Nino M.Verified
Box was great. There was a mix up on one of the brownies but the customer service to fix it was fantastic and the replacement was shipped out lightning quick. Love when it comes time to order our Buckeye Brownies.
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Build Your Box
John A.Verified
Circus animal and oatmeal cream pie ones were amazing! I'm very upset I didn't get the Christmas tree brownie during Christmas. But overall February box was second best box. 4th of July box was the best box I've had. Bring back campfire s'mores !!!! Lol
Limited Edition February Box
Peggy D.Verified
These brownies are simply AMAZING!
They have the best taste to each one. They're not too sweet and they go great with a microwave on 30 seconds and a glass of cold milk! Yum!!
I will definitely by ordering more flavors in the future!
Order Protect
Thomas M.Verified
Everything was perfect, my wife has loved her brownie’s. I ordered to much though, so we have a bunch in the freezer! Lol really is there ever to many brownies!?
Order Protect
Jaimee H.Verified
The cookies were really good. Score on them. I will be ordering more. The no bake with a pb cup is genius! I never thought of that. I used to make them all the time. I forgot how. Never added a of cup. That was the best thing!
We also like the nutter butter brownie so good. So good. The blonde with white chips was good as well at the party cake with sprinkles. Score on a bundle where you can try a bit of everything.
The Experience Bundle
Sawan M.Verified
The packaging and timing of delivery were great. The brownies themselves look just like they were in the advertisement. I just didn't enjoy eating the brownies. They all lacked flavor and somehow all tasted the same.
Order Protect
Marc D.Verified
Loved the peanut butter stores! Pretty much all the peanut butter brownies are amazing. Can't wait for my next build a box. Also can't wait for any new flavors your team can come up with. Frosted Animal Crackers is another incredible flavor !!
Build Your Box
Alicia C.Verified
I loved all the yummy brownies 🤤 Unfortunately, I didn't take any pictures but they were delicious 😋 my kiddos loved them as well. We will definitely be buying more in the near future 😁 Thanks again 😀
Order Protect
Latiyah C.Verified
Perfect birthday present! I order this starter pack for my sister. As normally I would make a cake or give some other assortments for her. This time I decided do something different and I'm glad that I did. She love everything in the starter pack especially the brownie cups. Which was her favorite! If I had another birthday or celebration for someone else. You expect me to order again!
The 2026 Starter Pack
Andrea S.Verified
A delicious treat! I took them to work to share with my fellow teachers and they were a huge hit! Everyone loved them. I especially liked the PB candies that were mixed into the top of the brownie separate from the peanut butter cup. One of my favorite treats, I really enjoyed these treats!
MINI BUCKEYE 6-Pack
Diana H.Verified
Everything i ordered was DELICIOUS! There wasn't anything we didn't like. My 2 guys loved the buckeye bombs the most. It was a no bake with a Reese cup in the middle! Bes thing EVER! Thank you!
Order Protect
Brook S.Verified
Everything turned out wonderful it was all so yummy. This is my 2nd order and it went way better than my first order. My first order was dry and hard and these were absolutely amazing I will be ordering again.
Order Protect
Michael C.Verified
If you haven't tried Buckeye Brownies yet, you are missing out. These are hands down some of the best gourmet brownies I’ve ever had. They are incredibly thick, packed with flavor, and have the perfect fudgy texture. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, and the creative flavor combinations are next-level. They arrived fresh and perfectly packaged. Highly recommend treating yourself or sending them as a gift!
Fantastic Four Pack
Amanda G.Verified
The brownies were delicious and huge! I tried Nutella, MVP and the peanut butter ones. All exceeded expectations. The three free brownies cups were a plus and so good! Will definitely order again.
Order Protect
Cindy S.Verified
I ordered for my Granddaughters birthday. She and her family loved them. They were so surprised. They heated them slightly and they were gone within a few days.
We will definitely try you again.
Order Protect
Noel M.Verified
Cookie Monster is a flavor I wish would be year around it’s so amazing. The lemon cookies are surprisingly not too sour nor sweet just the perfect balance. The no bake bites I wasn’t expecting the oats but nonetheless I’d recommend them if you love oats and peanut butter cups. The peanut butter pieces and cup brownie was also amazing too best enjoyed with some milk (or milk substitute). The almond topped flavor personally I didn’t enjoy it much but my other friends did. And last but not least th...
August Bundle Pack
Aidan A.Verified
It took me a minute to realize that my order is coming from ohio and i relaxed and continued watching reviews on buckeye brownies and i was excited all over again
Thank you all for your innovative
Brownie Creation
Order Protect
Aisha A.Verified
We got a box of the snickerdoodle variety blondies and a half dozen of the chocolate chip cookies, and both were excellent! The blondies were delicious, not too sweet, huge and took a good while to get through, so you're definitely getting your money's worth. And the cookies were so good, we're craving more already!
Order Protect
Kelly G.Verified
I placed my order with Buckeye Brownies and had it delivered within a week. Fresh and Tasty like it was right out of the Bakery! You can't go wrong when you place an order with them!!!
Order Protect
Gretchen H.Verified
These are the best treat ever! They just like I remember eating no bakes when I was a little kid. The peanut butter cup on top is a nice touch. It doesn't really pop out.Because there's peanut butter in the cookie too.But they go together really well. I definitely will order these again if they are offered!
