Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Visit store
Tracie O.Verified
The quality of these brownies is amazing!!1 They taste Awesome! My grandkids were fighting over them. We cut each brownie in several pieces for everyone to taste, but no one could choose a favorite!!! I will recommend them to everyone. It was fun doing the tasting. I will say that the kids loved them all.
Order Protect
Antoine L.Verified
Buckeye Brownies stays on target with the preparation and the shipment. I ordered two back-to-back shipments and they both arrived looking spectacular to eat and I'm already digging into them. Buckeye Brownies is #1 and that's why they continue to get my business.
Order Protect
Andrew B.Verified
The Twix and blueberry maybe the best ever. Twix is brownie of the year last year. And you guys kill it with the fruit and the crumb topping with the sugar mind blowing.
Build Your Box
Charles J.Verified
Hi, This is my second order of brownies. Very good. I'm from Michigan and there is a place known for it's fudge called Mackinac which is known for it's fudge. Your creative brownie ideas could pull off incorporating some of that locations unique tasting fudge. Call it something like the "Mackinac Fudge Attack". Here's just one place that sells the fudge. https://originalmackinacislandfudge.com/
Build Your Box
Justin B.Verified
I bought this for my wife. She is allergic to dairy and finding snacks for her can be challenging. I'm aware that there's never a zero chance of contamination, so I try to find what I can get for her. That aside, she absolutely loved the brownies! The snickerdoodle ones were her favorite of the two. They were pretty good, I'll agree. Overall, she was very pleased with the order and told me to get more in the near future. 10/10, would recommend!
Vegan Box
Susan K.Verified
There a few that just are not to my liking. But we do love most of the Buckeye Brownies. My favorite being any with the red velvet And then any of the chocolate and peanut butter. I know I'm Diabetic but your Buckeye Brownies are to die for.. I just have some when my b.s. is low. Thanks for your great scrumptious product.
Buckeye’s Birthday Bundle
Going D.Verified
Everything was absolutely amazing! Wasn't a fan of the lemon pound cake thing was zesty as all get out but I've been supporting since 2019 so always worth it love yall and thank you!!!
LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX
Dakota A.Verified
So I have ordered from buckeye brownies before and that box was fantastic and I ordered the Memorial Day box this time at first there were complications but Zack the ceo and owner had taken care of the problem for me and so far I tried the almond flavor and finished it it was subtly sweet had a lot of flavor and held up well I will definitely keep buying from this company.
Order Protect
Aaron P.Verified
Very amazing brownies, I have been wanting to purchase from buckeyes but kind of put it off every now and then. But when I finally got the chance to purchase it and try it, I was really worth the wait. Everyone I said my box from really enjoyed it.
Order Protect
Leezette G.Verified
This is my favorite! The fudge base with peanut butter morsels. I didn't share that with anyone. My big back thanks you.🤗🤗🤗 We will be ordering that again.
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
Bruce F.Verified
Shipping was fast! I was surprised how heavy the package was until I opened it and saw how massive each brownie was. I've only had two, so far, but looking forward to having the next one. Absolutely delicious!
Order Protect
Karen T.Verified
Loved the brownies. They were huge and delicious in every bite. Very satisfying. They arrived earlier than expected. I chose the 4 pack due to the 1st time I ordered from this company. They were fresh, soft, flavorful and very filling. I gave one away as a gift as I wanted to share how good they tasted. Will always recommend these delicous brownies.
Order Protect
Amanda S.Verified
First I have to say customer service is great! I had an issue with shipping and it was rectified right away. Thank you! The brownies are amazing and they are HUGE! I actually froze 3 of them and used them for dessert on different occasions. They thawed well and tasted just as amazing as the one that came fresh! My whole family fought over them so I guess I’ll have to order more!!
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Kathleen S.Verified
Great product! Delicious and worth every penny. It was a big hit at my house this holiday season ...and didn't last long! Will definitely make more purchases in the future. This was my first, and Buckeye Brownies did not disappoint! Thank you!!
Brownie Cakes
Janerio M.Verified
I purchased these as a gift for Christmas.my son. He loves your brownies he orders all the time. Lol he braggs about how they are the best brownies he's ever had. He loved the holiday brownies. Order arrived in time for christmas and packaged nicely. Company kept me posted. Will order again for myself soon.
Order Protect
Deborah N.Verified
The lemon brownie was amazing and the strawberry cheesecake was delicious as well. Both are moist but have the brownie "edge" that is often my favorite part. I liked the lemon one chilled and the strawberry one heated up just enough to make a little bit of vanilla ice cream a warm place to rest. I have the other two left to try but they both look incredible as well. I ordered the summer bundle that also had chocolate chip cookies and the lemon pound cakes. Warm up the cookies with a tall glass o...
Summer Bundle Pack
Claire P.Verified
Discovered these brownies a couple years ago at a market. So delicious, great flavors, moist and chewy. Love the build your own box. We can choose our favorites. Fast delivery, packed well & the box is sturdy so never any issues with brownie quality.
Build Your Box
Crystal J.Verified
I ordered the holiday sample pack. I had seen these Brownies on tiktok and thought I'd give them a try. I am so happy I did! These things are huge!! They are super moist and delicious!! Even the cups are huge! You can tell they are freshed baked and care was put into the order. They were well packaged, I dividually wrapped, and labeled. Definitely worth the price and the wait to get them!
