Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Visit store
Cindy Z.Verified
The packaging was very nice. Loved the paper that came w the description of each kind. As well as the storage instructions. Taste each one was different and wow they were good, im not a brownie gal but there was very tasty. I cut them up and stored them in the freezer to share at Easter
Order Protect
Cynthia J.Verified
Brownies were delicious, but FedEx failed to deliver on the expected date on Saturday It arrived at the facility for delivery, but was not loaded. It was then on a hot truck all day on Monday, before finally being delivered Monday. That was disappointing, but I blame FedEx.
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Adrianna M.Verified
I ordered a 4 pack for my boyfriend’s birthday and they arrived so quickly! Perfect timing for his birthday! We loved them, seriously so good! We will definitely be ordering again in the future!
Rush Baking
Carlos T.Verified
Amazing cookies, sadly I didn’t get a picture of them because they were gone so soon! You can either have them at room temp or slightly warm, either is amazing.
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
Angel B.Verified
More impressed than I thought. More brownie than I thought. But presentation from opening the box wasn't the greatest. Seeing the brownie in a plastic bag doesn't seem that appetizing. Other than that 9/10.
Fantastic Four Pack
Stephanie P.Verified
Sent these as a valentine treat to my youngest at college. He absolutely loved each of the flavors. They arrived on time and while I felt the order was somewhat pricey, he said they were definitely worth the cost because they were huge! The different flavor combinations were outstanding and I love that I was able to choose four that suited his taste. I will definitely be ordering from you again in the future.
Limited Edition February Box
Jerad H.Verified
My wife loves cookie butter and she loved your bishoff brownie. Not to mention it’s from Ohio and we love to support Ohio small businesses as we own one too.
Build Your Box
Carrie L.Verified
I sent these as a gift. I added the personalized card. The website wouldn't let me add the message but I reached out to Zach and they remedied right away for me. Service was impeccable and brownies delicious.
Order Protect
Goran V.Verified
I ordered this for my daughter and roommates for delivery in Rhode Island. They absolutely loved the brownies and cookies. Would definitely order again. Thanks for all your help with the order
Order Protect
Patricia F.Verified
These are the absolute best brownies I have ever tasted in my life. They may even be the best dessert I’ve ever had. I absolutely will re-order. I shared your post and bragged about the brownies on my Facebook page as well.
Order Protect
Ian R.Verified
These quarter-pound brownie cups are ultra-fudgy, packed with chocolate chips, and topped with vanilla glaze and crushed Oreos for the perfect cookies-and-cream hit. Warm them up for 15-30 seconds in the microwave they turn irresistibly gooey and melty, making them even better. 9/10 addictive single serve indulgence! 🍫🖤
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Terrence M.Verified
I ordered from 2 times already and the the shipping was fast the protection for my for my purchase was great I definitely appreciate you and I definitely will purchase more I found my new go to for sweets💪🏽💯
Order Protect
Jeffrey S.Verified
I love peanut butter cookie's as well as Reese’s. They got this cookie spot on with chocolate in the middle surrounded by a peanut butter cookie. I freeze my cookies like them cold!! Delicious
Perfectly Peanut Butter Cookies
Don A.Verified
This box was Amazing. The Butterfinger one was the ⭐. Tuxedo was also A+. The Apple one was really good, could've used more Apple Flavor. The Blueberry was a sleeper hit. Reminded the family of a bigger, less sweet gourmet Pop tart, which is a good thing. All and All. 5⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐.
Limited Edition Fathers Day Box
Michelle S.Verified
Wow! The brownies were alot bigger then I even expected. We were able to cut them into 4 pieces and and those pieces were still a good size. We also ordered cookies and received brownie cups for being a first time buyer Everything was delicious.
Build Your Box
Misty L.Verified
Some reviewers say they’re too bland and others say they’re too sweet. I found both to be true. The snickerdoodle was just right (not bland just not loaded with sugar) and my favorite. The MVP was really sweet (I guess the extra Oreos added the sugar spike🤪). Zack provided great customer service to an issue my order came across and made sure I received it quickly.
Fantastic Four Pack
Kelly G.Verified
I/We Absolutely Loved each and everyone of the Brownies we received!! I bought 8 brownies, 3 I kept for myself and my fiance and the other 5 I gave to my Daughter, her Husband and my Grandkids for Valentines Day. She said they all devoured them. I am ordering more for my Son's Birthday, who lives in another State. Kudos to this Wonderful Company for making such a Delicious Product!!!
Rush Baking
Robert D.Verified
Offered free brownies one or two days later felt I should have got them. Only because maybe I just saw the wrong advertisement when I purchased. It wasn't on all the ads. Great product though for when I'm in the brownie mood again
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Bryant G.Verified
Oh my goodness there brownies were good! I have for the past few days been cutting pieces off to have for desert and I can’t but help to think about the next slice. Butterfinger, and Valentine’s Day one were the best! I want more and will buy more in the future!
Order Protect
Deshawn B.Verified
It was delicious the MVP was my favorite one everything else was good too it wasn't tasteless flavorless dry or bland like everyone else be saying cause it seems to be good to me it's just that the brownies are thick and BIG !!!! but anyway so i will be back to make future orders again
Order Protect
Brian W.Verified
The brownies were amazing. We got the fantastic four. They are big and delicious. My favorite was Mr. Buckeye but they were all good. We split them up between all of us and there was enough for everyone to try one. Will buy again!
