Rick K.Verified
Great communication, answered any questions that I had in regards to the order. I sent as a gift for Valentine’s Day and it was absolutely loved. Definitely a high-quality product.
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
Ofelia M.Verified
The brownies were a gift for my husband. He is from Ohio and said he missed these big stuffed brownies he used to buy. I found Buckeye Brownies and thought he would appreciate your products. So far he has eaten the Biscoff cookie butter flavor, the Little Debbie Valentine's cakes flavor and the Butterfinger flavor. Luckily, he was willing to share with me and our 2 kids. The brownies are big enough to satisfy the whole family. We look forward to digging into the Oreo brownie next. Thank you for ...
Order Protect
Terrilee W.Verified
They are delicious- heated up for 30 secs and they melt in your mouth- and even though they look super sweet- they aren't. Perfect blend of sweet without being overpowering.
Fantastic Four Pack
Rashawn B.Verified
I will say these are the best brownies I have ever tasted! All of the different flavors and combinations are excellent! Definitely 11 out of 10 and you will continue to see my orders coming in! 👍🏽
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
Jacob A.Verified
By far the best thing I’ve ordered from buckeye brownies and I’ve been ordering from them for years so it says a lot about how good this is. Highly recommend!
Blackout Oreo Cookie Cake
Misty A.Verified
I cut them up in little pieces so me and my husband can enjoy them. Since we can’t really have a lot of the sweetness. I actually put them in vacuum seal bags and put them in the freezer and take them out when we want to enjoy them.
February Bundle Pack
Ricky P.Verified
There's an old adage, you get what you pay for!... and let me tell you, nothing but rich, amazing flavors. Size so large, you'd feel like a fat person if you ate it in one setting. Can easily be cut into 4 pieces for medium size desserts. Definitely buying again!!
Order Protect
Rachel M.Verified
What a great experience with your baked goods. Was a huge hit at the party event I bought the brownies for. Decadent? For sure. Worth it? Definitely! I do intend to buy again. Just fresh and delicious. Packing was on spot and shipping was fine and on time. I recommend to anyone who would wish to buy something extraordinarily special. Especially for a significant occasion with that significant someone. Every brownie at my get together was enjoyed. I say to those online, buy from this company. N...
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Angela D.Verified
I must have missed the fine print statement prior to ordering about 4-7 business days for your order to be made after order is placed. Then you get the one day shipping. I did see it after payment & submitting the order but it was too late at that point to change myself. However, Customer service was very responsive by email and quickly changed the shipping address since we were going out of town and wanted this delicious treat for our family getaway. They were a huge hit and everyone loved them...
Build Your Box
Travis C.Verified
This might’ve been my favorite mix yet! I’ve never had treats that I consistently order online because my fam and I love them so much but here we are with Buckeye Brownies!!
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Deborah H.Verified
The Experience Bundle went over really well. I think you may get some new customers out of this. My oldest son took the Brownie Bombs to work and they went over quite well. The 4 pk. Of brownies were cut into fourths and the cookies were cut in half then taken to a family get together. I heard people saying how great they tasted...
I will gladly purchase again since they were such a hit. You won me over long ago
The Experience Bundle
Jaime G.Verified
My first time ordering Buckeye Brownies was worth it! They arrived in a timely manner and are super delicious. The size of each brownie was enormous! I was able to share with lots of people. I will definitely be ordering again.
Order Protect
Kylie M.Verified
So nice to be able to choose what brownie you want!! I’m allergic to nuts so being able to get a nut free box was amazing! :)) So yummy, I will order again!
Build Your Box
Lauren M.Verified
I watched so many reviews on these brownies, so I had to try them for myself. They did not disappoint! All the flavors were delicious- I will absolutely be purchasing more!
Fantastic Four Pack
Alan G.Verified
Shipping is fast even to California. The brownies were good the summer collection, but not as good as the 4th July brownies. Still very much like the brownies but my waist tells me to slow down.
Rush Baking
India E.Verified
Good as always, but kinda sucked that my 500 reward points for this free Fantastic Four pack wasn't really free since $2.00 was still charged for the brownies themselves. Just a minor critique, though
Fantastic Four Pack
Marcus B.Verified
All the brownies were good😀 Took them to three different places! The first place was the school were I volunteer, and the kids loved them. Then to work! Finally at home were I had family over , so they are all gone. So it’s time for so more😀😀
Order Protect
Michelle S.Verified
First time Customer. Definitely enjoy the brownies warmed up in the microwave. The ooiey gooeyiness of all the ingredients flavors is amazing and delicious. The Customer Service is beyond excellent. I definitely would suggest trying these wonderful brownies for anyone that has a sweet tooth.
Fantastic Four Pack
Nicholas T.Verified
They were delicious each one was stood on its own taste and flavor. They were an enjoy to eat, my favorite one was tuxedo and the M&M and cookie bears.
Limited Edition September Pack
Brianna V.Verified
The birthday cake brownie was my favorite, I’m definitely ordering it again. The mvp was delicious as well. I tried the Girl Scout cookie one and it tasted really good but it was just a little too sweet for me but I don’t like very sweet things so I assumed I wouldn’t be able to eat that much of it. I’m definitely gonna be ordering another box though. 10/10
Build Your Box
James G.Verified
Buckeye Brownies never fail.
Ordered the MVP (10/10), Terrificlly Twix (8/10), Butterfinger AF (10/10), and Cupids Cake (7/10).
