Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Zamir F.Verified

Cookie Monster: 10- best brownie you guys make Terrifically twix: 8- caramel was a bit much, but overall was good Churro caramel cream: 10- 2nd best brownie you guys make Pebbles and cream: 9- strawberry cookie dough is amazing

Build Your Box

Bernadette B.Verified

When I opened the box and looked at the brownies and blondies it was difficult making the choice of choosing which one should I try first. It was the blondie Muffin Madness which was full of blueberries which made the dough perfectly moist. My second bite came from New York Cheesecake which didn't meet my expectations. Then it was on to the brownies. Both Cosmic Craze and finally PB Perfection. I rated the four in order of my tastebuds. 1. PB Perfection - it really was perfect 2. Muffin ...

Limited Edition New Year’s Surprise Box

Marsha D.Verified

I ordered a four pack of the snickerdoodle brownies and they came stale. Zach contacted me and made it right immediately by sending me out another four pack for free. Zach was amazing. Thank you so much!

Order Protect

Everett K.Verified

This was my first time ordering and I was not disappointed! These are definitely big enough for two and if you’re a fan of cookies and cream you’re going to love them!

The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Cindy S.Verified

These were sent to my Granddaughter and family for her birthday. They absolutely loved them. Unfortunately I do not live close so I could not taste them but they loved them!!

Fantastic Four Pack

Brenda S.Verified

Oh my goodness! These are the beat brownies I have ever had! Great flavor, baked perfectly, easy to order and arrived quickly. Will recommend to all my family and friends. They are heavenly!!❤❤

Order Protect

Jeremy M.Verified

The brownies weren’t that great to me. Too cakey for my taste as I like my brownies more fudgy. Also the blonde based ones were to dry. I would honestly give them all a 2.5/5.

Order Protect

Michael C.Verified

These brownies are so good that they’re almost unbelievable. Grateful that these got advertised to me online and I pounced as soon as I saw them. They arrived quickly and are absolutely incredible. Great job with these!

The MVP 4-Pack

Michael C.Verified

I ordered these and a four pack of brownies because they looked so delicious online. When they arrived and I got to enjoy them in person, they did not disappoint. What an amazing find and what an amazing product!

The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Paul Z.Verified

I loved the peanut butter cup on top of the brownie 😋 l put one in the microwave and melted it a little and added a couple of scoops of ice cream and you just can't beat it 😋

MINI BUCKEYE 6-Pack

Nicolette I.Verified

Buckeyed Brownies are great! I had one of the wrong brownies sent and they fixed it for me the day I emailed. Super happy with both the brownies and the customer service. Thank you guys!

Build Your Box

Susie S.Verified

Excellent! I loved all of the flavors (mvp, Mr. Buckeye, Snickdoodle and Chill, The Gift) but Snickerdoodle and Chill was by far my favorite! It's just me, so I cut them into smaller portions and froze them to enjoy later. Can't wait to try more!

Order Protect

Beth P.Verified

My order was absolutely amazing. I ordered these brownies for mine and my boyfriends birthday, and we have loved every one of them. We highly recommend ordering one of everything!

Order Protect

Todd H W.Verified

They were bigger than I thought, which was a good thing. I had to put quite a bit in the freezer to keep them from spoiling so soon. Great tasting brownies, the combinations were really good and inventive.

Order Protect

Jesus A.Verified

The best brownies in the game!! Who could go wrong with a monster brownie packed with flavor. Amazing combos, and really enjoyed the Halloween edition. Didn’t have a favorite, all packed flavor in their own respected way. I like how you guys don’t make them extremely sweet as well, keep it up Buckeye team!

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Shawn A.Verified

I absolutely loved how all of the flavors gelled together, especially after I heat up the brownie before I eat it. You guys knocked it out of the park with this brownie flavor, keep up the good work and innovative flavors! Shawn

Pebbles & Cream 4-Pack - October Flavor of the Month

Samuel O.Verified

So I bought these brownies for my dad for Father’s Day! He called me every single day to thank me for them he ate on them for days! The pictures don’t do them justice. They’re huge! Now the old man’s asking when I’m gonna buy more! Showed up in just a few days and still tasted fresh after being in the fridge for a few days

Rush Baking

James H.Verified

My actual order was delayed by several days due to bad weather. I didnt receive it for 12 days and when it arrived it was unfortunately dried out. I gave a 5 star review because Zack from buckeye brownies reached out to me and sent me a new order when he saw what had happened. So the 5 stars is for great customer service and of course the brownies are the best. Thanks Zack.

Build Your Box

Carolyn Y.Verified

I love Buckeye Brownies! The brownies are delicious. I even got my sister to try them and now she is hooked! I watch my weight so I cut each brownie into 8 pieces and put them in the freezer. Then each evening, I take one piece out and warm it in the microwave for 15 seconds…and PERFECTION!

Limited Edition February Box

Candice B.Verified

The oreo lava cakes are my favorite and then I would say the chocolate chip cookies 2nd, and 3rd the brownies. Vanilla Ice cream on top of the cookies and lava cakes, was just wonderful!

February Bundle Pack

Lisa B.Verified

them fudge cups are beyond delicious. very very rich!! the brownies are very big and were a little off of expectations :/ kind of dry. pb one is delicious. still have 2 more to eat.

