Michael S.Verified
The Twix Four pack was my first order from Buckeye Brownies. They were delicious, especially when warmed up! My next order is the Limited Edition Valentine's Pack. I can't wait!
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Terrifically Twix 4-Pack - January Flavor of the Month
Everett K.Verified
This was my first time ordering from Buckeye Brownies and I was very happy with it! I actually shared part of it with a friend and her grandsons and the one grandson who isn’t really a sweets person loved them too which meant a lot! My favorite was the one with the strawberry pop tarts so I’m looking forward to ordering that one again!
Build Your Box
Collin W.Verified
Zack was absolutely amazing i messed up my first order with the wrong address and emailed him and he got it taken care of right away,brownies are delicious to thank you zack and the buckeye team!!
Order Protect
Lance W.Verified
Holy brownies these were so good, very rich so share with a friend. I put them in the oven for a few minutes to get them warm and gooey just how I like them. Definitely want to try more flavors. Do yourself a favor and order some of these brownies now, you won't regret it.
Order Protect
Teresa M.Verified
Brownie flavors are amazing. Shipped quickly to military location and arrived in great condition. Perfect birthday gift for my son who has been on active duty for the last 6 months.
Build Your Box
Daniel T.Verified
Awesome treats for my crew and suppliers.
Zachery hooked us up. Great communication and timely delivery.
All the brownies we got were fresh and super tasty , nice work Buckeye keep it up.
I would absolutely order more and pass on the good word.
DT Seattle WA
Order Protect
Matteo A.Verified
I’ve ordered before & it was too much never got to finish it all this time was a smaller order & it’s too much as well… BUT I really do like the cookies & cream & peanut butter brownie classics..
Order Protect
Amanda L.Verified
This was our first experience with Buckeye Brownies and WOW!! Super tasty treats and we could not believe how big the brownies were. We really enjoyed all 4 flavors and will be ordering again soon!
Closeout Box A - Will ship 1/19
Tanya M.Verified
Order was lost in shipping. Received refund. Order finally was delivered, but some items could not be used. Zack was the best and so understanding. Will definitely be ordering again due to the quality of service and the products being delicious 😋
Order Protect
Beth W.Verified
Picking your own brownies is great because you can choose your own flavors. I have eaten one brownie out of four and it was delicious! At a half pound per brownie it’s too much to eat all at once so I put the other 3 in the freezer. I will enjoy another one soon!!!
Build Your Box
Virgil W.Verified
I was very happy with these delicious treats. They’re large enough for us to share and others to enjoy. Brownies that are made the way I like them. Rich, chewy and I was able to keep them for a week or so without freezing. I kept them on the refrigerator and placed them in the microwave to heat them. Very good product!
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Charlene F.Verified
Everything was so delicious! I just didn’t realize how big the brownies were so I cut them in half and froze them.
I will definitely be ordering again and telling everyone I know how delicious Buckeye is!
The Independence Bundle Pack
George M.Verified
These brownies are absolutely divine! The texture is perfectly fudgy, with just the right balance of richness and moisture. The outer edges are slightly crisp, while the inside stays wonderfully dense and gooey. Each bite is packed with deep, chocolatey flavor that’s not too sweet, making it feel indulgent but not overwhelming. Whether you’re a chocolate lover or just someone with a sweet tooth, these brownies are a must-try. They strike the perfect balance between decadence and satisfaction. Hi...
The MVP 4-Pack
James B.Verified
Insane. All kinds of companies marketing sweet treats that they ship online these days, but nothing really matches up to Buckeye Brownies… If I wanted to become a fat piece of shit, I’d be ordering regularly. Keep it up!
Limited Edition Holiday Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 1/2
Amanda B.Verified
My niece loves the gluten free Buckeye Brownies. I have bought the gluten free Buckeye Brownies for my niece 2x's. She absolutely loves them and cannot believe they're GF. Her Fav sweet tooth fix are Buckeye Brownies!!
Gluten Free Box
Beth W.Verified
The brownies arrived quick and fresh. I have only eaten 1 because at half pound each that is too much. The first one I had was the triple berry and it was yummy.
Order Protect
Ross B.Verified
I hate when companies pester you over and over for a review. That being said, Buckeye Brownies were amazing. They are quite the feast and will last a while if you freeze them. Definitely worth the price.
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Zayne S.Verified
Thank you so much!! I don't EVER order online. Just not a technology kinda guy. But I'm so glad I ordered your brownies. Absolutely amazing and I can't wait to order another batch!
Order Protect
David P.Verified
I only ordered these brownies because they are from my hometown of Akron, Ohio—and let me tell you, they made the 600 mile trip like little champions. One bite in and my whole family went quiet… which never happens. That’s how you know they’re magic. Very fresh, and dangerously delicious. I honestly don’t know if I should thank you or blame you for the fact that we demolished the box in record time. Either way—we’ll be ordering again.
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Linda T.Verified
I am so happy to have found these delicious treats! I am trying all the flavors and have loved them all! They are such a delicious combination of brownie, cake, cookie and topping. I love how dense they are and although they are rich they are not too overly sweet. Fantastic!
Order Protect
Larry P.Verified
I have ordered twice now and I absolutely love them! I have shared them with my friends and family and they all ask where did you get these! Of course I let them know!