Order Protect
June M.Verified
You guys are the bomb!! Best tasting brownies I have tried. Love the layering, loved the Minty for Christmas, also tried the peanut butter cookies and they were fantastic!!! Each 8oz brownie easily yields 4 servings. Keeping it going!!!
Order Protect
Samuel W.Verified
Unfortunately, my package was shipped pass the due date but when it arrived, the brownies were delicious. I did receive a discount code for my next order, which was awesome.
BUGS BUNNY 4-Pack - National Pecan Day Special
Christopher P.Verified
Excellent! This truly was an experience. A delicious assortment of the biggest, richest, tastiest and most unique brownies, cookies and cup cakes I've ever had in my life. Worth every cent!
The Experience Box
Joshua D.Verified
The brownies/blondies came perfectly packaged and are absolutely huge, circa 400g. Great flavours nice gooey and indulgent. Ordered all the way from the UK and although postage was obviously pricey absolutely worth it.
Order Protect
Cindy S.Verified
These were sent to my Granddaughter and family for her birthday. They absolutely loved them. Unfortunately I do not live close so I could not taste them but they loved them!!
Fantastic Four Pack
Brenda S.Verified
Oh my goodness! These are the beat brownies I have ever had! Great flavor, baked perfectly, easy to order and arrived quickly. Will recommend to all my family and friends. They are heavenly!!❤❤
Order Protect
Jeremy M.Verified
The brownies weren’t that great to me. Too cakey for my taste as I like my brownies more fudgy. Also the blonde based ones were to dry. I would honestly give them all a 2.5/5.
Order Protect
Michael C.Verified
These brownies are so good that they’re almost unbelievable. Grateful that these got advertised to me online and I pounced as soon as I saw them. They arrived quickly and are absolutely incredible. Great job with these!
The MVP 4-Pack
Michael C.Verified
I ordered these and a four pack of brownies because they looked so delicious online. When they arrived and I got to enjoy them in person, they did not disappoint. What an amazing find and what an amazing product!
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Louis P.Verified
My son actually looked up brownies and found your website. We were very impressed with your website and ordered the limited holiday pack. The best brownies we have ever consumed. We are going to order another round very soon.
Limited Edition Holiday Pack
Nicolette I.Verified
Buckeyed Brownies are great! I had one of the wrong brownies sent and they fixed it for me the day I emailed. Super happy with both the brownies and the customer service. Thank you guys!
Build Your Box
Crystal M.Verified
The best brownies!!! My son looks forward to these brownies every year!! We order them so he can enjoy after his bodybuilding competition and it’s all he can rave about Thank u!!! We will definitely keep ordering from you.
Order Protect
Carolyn Y.Verified
I love Buckeye Brownies! The brownies are delicious. I even got my sister to try them and now she is hooked! I watch my weight so I cut each brownie into 8 pieces and put them in the freezer. Then each evening, I take one piece out and warm it in the microwave for 15 seconds…and PERFECTION!
Limited Edition February Box
Candice B.Verified
The oreo lava cakes are my favorite and then I would say the chocolate chip cookies 2nd, and 3rd the brownies. Vanilla Ice cream on top of the cookies and lava cakes, was just wonderful!
February Bundle Pack
Deborah H.Verified
Brownie Bombs ...wow!! You definitely made an impact on Christmas Day! Sweet and ooey gooey everyone raved about them. If you love brownies this is the way to go. I will be back for sure.
Order Protect
Brandon A.Verified
I really enjoyed the pumpkin pie and sweet potato ones and loved the chewy texture of the brownie mixed with the softness of the cookie dough. Although the banana flavor was a bit dry which was okay but was enjoyable still!
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Gladys B.Verified
Amazing service! Very quick response! My boyfriend loved the brownies. I was pleasantly surprised by how large the brownies are, how well packaged they were. This company definitely takes great care in how they ship their products. Will be ordering from them soon.
Order Protect
Mayuri M.Verified
Delicious! We'd previously tried the brownies, but everything in the Experience Box was just as good. The tops of the cupcakes were concave rather than convex (they looked kind of "scooped out"), and at first we wondered if this was a weird batch or just how they normally look, but they tasted as amazing as the rest of the box's contents.
The Experience Box
Kathleen G.Verified
They are extremely delicious and they were fresh when they got here. I appreciate the company working with me and resolving any issues that I have. Thank you very much.
Brownie Cakes
Zayne S.Verified
I don't order online. Ever. PERIOT. But when I saw a food review of your Oreo Cheesecake and Red Velvet brownies I had a package ordered before I even knew what I had done. AMAZING. You have a forever fan now, and I will be ordering again!
Limited Edition Cake Pack
Derek B.Verified
The brownies are always good, I love the Thanksgiving pack flavors. My favorite flavors out of that pack are kettle my cornbread & sweetie pie. Coincidentally sweet potatoes & pie and cornbread are two of my all-time Thanksgiving dishes and you guys always knock it out of the park every November!
Order Protect
Carolann L.Verified
These brownies were a hit, very shareable amongst family. Glad i tried them. Was wondering if there could be future versions that would be sugar free for diabetic people or people who cant have much sugar!
Build Your Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store