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Christian D.Verified
My phone wouldn’t let me send the picture of it. I ate half of the tagalong brownie and then took a picture. I just finished all of them yesterday because I’ve been trying to savor them but they’re just too good. Milk n Cookies 1000/10, The Gift 9/10, The Cookie Monster 8.5/10, The tagalong 7/10. MnC was just perfect which is why I saved it for last, I wish I had milk with it to finish it off because it meshes perfectly. Thanks for making the brownies they were delish, I hope y’all continue to p...
Order Protect
Peggy D.Verified
These brownies are amazing!!
They're fresh, soft, and the sweetness is just right, not overpowering!
Slice them up, or not, pop them in the microwave for about 25-30 seconds, pair it with a glass of cold milk and Oh my lanta!! What a treat!!
I have shared one, just one, with my co-workers and they really liked them too!
I'm going to try other flavors soon!
Fantastic Four Pack
Sheena W.Verified
I ordered the strawberry and chocolate chip cookies and the variety pack. The order came really fast with clear instructions about how long you have to consume them or freeze them which I really like. Everything tasted amazing and fresh. I would definitely recommend ordering from them.
Order Protect
Gavin C.Verified
These brownies were probably the best brownies I’ve ever had! Me and my coworkers ate them on our overnight shift with a cup of coffee and were so full we couldn’t stop laughing 😂
Order Protect
Rex T.Verified
The package was well packed, and surprisingly heavy😁, a sign of quality baked goods. Everything arrived in great shape, with nice presentation boxes. All tasted delicious as advertised. Would recommend to anyone with a sweet tooth and a love of baked goods.
The Experience Bundle
Andrea O.Verified
It was everything I hoped it would be!! I bought it for my husband for Christmas and he loved it! The best part is that we ate these for 3 days, just froze the rest for another time(at the time of receival). So fresh and delicious, I would for sure buy again just because ❤️
Order Protect
Geri B.Verified
I would love to share pics but I’ve already ate up those yummy treats up! Please keep making these and I’ll keep ordering them! Now excuse me while I go run off a few of these calories I put on😏
Order Protect
Rashad C.Verified
Absolutely delicious!
Duchess Delight was an excellent indulgent chocolate experience, akin to a Fudge Round in brownie form. Probably my third favorite in the box. Lots of great chocolate flavor but the others in the box pulled ahead for me with their creativity and variety. Definitely one for the chocaholics.
Milk and Cookies with the chips ahoy was arguably the best in the box. White chocolate and chips ahoy is a combination I didn't know I needed in my life! And of course with the classic...
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
Justin H.Verified
Clearly understand why this is a fan favorite. Hard to actually pick one. Warmed with some icecream you’ll be more than satisfied. Gluten free does not mean lacking of flavor.
Gluten Free Box
Lisa B.Verified
These brownies are so decadent and delicious. I usually ration them so they last longer. At least it sounds good it theory but they are so good it’s hard to not overindulge.
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Brian S.Verified
I've ordered a couple of the build your own brownie box to try the different kinds... I have not been disappointed yet! My family and me love trying all the different flavors! You can't go wrong with any choice!
Build Your Box
David C.Verified
The brownies were beautifully made and so delicious. I gave a sample to a couple co-workers and both said they loved them. The Buckeye Bombs are simply marvelous, also. I will definitely look forward to another order in the future.
Order Protect
Tylor H.Verified
She was very surprised and delighted! Brownies were outstanding with many layers to each kind. Held up great in Tupperware; in and out of the fridge. Everything was fresh and worth the wait.
August Bundle Pack
Charles B.Verified
Tried the build your own box for the first time. Definitely have 2 new favorites having tried the Dark Knight and Mr Buckeye flavors! These will definitely hit the sweet spot for brownie aficionados 😄
Build Your Box
Timothy C.Verified
Delivery was great. Quality of the brownies was spot on. Easy to freeze and hang on to them when I was ready to use them, and just as easy to get them warm like they were fresh baked!
Fantastic Four Pack
Amy M.Verified
This was my first time ever ordering brownies from here. I can say this will not be the last time. These brownies are amazing and we ate them up. I have two that we are saving for later. Will be ordering again soon.
Order Protect
Garrett S.Verified
The brownies were just as good as they looked in the video I saw. Very decadent but worth the wait! Super glad I took a risk and made the order. I did not get the fudge promised but maybe that shipped separately. Looking forward to trying more flavors, especially the butterfinger
Order Protect
Jennifer C.Verified
My order ended up getting lost in transit due to weather. The owner Zach immediately sent out a new order. I received the order quickly. These brownies are amazing and so are the staff. I am grateful for their service.
Fantastic Four Pack
Nathaniel K.Verified
I was looking forward to the Thanksgiving pack and it did not disappoint. Out of several pumpkinfluenced brownies I have tried, The Pumpkin Crumb Cake had to be my favorite. The crumb cake topping rose it to an even higher level.
Could cornbread be improved upon? An attempt is made, and it succeeded.
I was really looking forward to Sweetie Pie, and it did not disappoint.
I do like my banana bread, but I was looking forward to this the least (the other flavors these brownies were incorporating ...
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Breanne S.Verified
It was great. Although I couldnt eat it because of peanut butter and im allergic. my kids thoroughly enjoyed them. I couldnt find create your own box on the website the first go around but I'll definitely be ordering again here soon since I commented on a Facebook post and your company sent me the direct link to it. Thank you again .
Order Protect
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store