Order Protect
Jessica V.Verified
2nd year in a row getting the thanksgiving box and was not disappointed. Could eat my weight in the sweetie pie brownie, would love to have a whole box of just those next year. The other flavors were great too but the sweet potato one is my favorite
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Alexis W.Verified
These were some of my favorite brownies. The fidgey texture, the brownie base, the fact that they were/are brownie cups and cookies and cream made the taste even more delicious
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Kathy S.Verified
I was very pleased with my order. It was absolutely delicious. I will definitely be re-ordering the next time. I would like to try the brownies. I’m sure they’ll be just as delicious. I highly recommend.
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Cara A.Verified
cake pack was great. I liked all of them. Ted Velevet and the butter blondey were my favorite. Cheesecake one was good as well however the peacan one was a bit too nutmegy for me. It was still really good.
DO NOT reheat in the microwave. I tried both methods and the oven is so much better. The microwave will overcook some parts of the brownie making it hard, but the oven heats it evenly. The package says 5 min but i end up putting it in for about 10 because i like the inside to be a little bit...
Limited Edition Cake Pack
Karen T.Verified
Excellent brownies, more than expected. Very moist, tasty, sweet and they last forever. It was so much that I ate it over a week and a half taking little pieces. I loved the Oreo brownies most of all. It was packed full of goodness.
I would recommend this to anyone wanting quality and taste. I will definitely reorder more in the future. Keep making excellent brownies.
Pick Two
Lori A.Verified
It took extra time to receive my package from the post office, but the products were GREAT!! I will be a return customer! The No-Bake Buckeyes are my favorite, followed by the Lemon Haze and the Terrifically Twix then Coffee Crumble Delight. Sorry, I’m not a big choco-holic. Next, I cannot wait to try the Snickerdoodle and the Mr. Buckeye.
Order Protect
Andrea O.Verified
It was amazing!! I bought it for my husband for Christmas and he loved it ❤️ we couldn't eat everything, so we froze some of it, then thawed them and ate it as we wanted. I highly recommend this to anyone who loves sugary sweet delightful treats 😀
The Experience Box
Larry C. O.Verified
I have had a chance to try only two of the four, but they are delicious! A great special treat for that favorite someone in your life. I hope you have one!
Order Protect
Katie B.Verified
This was my first order and my family really enjoyed it. We made sure to warm them up prior to eating. The Triple Berry was our favorite. Looking forward to trying out other flavors.
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Tammi D.Verified
I wish I could give better review... I ordered the brownie 4 pk, 2 different cookie 6 pks, and the buckeye PB cupcakes for my husband's birthday. They arrived on his birthday, BUT..... we all ended up sick before we could try everything. Nothing tastes right, right now to give an accurate and honest review.
It's been 5 days and we are all still sick. Everything will probably be bad by the time we feel better. Can I freeze them?
Tammi D
Order Protect
Gary H.Verified
My wife and I loved the brownies. Extremely flavorful and we can’t wait to eat the next one but we are pacing ourselves due to how rich they are. We don’t want to become a small blimp.
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Nathan F.Verified
Absolutely love these brownies. Do you by any chance have a banana bread brownie in the works? I would be very interested in getting my hands on some of those.
Order Protect
Dawn C.Verified
I made this order for my grandson, he saw your ad on tik tok. So he called me and asked could I bring him some because I live in Ohio. So I did one better I mailed him his own order to New York. He my daughter and his friends loved the brownies. So it was a huge hit!!! Yes I will be making another order soon.
Fantastic Four Pack
James E.Verified
Great experience. I have never ordered anything from them that has not turned out to be amazing. My initial order was ruined by the delivery service, and the Buckeye staff was insistent that they be allowed to fix the order free of charge. I told them that there was no need as it wasn't theor fault, but they wouldn't take no for an answer. Will definitely be ordering again!
The Independence Bundle Pack
Sheri A.Verified
I ordered the new sugar cookies, the peanut butter cup brownies and the MVP Brownies! I had ordered the MVP Brownies before, so I already knew those were gonna be amazing. I dove right into to one of the sugar cookies and let me say, I was NOT disappointed. It was bigger than the palm of my hand, so soft and so delicious, the white chocolate chips were a great idea. The peanut butter cup brownies? OMG!! I didn't think I would be able to eat a whole one as it is so big however once I took...
Order Protect
Dave C.Verified
These were some of the best brownies that I ever had! I have had some wonderful homemade brownies but these were thick and heavy witch made me eat so much less even though they were fantastic! The taste and consistency was fantastic! They weren't like eating air filled very light homemade brownies! I will be ordering more!
Order Protect
Anthony C.Verified
I loved every single brownie and blondie in the Black Friday pack. Campfire Crunch and Almond Sugar were my favorites from this bunch. Cookie Monster and Butter My Biscoff are awesome too.
Black Friday Box
Enrique H.Verified
I was able to double up on flavors I already enjoy and get new ones I never tried so that’s probably the best part about the build your own box.
Build Your Box
Stephen S.Verified
As great as they look, they taste even better! The different ingredients compliment each other and enhance the overall flavor. I tried the Fourth of July bundle, and they were all delicious… and I was kind of partial to the s’mores brownie myself!😋
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store