Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Stephen S.Verified

As great as they look, they taste even better! The different ingredients compliment each other and enhance the overall flavor. I tried the Fourth of July bundle, and they were all delicious… and I was kind of partial to the s’mores brownie myself!😋

Limited Edition Fourth of July Box

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Summer Celebration Box

Kyle S.

Best Brownies in the Game 🤯 Reasonable shipping time, great packaging, insane tasting brownies! Plus they freeze & thaw + reheat very well!

Limited Edition Summer Celebration Box

Laura M.Verified

We've loved everything we've tried so far. The brownie cups were so good. Every brownie we've tried, we loved. What we haven't tried are closed up in the freezer for another day.

Order Protect

Linda F.Verified

I ordered more than I could eat. They look so good. My family loves them. Heating them up in the oven made them ooey and gooey and just amazing. Unfortunately, I had to have a tooth removed, so I've yet to try them. I get to hear hi, how good they are from my family and I can't wait to try them in a month. I like how there's instructions in the box on storage for future consumption.

Order Protect

Trevor G.Verified

Skeptical at first because promo videos be muscular dudes saying how good the brownies are so I’m thinking that they are protein brownies like probably not sweet at all …….. wrong these are really sweet and great brownies and it’s hard for me being from Michigan to give credit to something called buckeye brownies but congratulations these are really good I’m about to order more

Order Protect

Adrian G.Verified

I sent these brownies as a gift to a friend for their birthday and they loved them! These brownies helped to make their birthday a special one and they loved every single one! I will be ordering more, and next time they will all be for me!

Order Protect

Timothy F.Verified

I love the variety of this delicious package! Each brownie so massive, you can cut it in multiple pieces and still have plenty to share. I was a big fan of the chocolate peanut butter!! All four flavors were amazing! I would absolutely recommend this purchase.

Limited Edition Fourth of July Box

Dereck M.Verified

The costumer service that this company has is probably the best out there no competition. They deliver the package week sealed and right on time unlike other snack companies. The brownies that I order were good I rate them a solid 8 just because the one I ordered was Oreo cheesecake and it didn’t really have a cheese cake flavor it was more like a doughy texture. I had better the MVP, and the PB one is better in my opinion. But I am grateful for the help that you guys provided me for my order an...

Order Protect

Ryan B.Verified

All flavors came as described and were excellent. My next order will definitely be a build your own box. Huge fan of buckeye brownies. Bulking season must haves 💪🏽🥇

Limited Edition Fourth of July Box

Bryan L.Verified

Great experience with customer service delivery and the brownies were excellent. I've ordered from buckeye brownies several times and they have not disappoint. Thank u and I'll be ordering again soon.

Order Protect

Garrison W.Verified

I got the box for my friend who is gluten intolerant. She gave the Buckeye an 8.5/10 and the snickerdoodle 9/10. I’m not allergic to gluten myself but I’d say the Buckeye 7/10 and the snickerdoodle 8/10, compared to the originals.

Sweet Specialty Gluten Free Box

Customer video review of Limited Edition July Pack

Leif M.Verified

I love the July box so much and the grandmas blueberry cobbler was the best one for sure for me for all the other ones were not far behind!

Limited Edition July Pack

Jelani S.Verified

The Cookies and Creme Fudge Cups are 10/10!!! They were much bigger than I expected them to be and the brownie flavor is rich and moist. I will be ordering them again ASAP

The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Lavar F.Verified

The taste and quality of the cookies and brownies are top notch and I'm enjoying them with some good vanilla ice cream. I will order from Buckeye again in the near future. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!

Order Protect

Kenneth M.Verified

Brownies were amazing as I got the Christmas ones I still have two in the freezer but all the brownies are always amazing and very filling I love the variety can't wait to see what you guys come up with next for January

Order Protect

Darrelle P.Verified

I got myself the brownies as a reward to the end of a 10-week prep for my first figure show and they did not disappoint. The middles were gooey, just like I like them and the edges were crispy. A great contrast of textures and delicious flavors.

Fantastic Four Pack

Aaron D.Verified

Everything tasted great! The oreo brownies are super rich - had to cut up in pieces. The reese cup mashups were my favorite honestly. All the brownies were fantastic! My only recommendation is to turn the large brownies into 4 smaller versions - It would allow easier sharing and sampling each of the brownies ordered.

Holiday Bundle Pack

Donna D.Verified

These brownies were highly anticipated, and they did not disappoint! We loved the snickerdoodle one so much I plan to get it as a birthday cake for my partner in June!! She also would like those fudgy, peanut butter cups, so that's going into the cart as well. All four of the brownies were scrumptious, but everyone will have a favorite. Thanks again for the quality and the fast shipping! Will be calling on you again soon!!

Order Protect

Jodie B.Verified

I haven't tried the brownies yet, they are in the freezer. I did look at them, they look amazing!!! I tried the No-Bake peanut butter bombs - definitely AMAZING!!! I WILL be getting those again!! THANK YOU!!!

Order Protect

Joshua A.Verified

The no bake cookies are some of my favorite. Wish there was either peanut butter (or more if there’s any in it) or some salt just to balance it out (very sweet) the added pb cup on top is great.