Limited Edition New Year’s Surprise Box

Susan K.Verified

We love Buckeye Brownies, The Terrifficly Twix are fantastic. The caramel makes it. I enjoy all of the Buckeye Brownies with just a few seconds in the microwave. The best.

Limited Edition Holiday Pack

Gladys B.Verified

Amazing service! Very quick response! My boyfriend loved the brownies. I was pleasantly surprised by how large the brownies are, how well packaged they were. This company definitely takes great care in how they ship their products. Will be ordering from them soon.

Order Protect

Greg P.Verified

The brownies are very good, they don’t look like they do in the ads, but they are very good. I wish they were a little cheaper, but overall I was pleased.

Build Your Box

Susan M.Verified

Hello, This was my first time ordering. The box was amazing. Looked great. Tasted great. Unfortunately I probably will not order again as this was way too big and too much sugar for us. Sue

The Experience Bundle

Ashlee G.Verified

Baked to perfect!! Purchased these brownies for my husband for Father’s Day and you know I had to sneak a bite, obviously lol, and they were incredible. The Apple pie one was my fave, with that oat crumble just amazing!! My husband loved the butterfinger AF! But let’s face it, they were all a hit! 🔥

Order Protect

Anthony M.Verified

Thanks to a fantastic brownie I survived a very long and stressful day without breaking up with the girl friend or going postal on all my co-workers. I have found that your brownies are better at solving a problem, rather than saying f**k it and shooting everyone in the room. They have also increased the possible chances of me getting laid!

Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack

Louis M.Verified

Every time I think I've had the best brownie another one comes out and these by far was one of the best combinations of chocolate and cheesecake that I've had

Oreo Cheesecake 4-Pack - November Flavor of the Month

Paul S.Verified

This is my third order and everything was great. I added two packages of grandma’s chocolate chip cookie and they were great as well. Another home run for your talented bakers and employees. I tasted the love in every cookie. Thanks for again managing to ship “perfection” in a box. Paul Spatzek

Limited Edition Fathers Day Box

Kimberly R.Verified

Omg! These are my new, all time, favorite brownie ever! I loved everything about them. I am a huge peanut butter fan and these were just absolutely amazing! I'll most definitely be ordering more

Mr Buckeye 4-Pack

Joy H.Verified

🧐these brownies are moist, and full of yummy surprises. They are simply delectable! The best part is that they are not overly sweet as you may expect because of all of the yummy ingredients. What they are is absolutely delightful! I have ordered at least four times in the last year, one of the best desserts EVER!

Ravenous Red Velvet Oreo Brownie Cake

Zander P.Verified

I got the fantastic 4 pack for after my BB show and I loved them my favorite was the snickerdoodle and oh my gosh I could not put it down I wanted to eat it all right there but I didn’t I almost did but I didn’t then 2nd place was the Mr Buckeye (nutter butter one) so good I had both not heated up but later did heat them up and went from and 11/10 to a 15/10 both times breaking the scale highly recommend getting these

Order Protect

Francisco R.Verified

The Christmas brownies and holiday cookies were awesome. They came in right before the Christmas party just in the and they were a big hit with everyone. My personal favorite was the funfettie sugar cookie with the gingerbread cookie, a close second.

Christmas Cookie Collection

Bella S.Verified

Not a fan of the brownies. They look super sweet but when you taste it, there’s no sweetness at all. The brownies are not good, very disappointing and dissatisfied. Texture, taste, everything is off in my opinion. Maybe if you like unsweetened brownies you’ll like these idk…

Order Protect

Samantha C.Verified

I got this bundle for a Thanksgiving Event. AND IT WAS A HIT. A ABSOLUTE HIT. SO MUCH SO I couldn’t wait to get the December bundle for Christmas season. My guests were pleased, and constantly asking where the brownies came from! I froze them upon arrival, let them defrost then put them in the oven. They tasted so fresh and moist. This November pack did not disappoint.

November Bundle Pack

Nathaniel K.Verified

These are the bescoff cookies by buckeye ever made, and I am sure it will remain true even after I try more varieties (even if these are topped, they will still be in the top three) These can go toe to toe with the inspiration for these creations, even if they are in a whole different weight class.

Brown Butter Biscoff Cookies

Anthony A.Verified

I actually work for an insurance company and I came across your business by a coincidence. I was curious so I ordered some and the brownies were incredible!! Hands down one of the best coincidences ever!

Limited Edition September Pack

Linda T.Verified

These are unbelievable! They are dense and just scrumptious. They taste like the inside of a bear claw pastry—brown sugar and almonds. SOOO good! I wish these were available year round. I will definitely have to stock up next holiday season!

Order Protect

Benjie Lauren G.Verified

I sent the no bake buckeye brownies to my son and daughter-in-law as a Valentine’s Day treat. The tracking was great I live in South Carolina and often time surprise my kids I needed customer service and had questions again answered very quickly very professionally done and it got me and I love you, mom and a phone call so best gift for Valentine’s Day.

Order Protect

Nino M.Verified

Box was great. There was a mix up on one of the brownies but the customer service to fix it was fantastic and the replacement was shipped out lightning quick. Love when it comes time to order our Buckeye Brownies.

Build Your Box

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store