Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack

Buda G.Verified

I was a bit afraid because the package came all the way to Hungary and it even got delayed by ups. But thank God all the brownies arrived as it was baked yesterday! I only managed to taste Hella Nutella, but boy oh boy it was fantastic! I'm sure I'll have the same opinion for the rest of the pack! Thank you so much guys! :)

Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack

John L.Verified

The brownies were amazing and super delicious! I wasn't expecting them to be so packed and heavy, they were great and I'm glad I got to build my own box and pick the 4 that I wanted to try the most.

Build Your Box

Andrew K.Verified

Opening up a buckeye box Is like opening a Christmas present! You guys never let me down, from the inventive combos To the amazing flavors!!! It’s hard not to want to eat the entire Box right away. Haha

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box

Shauna H.Verified

Wished I would have took more pictures I absolutely fkn love these! I’m obsessed with biscoff so I had to order the box for It lol 😂 I hate peanuts butter so didn’t eat that one. The Cookie Monster looking one was delicious and the BLUEBERRY WAS OUT OF THIS WORLD I wished I could just order that one It blew me away with the softness and blueberry taste so glad I ordered I’ll always be a customer (even If I’m supposed to be eating less 😂) shhh…. Try It you’ll love them. Please keep the blueberry ...

Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box

Salih Y.Verified

I absolutely loved it! I order mr peanut because my gf love peanut butter, I personally not big fan of peanut butter BUT GOD DAMN it was absolutely beautiful i found my self ate 2 of the brownies Im excited to be keep ordering for different flavors as well

Order Protect

Customer video review of Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack

Pat P.Verified

Down to my last two of the January limited edition fan favorite pack and the valentines edition pack, they were all so amazing, I will be devouring in the blueberry muffin one this Sunday night after my college wrestling tourney at lock haven!!

Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack

Justin G.Verified

I saw these on a tiktok channel I follow and I had to order a box and holy smokes what a treat, probably the coolest and most delicious brownies I've ever had and in my home state too!! I'm totally ordering another box and try some diff ones but loved the oreo and peanut 🥜 butter flavors, THANKS BUCKEYE BROWNIES!!

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Gregory R.Verified

My two athletes did a bodybuilding prep for 8 months! No cheating on their diet and I saw this company and thought they would absolutely love these after show! So I ordered them a box each and after their competition they tried them and got nothing but love for these brownies! 10/10

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Mark O.Verified

Amazing brownies and so much better than I was expecting. I was looking for a certain kind but didn’t see it. So tried the MVP and another I can’t remember. But both just are amazing. Still trying to finish them because they are super rich and tasty.

Pick Two

Justin R.Verified

Delivered during a hurricane and still all in one piece, the CEO Zack was amazing with communication and they were absolutely Ahhhhmazing exceeded my expectations and so glad I did the monthly shipment! They are HUGE! Pictures and videos do no justice! I have zero complaints! Each brownie was more than enough for 4 and I love to eat!

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Limited Edition September Pack

Brandon M.Verified

This was my first time ordering Buckeye Brownies and I really enjoyed the September pack. Although I expected to like it the least (because I am not a huge fan of peanut butter), the peanut butter and jealous was my favorite one. I hope to try another pack in the future!

Limited Edition September Pack

Antoine L.Verified

I've been ordering from Buckeye Brownies since January, February, or March of 2024 and I was very skeptical about ordering from them because I had never ordered any food or snacks from a business before let alone from another state. My skepticism was clean and the brownies were/are legit. I've been ordering for months on end and I am never left disappointed. The Mr. Tuxedo and the M&M Cookie Craze really hit the spot. You gotta drink milk with these brownies. 1/2lb brownies are no joke. You hav...

Build Your Box

Khalil W.Verified

The flavors were so amazing they were all made with care it was soo good bugs bunny especially I loved apply ever after and the peanut butter and jelly one it was so perfectly made and then the oreo one ugh it was my first time buying them and I will definitely get more for sure!!!

Limited Edition September Pack

Stacee K.Verified

This was my first time trying these treats and boy oh boy will I be a returning customer! After being on a strict diet for 16 weeks, this tasted like the Lord himself poured it into my mouth.

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of Peanut Butter S’mores 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 2/11

Christina B.Verified

These brownies were HUGE and packed full of flavor! I was almost tempted to eat them all. Loved the taste and was pleasantly surprised to find a hidden s’mores pop tart baked in these bad boys. This is the perfect treat yo self dessert and I would definitely order again.

Peanut Butter S’mores 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 2/11

Customer video review of Fantastic Four Pack

Shaun N.Verified

All four of the brownies in the Fantastic Four Pack exceeded my expectations. I thought they might be a little too rich and sweet, but to be honest, they were light on the stomach and delicious. I am already recommending them to my family and friends, and have just ordered another create your own box four pack. Excited to try more flavors, thank you for building this awesome business!

Fantastic Four Pack

Alicia B.Verified

Please please please bring back the butter my biscoff!!! I would purchase whole box or brownie cake with just that and so would my family. We would love them for family get together! Would love it if it became part of the permanent collection. I wasn't sure I'd like it and it ended up being the best brownie ever!!!

Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box

Manuel R.Verified

I am not a peanut or nuts fan so having the “build your own 4-pack” box option was the promotion that got me to place my first order. All 4 flavors were phenomenal! These are wife and kid approved with everyone giving two big thumbs up for Buckeye Brownies! We will be ordering again.