No Bake Buckeye Bombs

Sydney S.Verified

my second time ordering from buckeye brownies and i love them!!!! i find that 5mins in the oven at 350 isn’t enough, but that could be more of an oven issue LOL. i just keep them in for a bit longer until they hit the gooey stage <3

Order Protect

Patricia E.Verified

My daughter competed in a swim suit competition. Training from Oct 2023-May 2024. This was a request of hers to eat!! Thank you!

Order Protect

Barbara H.Verified

I have never in my 73 years tasted a treat so delicious. Every brownie I have tried has been amazing. I thought I had a favorite, and then you have a new flavor, and it changes. I grabbed a deal you had, and figured we would be set for a bit. That was maybe 2 wks ago. Haa. The brownies were eaten as fast as we could. We tried to hide them in the freezer, and would take them frozen, cut off a chunk, and eat them. I used 4 pieces for my birthday cake, and my family wants to know when the ...

Order Protect

Greg R.Verified

This was the second time I ordered. First order was sent to my brother Greg and this last order sent to my sister in law Nancy. While I have never tried Buckeye brownies, my family raves about them.

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Fantastic Four Pack

Malia R.Verified

Firstly, when I ordered, I chose the incorrect address and immediately reached out to customer support and Mr. Buckeye make the correction instantly which was the best customer service. The overall taste of the brownies were good, I prefer my brownies cold so I put them in the fridge first but they weren’t bad heated either. Would I buy them again ? Perhaps in other flavors, my favorite from the four was the one with Oreo cookie and chocolate. The sale on the was appreciated.

Fantastic Four Pack

Deshaune B.Verified

It took a little while for my order to come. But the wait was worth it. Everything tasted fresh and I can tell it was made to order. My definite favorite was the MVP but everything else was delicious 10 out of 10.

Rush Baking

Vickie B.Verified

These brownies are so good. I love the peanut butter brownie. I like the snickerdoodle brownie. My son likes the brownies, all the brownies. This is gonna be a problem for me, I just can’t help myself.

Order Protect

Cam R.Verified

I genuinely loved the cookies and dream. There was nothing quite like it! I'm halfway done with my box, bet the other 2 flavors of the March Madness pack are just as good!

Order Protect

Sam A.Verified

All of these were delicious! I take these to work and we share, and the strawberry cheesecake was a huge hit. The hot fudge and chocolate chip muffin ones were also hits.

Limited Edition Summer Celebration Box

Cynthia J.Verified

Brownies were delicious, but FedEx failed to deliver on the expected date on Saturday It arrived at the facility for delivery, but was not loaded. It was then on a hot truck all day on Monday, before finally being delivered Monday. That was disappointing, but I blame FedEx.

No Bake Buckeye Bombs

Alissa N.Verified

I received my order the other day and they were the biggest brownies ever. So good in fact I have to cut my brownies by piece and have one every day cuz I’m diabetic and I do have to watch my sugar but other then that they are very good very soft and moist. Kudos 🤜🏻🤛🏻👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Order Protect

Cheryl H.Verified

sent them to my kids. They are enjoying them. Website was a bit confusing in that I was not exactly sure what each brownie entailed unless it was obvious, like a Smores or Butterfinger type.

Order Protect

Goran V.Verified

I ordered this for my daughter and roommates for delivery in Rhode Island. They absolutely loved the brownies and cookies. Would definitely order again. Thanks for all your help with the order

Order Protect

Patricia F.Verified

These are the absolute best brownies I have ever tasted in my life. They may even be the best dessert I’ve ever had. I absolutely will re-order. I shared your post and bragged about the brownies on my Facebook page as well.

Order Protect

Trevor D.Verified

Got the July 4th Box and it was a huge hit! There was something for everyone; This was my 3rd time trying Buckeye Brownies and I’ll be back for more 💯

Order Protect

Ian R.Verified

These quarter-pound brownie cups are ultra-fudgy, packed with chocolate chips, and topped with vanilla glaze and crushed Oreos for the perfect cookies-and-cream hit. Warm them up for 15-30 seconds in the microwave they turn irresistibly gooey and melty, making them even better. 9/10 addictive single serve indulgence! 🍫🖤

The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Robert D.Verified

Offered free brownies one or two days later felt I should have got them. Only because maybe I just saw the wrong advertisement when I purchased. It wasn't on all the ads. Great product though for when I'm in the brownie mood again

Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack

Erika K.Verified

Absolutely love these brownies! This is my second order & am again blown away by these enormous, decadent, high quality brownies. The flavors are unusual, creative & on point. Price is a bit high but worth it. Will definitely order again. I recommend possibly adding more fruit flavors to your summer collection.. maybe banana, strawberry & other berries?

Order Protect

Deshawn B.Verified

It was delicious the MVP was my favorite one everything else was good too it wasn't tasteless flavorless dry or bland like everyone else be saying cause it seems to be good to me it's just that the brownies are thick and BIG !!!! but anyway so i will be back to make future orders again

Order Protect

Jennifer S.Verified

Love getting to pick flavors to try. The brownies are really good and they are huge. Love that they give you on instructions for freezing them so they don't go bad.

Build Your Box

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store