box as well to check out the blueberry and cream and the appley ever after
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
Kareem K.Verified
It was good I enjoyed all of them my favorite was the bugs bunny the candied praline and pecan butter cookie along with the carrot cake cookie dough just a beautiful delight 😌. Keep em coming buckeye your on to something much love from NYC.
Order Protect
Cheryl S.Verified
They were very delicious even though they’re gluten-free. I still feel like I might’ve put on a little bit of pounds eating them. I’m going to lay off of them for right now, but probably will order in the near future. Thank you.
Order Protect
Deborah B.Verified
The Cookie Monster Brownie is a new favorite. Snickerdoodle is fabulous too. The Gift actually tastes like a cupcake. But the best is Mr. Buckeye. I have to hide that one, because my mom will fight me for it.
Build Your Box
Arturo C.Verified
Incredible my cookies and milk brownie was destroyed, I emmailed buckeye brownies sent a picture and not only did they send me a new one to replace it they sent two!! Great company and brownies are amazing
Order Protect
Lacount T.Verified
I was very pleased and satisfied with the product. The delivery was on time. Due to the size of each brownie, it can be a challenge trying to eat one in a single sitting. As always, they are great with either milk or ice cream.
I would highly recommend this product for those with a sweet tooth for brownies.
Milk and Cookies 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 6/5
Rae R.Verified
I loved the fact that I could pick the brownies I wanted. They were all awesome! I’ve ordered 4 times now and I’m sure I will order more in the future
Order Protect
Corey W.Verified
Built my own box with the caramel apple pie, butterfinger, and tagalong all the brownies were great, they also edited my box for me after I placed the order too which they didn't have to do. Great company, great brownies, and customer service.
Build Your Box
Debra J.Verified
It's was beautifully good one, I love them.🎉💯💖🌹💋💋😘💐🎉🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🧓🏽 Thank you,!!!!
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
Eleanor L.Verified
They are really great. I put one on a plate then microwave it for about 40 seconds and eat it with a fork. They are so delicious and gooey soft that way
Order Protect
Nathaniel K.Verified
While they were all good from the fridge, I recommend heating them up in the microwave or air fryer because it is a better experience. The one I least looked forward to, Almond sugar, was better. It was very good as is, and my sister and mother really liked the flavor, but my favorites were the milk and cookies and duchess delight. I love my cornbread, but I have yet to place it in the air fryer, and that is when i will like it best, because it was definitely better warmed up, and doing that wil...
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
Kelvin R.Verified
even "gluten-free" is beyond any measures of just excellent in taste, never the least just me still convincing myself "Buckeye" is a brownie just can't fully believe they could be that tasteful is award winning...Big Salute on my purchase 👍 & future purchases thanks
Brownie Cakes
Lisa M.Verified
My son has had your brownies as his mental reward in ever since he started his 16 plus week long prep for a bodybuilding competition. He was super excited to receive your product upon returning home from the competition. He was NOT disappointed. Thank you for your fast communication, fast and dependable delivery and very heavenly tasting brownies!
Order Protect
Eric H.Verified
The brownies were exactly as they looked in the pictures. Thick, chewy, filled with ingredients that I love, and the taste was excellent! I appreciate these very much. I would definitely order again.
Limited Edition March Madness Pack
Marilyn Y.Verified
Zack was so kind when we order and after our order got stolen. He was Johnny on the spot shipping us a new order thanks buckeye brownie customer for life!!!
Order Protect
Andy B.Verified
First time buyer, and my expectations were blown out of the water, absolutely what I was looking for, I have one out of four brownies left, I will be buying again in the future!!!!
Order Protect
Rosetta B.Verified
Easy to order! Lots of brownie options to choose from! I was sending an order to my grandson and found out he was leaving school for summer. I contacted the office and Zack changed the delivery address from university to home. They all enjoyed these delicious treats!
Order Protect
Antoine L.Verified
How can you go wrong with the combination of M&M's and cookies built into a brownie. I would definitely order these again the next time they come around again, even if it is a special closeout box sale.
M&M Express 4-Pack - April FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Bendrell A.Verified
The brownies are delicious! Unfortunately a squirrel beat me to one of the brownies. He smelled the deliciousness & nibbled through a quarter of my chocolate brownie with the cookie in the middle…lol.