I received the Butter My Biscoff (8/10) instead of Butterfinger AF, but they corrected it instantly.
This company is awesome and my diet is now forever ruined.
Order Protect
Jordan J.Verified
I wish I could show a picture or video but it’s long gone. That pebbles n cream was amazing especially when it’s warmed up, 10/10 wish they kept it year round tho.
Pebbles & Cream 4-Pack - October Flavor of the Month
Tinamarie M.Verified
These are big and moist and full of yummy goodness ! They are packed with flavor ! I have ordered several times and have not been disappointed at all! They have a forever customer in me ! Please try these amazing brownies and share with someone you love !
Mr Buckeye 4-Pack
Shawn A.Verified
I absolutely loved these brownies!! Even though you don't need to heat them up to eat them, I highly recommend that you do, I feel like the brownies are more flavorful when heated up.
Limited Edition September Pack
Linda T.Verified
These “brownies” are so much more than just brownies. They are a truly delicious treat that has to be tried to understand how scrumptious they truly are. It says to warm them, but I like them right out of the box. They are dense and sweet—but not too sweet—and very filling with just part of the whole brownie. I am definitely a fan and can’t wait to try other flavors.
Limited Edition Holiday Pack
Sam H.Verified
I loved it i don't have any pics other wise I would have sent but I'm a planing on ordering some this Friday I'll definitely post on my Instagram an send you guys a pic
Ravenous Red Velvet Oreo Brownie Cake
Tina T.Verified
Delicious! Pop it in the microwave for a few seconds and it taste like it came out of the oven. I don't like my desserts too sweet and the brownies to me has just the right amount of sweetness. Will be ordering again.
Fantastic Four Pack
Chris J.Verified
I absolutely love Buckeye brownies! This order is for me and I will be enjoying them this weekend. My previous order, I drove all the way to Kincardine Ontario to give as a gift to my girlfriend. One of the gifts for our 1yr Anniversary! She loved them and even shared some of it with her co-workers at her Law Firm in Toronto! They loved them as well!
Order Protect
Evelyn H.Verified
These chocolate chip cookies are the best we have ever had. The flavor is wonderful, and best of all not too sweet! Nothing to get in the way of tasting the flavor of the cookie. Will definitely order again!
Order Protect
Janet F.Verified
Had a hiccup with delivery , but Zack was quick with a response and sending out a fresh order.
They taste amazing. That was my second time ordering grandmas cholate chip. Not to sweet , soft and perfect size.
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
Susan K.Verified
We enjoy our Buckeye Brownies and we've shared them with a lot of our friends and all have like them. I enjoy mine just warmed for at the most about 12 seconds.
Holiday Bundle Pack
Justin T.Verified
Only took a picture of it in the box because once those wrappers came off one bite and they were devoured in seconds. Can’t wait to order more my niece who heard about it really wants to try them. Delicious brownies that are surprisingly moist upon opening. I can’t wait to try them warmed up. 4 flavors down more to go.
Order Protect
Bill P.Verified
Honestly the Best batch I’ve ordered! The Birthday box flavors are awesome. It’s really hard to choose a favorite, especially with the blondie’s. The flavors in the Lou and Sugar Almond are so good! Also, peanut butter paradise is even tastier than the original nutter butter version. I saw Septembers flavors and have been struggling not ordering again so soon. Cookie Monster brownie also rich and satisfying.
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
Steven W.Verified
1 of my favorite brownie cakes of the year that I’m still sorry isn’t on the menu lineup all the time. Ithink it’s better than cookies! 🍪
I like the flavor, the way it melts in my mouth and just the great overall taste of the brownie cake. Because all of the flavors come together when you’re eating it.
I can’t wait to see if we’re going to get some more red velvet cookies for this year! That would be great!
😱😆😆💯%⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️👍
Ravenous Red Velvet Oreo Brownie Cake
Traci Y.Verified
They were delicious!! I absolutely loved them all. The triple berry was amazing. I was shocked at how thick these brownies were. I could barely get my mouth around them to take a bite on the edges. Definitely ordering again!!
Order Protect
Angel A.Verified
We were a little let down by the brownies we ordered the first time but we decided to go ahead and try again and your fourth of July box totally made up for it all! The fourth of July box was absolute amazing! Thank you so very much!
Order Protect
Jonah J.Verified
There were so delicious I couldn't put them down, I loved the 4th of July box it was splendid and the peanut butter no bakes were just what I needed to get through the day, I'm a huge fan of peanut butter and chocolate. The Oreo cups were really rich and creamy when warmed and I had a blast, Im a big fan of area as well as it comes as my second go to sweets.
Order Protect
Cristal O.Verified
Amazingg brownies ! That Almond Sugar Is Something else. Highly recommended, perfect amount of sweetness & flavors. Definitely will purchase again. Also Buckeye brownies was sooooo kind enough to send me my brownies that were sadly damaged. Thank you so much <3
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
Ric T.Verified
I sent the 4th of July combo box to my mom for her birthday. She said it was amazing! So many great flavor combos. I live in Akron and Buckeye Brownies are my "go to" gift for friend and family.
Order Protect
Ethan G.Verified
All of the brownies were so good! Our personal faves were the Almond Sugar and the Campfire Crunch, but I did also throughly enjoy the Cookie Monster! Hoping to see these pop up again soon!
Black Friday Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store