Build Your Box

Cynthia A.Verified

I ordered this pack for my nephew and family because he has helped so much with a cross country move.. when the ordered arrived he was shocked… BEST BROWNIES AND OTHER GOODIES EVER!!!

Order Protect

Customer video review of Butter My Biscoff 4-Pack - September Flavor of the Month

Genevieve W.Verified

Cookie butter is a good reason to get up in the morning. These Blondies are a great reason to byod to the party ( or eat them solo in a dark closet 😋😋😋).

Butter My Biscoff 4-Pack - September Flavor of the Month

Customer photo review of Christmas Cookie Collection

Samantha C.Verified

All showed up fresh, flavorful and as expected! They were a hit at work, I shared them with all of my coworkers (and snuck one to my husband) and everyone was floored with how good they were!

Christmas Cookie Collection

Customer photo review of The Classics - Pumpkin Roll Blondie Cups

Manuel R.Verified

The pumpkin roll blondie cups are a must have seasonal treat. The cream cheese frosting pairs amazingly well with the graham cracker crumb base. Had to place a 2nd order before they are gone for the season because they are that good.

The Classics - Pumpkin Roll Blondie Cups

Leigh Ann S.Verified

I’ve seen these all over TikTok and had to try them for myself! My family LOVED these! We eat them all up! If you’re thinking about trying them, do it! You won’t regret it!

Order Protect

Suzette H.Verified

I ordered two of one item but only got 1 of them. The cookie didn’t arrive in the best shape. I reached out and heard back very quickly. Both issues were resolved immediately with a speedy new shipment.

Order Protect

Sylvia G.Verified

They hit the spot 💯 % we loved 🥰 them . As you could see in the picture I actually had to write on the box . Next time I’m hiding it from my teen lol 😂, my husband’s favorite so far is the Resees Peanut Butter, my the snickerdoodle & apparently my teens as well . I will definitely be doing future orders. Im still waiting to see what my daughter says about her order ☺️

Order Protect

Matthew S.Verified

Hands down the best gourmet brownies you will come across. Zach and the crew really have it figured out! Great job everybody, they have a loyal customer from this guy!!

Order Protect

Customer video review of Limited Edition July Pack

Leo N.Verified

I have yet to taste a brownie from Buckeye Brownies that doesn't knock it out if the park. Almost every month I think they can't outdo themselves and then they do. These things are like a controlled substance, highly addictive. Absolutely recommended.

Limited Edition July Pack

Customer video review of Keeping It Cordial 4-Pack - July Flavor of the Month

Hector G.Verified

I love brownies and I can’t complain about them yet. A little 10 seconds warm up in the microwave goes along way. Of course I have my favorite ones but I can’t complain about the others.

Keeping It Cordial 4-Pack - July Flavor of the Month

Customer photo review of August Bundle Pack

Teresa F.Verified

Buckeye brownies is the best ever! Many times I buy it to share with people and they are amazed at how fabulous the brownies are and especially the Buckeye bombs!

August Bundle Pack

Customer photo review of Limited Edition July Pack

Ahmad H.Verified

Was very tasty. Just wish they didn’t arrive melted but put them in the fridge for half an hour and came back like they never melted. Never like anything blueberry but until I tried the blueberry brownie liked it a lot. Best flavor was the chocolate and the other one with gram ham crackers. Definitely gonna order again on my cheat day.

Limited Edition July Pack

Jayson J.Verified

Package came well prepared very indulging items. I really love the nutty buddy and I also like the junk package. I can’t really tell you which one was my favorite because they were both great.

Order Protect

Customer video review of Limited Edition Summer Starter Pack

Hector G.Verified

I purchased 1 box and had to order another one because my kids ate them all and I was watching my diet in those days that it arrived. So I had to order another one because they bragged about how delicious they were.

Limited Edition Summer Starter Pack

Steven S.Verified

I absolutely loved it, my favorite was the white chocolate with peanut butter. I'm definitely ordering again and pictures don't do the brownies themselves any justice. They are way more gorgeous in person. I cut each one in four and mixed them up with some ice cream for dessert.

Limited Edition July Pack

Carly B.Verified

We did this as a date night. We will be doing this once a month as our monthly date since we are hermits. We are in Love and we recommend these to everybody we know

Build Your Box

Theresa M.Verified

This was a Christmas gift for my son. He’s been asking me to buy them for almost 3 years now. He says they were totally worth the wait! 10/10!

Order Protect

Ashley N.Verified

I love the build your own box opportunity! There are always a few from different boxes I want to try and these were no exception! This was only my second order and I have already placed my third 😅

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Megan G.Verified

The Valentine assorted box was a BIG win for each of my college twin boys. Delivery was quick and easy. They said “I wouldn’t mind having that again” which if you know 19 year old boys is code for “that was awesome, thanks mom!” 😂

The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Jeremy K.Verified

Loved the butterscotch! I was really looking forward to the bugs bunny, but it was a bit dry. Ted Velvet was a better than I expected, and the blueberry crumb was great! About to order my 4th box.

Build Your Box

Bridget M.Verified

after a bodybuilding competition july 19th it was incredible taste well worth the wait , bought them a week out and put them in the freezer , took them out the night before and they were perfect 👌

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of February Bundle Pack

Jose S.Verified

WOW SURPRISED ON HOW GREAT IT ALL TASTED, I ALMOST ATE THE WHOLE THING WHEN IT ARRIVED HAD TO USE CONTROLL AND SAVE THE REST FOR THE NEXT DAY WILL ORDER AGAIN AND AGAIN

February Bundle Pack

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store