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
Stephen E.Verified
Your brownies are so creative and fun. Not only do they look amazing, they TASTE amazing. I’m partial to the blonde brownies over the chocolate, but they are all so perfectly baked and I keep picking new favorites!
Join The Buckeye Club!
Brandon J.Verified
The Snickerdoodle and chill brownie was amazing hands down 9.5 I haven't tried the Mr. BUCKEYE yet waiting for another time to try it with my 3 year old daughter...I would really like to try the one with the blueberries I can't think of the name Grandma's "something" idk...but also please make one with Biscoff cookies too...Great work guys I will be ordering more Believe that!!!!
Rush Baking
Ashley R.Verified
Love the brownies!! Especially the PB cups!! They were so gooey and soft to eat! Absolutely our favorite! Every single brownie we got was amazing and they were best after being in the air fryer for 10 mins! Yum 🤤 WILL be back for more!!
Order Protect
Amber H.Verified
I got these for a friend and this is the text I got:
"Oh my gosh!!!! I got the most amazing thing ever in the mail today!!! This is literally the best thing I have ever gotten! Thank you so much!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Like literally ever!!!!"
Limited Edition March Madness 4-Pack
Victoria R.Verified
We’ve tried two different variety boxes, have loved every one of them, got the strawberry ones as a close out sale, they are delicious! So far, haven’t found any that we dislike honestly! They’re moist, go great with a scoop of ice cream, or just by themselves, you can’t go wrong! : )
Order Protect
Carol P.Verified
I loved all of it. The brownies are so yummy! So big you can share it with 4 others also. Was pleasantly surprised by how good all of it was.
Thank you!
March Madness Bundle
Alexander S.
The churro caramel one was my absolute favorite out of the four. The rest is still good btw. Good month. 👍
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Troy R.Verified
Super easy ordering, quick delivery and very yummy. They freeze very well and you’ll need to because they’re so large. Try them out for yourself. I liked some flavors better than others but they’re all tasty in their own way.
Order Protect
Drew A H.Verified
Absolutely amazing. My wife scarfed them down. We will order again and very soon. Had a small problem with my initial order but they made it more than right. Gained me a customer for as long as I don’t get diabetes.
COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 5/14
Luann S.Verified
Purchased these products as an appreciation gift for my department ar work. EVERYONE LOVED THEM!!!!! I recommend Buckeye Brownies to everyone who will listen. I have since my first purchase.
Rush Baking
Antoine L.Verified
Buckeye Brownies always delivers and always keeps me up-to-date on when my shipments are shipped out and USPS and UPS alerts me when my packages have been delivered. When all packages arrive, it's snacking time.
Buckeye Brownies has never let me down and it's the reason why they continue to get my business when I'm truly craving it.
Order Protect
K H.Verified
All four flavors were tasty. I would reorder all except the corn flake crunch, mostly because the corn flakes baked on the top were extremely hard to chew but it had good flavor. I wish Mr Tuxedo was a full-time flavor like Mr Buckeye!
Build Your Box
Taylor B.
Was looking forward to these for 20 weeks and they were well worth the wait will definitely order again! They are amazing!!!!
Fantastic Four Pack
Hector G.Verified
I love the options when built your own kicks in. But you do have to purchase the ones available before actually saying it’s worth it.
Build Your Box
Justin Z.Verified
My first order i got the cosmic brownie and the mvp In a build a box they need to bring back. But both were amazing especially when you worm them up with a glass of milk to drink. So that I made another purchase for some different ideas to try out and I can't wait.
Order Protect
Barbara H.Verified
I wish I could post a picture. It's too late. I have gotten them twice (so far), and was planning a very pretty picture! However, I took a knife, cut off good sized chunks of each brownie (to hide for myself) and reassembled them to be my birthday cake. My family DEVOURED it before I barely finished digging Happy Birthday. These are toooo good.
Build Your Box
James T.Verified
I have ordered the Experience Bundle and the Limited Edition Cake Bundle and was not disappointed with either order! The cookies were amazing, the Buckeye Bombs are hard to eat just one and the brownies are the best! Even after freezing, I have warmed them up and they taste just as if they were freshly cooked! You will not be disappointed when you order from Buckeye Brownies!
Order Protect
Phillip D.Verified
These brownies are a favorite of mine and my wife. They are great out of the freezer or warmed up till they get, just a little melty.
Will look for these and buy again. 10/10
COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store