Order Protect
Jennifer S.Verified
Love getting to pick flavors to try. The brownies are really good and they are huge. Love that they give you on instructions for freezing them so they don't go bad.
Build Your Box
Trent K.Verified
The brownies were amazing and huge! Some of the best I’ve ever had. Our family of four ate the for a week! Pro tip- toss them in the microwave for 20 seconds to warm them. You won’t be sorry!
Order Protect
Donna B.Verified
Have to say the bombs might be my favorite. I’m not sharing them! I took one box of my brownie to work and share and two squares were gone immediately with the girls saying this is mine!! Needless to say the other two square didn’t last the day. I might share a couple more but the rest are totally mine. Will be ordering again. Thanks so much. delicious everything
Order Protect
Terria J.Verified
Size of each brownie is very impressive. I like that they are not as sweet as I had anticipated. Delicious sampling of the four flavors. Highly recommend for everyone to try these out. So far, the oreo brownie is my favorite from the sampling.
Limited Edition September Pack
Jesse L.Verified
The September pack was very lovely my favorite being the apple pie and mr tuxedo with no unpleasant one in the pack. They were quite delicious, they were large enough for me to cut up and split with friends and family. Will be ordering from you again.
Limited Edition September Pack
Jessica M.Verified
I got the Christmas edition box and the brownie cups with the crushed Oreos. The package came a couple of days late but not no big deal. The look and smell amazing! They’re still super soft and delicious even though they were late. I will definitely be ordering more!
Order Protect
Ann M.Verified
They were delicious 😋 I do recommend them to anyone who likes brownies. I had to split mine in 3 pieces and shared it my kids. I just wanted to taste them. And I will place my second order soon.
Build Your Box
Tevin C.Verified
The delivery was good even though it took a little over a week to arrive, The brownies are large which is what caught my eye in the first place and they taste amazing. Will definitely be ordering more in the future.
Order Protect
Todd F.Verified
I got these for my daughter and future son in law. They absolutely loved them , they had a hard time finishing them , it took them almost 10 days. My daughter said they were huge and she was happy with the GF selection, her boyfriend said the same thing, I did ask her and she said they were definitely 10/10. I will be definitely ordering from you again
Order Protect
Dawn W.Verified
As a sweet potato lover, this brownie did not miss. ❤️❤️. Also, after heating the "banana pudding" brownie, and having to walk by others, the aroma had heads turning and asking who/what/where??? Yes, that great!!
Build Your Box
Steven W.Verified
Halloween Pack 5 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ for Halloween! Perfectly Pumpkin and The Dark Knight are the best flavors in the box. 📦 I always love this time of the year when these flavors come out and I get the ones that I miss and can’t get cause their is so much coming out of the bakery in just this 1 month. 😆🎃💯👍
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Sharon M.Verified
I ordered a build-a-box with 2 pumpkins and 2 Twix brownies. As I stated on another review, the pumpkin has a nice fall flavor. Not overly sweet. I had a piece with my morning Mushroom coffee. The terrificly Twix was AMAZING! My absolute fave so far. I am so disappointed that it was only offered on the site for a few days. The same for the Bugs Bunny. I went back to order whole boxes of both and they were not available. The Twix tastes like a Twic bar in steroids. The caramel mixed with the c...
Build Your Box
Terrence M.Verified
I've been ordering from buckeye brownies for a while now and it's always a great experience shipping is fast and protected I will definitely continue to buy from here thanks
Order Protect
Jennifer H.Verified
These brownies were AmAzInG!!!!! Warmed up in the oven to give them the gooey goodness method was preferred but they were also good out of the fridge! You can’t go wrong with these brownies. I will definitely be ordering again!
Order Protect
Lehland B.Verified
I seen these brownies on TikTok. People kept showing up on my FYP taking big bites and talking about how good these where soooo, I said," Let me see what these brownies talking bout"..I was correct to try these brownies. Your company is worth the hype! Well done!!
Bugs Bunny 4-Pack - September’s Flavor of the Month
Dr S.Verified
I bought them for my family in Pittsburgh and the loved them, especially the Pumpkin ones. I want to order more for Thanksgiviging for the family gathering. I highly recommend that if you like amazing brownies, GET YA SOME!! You can thank me later.
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Dale N.Verified
The wrapping of the brownies were perfect. The brownies were well packaged to keep critters from getting a hold of the package just in case you're not home when delivered.
Order Protect
Willie A.Verified
I really loved the Dark Knight Oreo theme brownie I am a big fan of Oreo flavored food. These brownies are so good it’s like you have to keep coming back for more once you tasted them.
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Philippe C.Verified
They were so good, I had to cut them up and put them in the freezer so I would only take a couple a day. After trying 1/16 of a brownie from the freezer, it felt like cocaine. I binged easily over 16 small pieces amongst the 4 flavors and went into a buckeye coma. This happened 2 more nights in a row where I finally decided these are too good for me to have and threw the remainder out. Needless to say they're INCREDIBLE tasting
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store