Renee S.Verified
This is just one of a variety that I bought.
They are the best brownies I've ever had.
Big enough to share with 4 people but I can totally eat one myself!!! 🥰
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Leebrian W.Verified
I absolutely demolished these brownies… love them so much that I’ve purchase two boxes this time. What perfect about them is I can eat them warm or room temp or even out of the refrigerator. My favorite is the MVP (warm) and grandma cobbler (cold) but thick than a snicker was a COMPLETE BEAST AND CAN BE EATEN EITHER WAY!
Build Your Box
+2Jon D.Verified
Delish!!! Oatmeal cookie, Nutella, milk and cookies, and butterfinger in a custom box. None were excessively sweet but rather just perfect to have with a nice old glass of milk. YUMMO
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Michael F.Verified
Oh hell yes I so loved the Triple 🫐 Berry Pie, and was shocked at how big and tasty they were and so heavy. I took me 9 days to eat 3, I gave one to my friends and they loved as well... 😍
Build Your Box
Daniel S.Verified
Love your Blondies! Please make Cupid’s Cake more readily available..it is easily your best one! Thank you so much! Sending big love from suburban Detroit,
The Shanle Family ❤️ 🍪
Pick Two
Thomas B.Verified
This is after opening my second box. Being in my mailbox for so long during the winter, they were practically frozen, but I still had to get a taste.
They were tasty.
So looking forward to eventually putting these in the oven for a decadent snack.
Limited Edition Cheesecake Box
Danielle S.Verified
Got another box to share with my co workers and they were gone in one day. The cupids cake with the little Debbie spoke to me but in all honesty we LOVED the peanut butter s’mores. I work at a casino resort and let a guest try a bite and he was like “ that’s a winner” 10/10 second time purchase
Order Protect
+2Rejana S.
Got the “build your box”… I always tell myself just one more bite but it’s never just one more, these are the most decadent brownies I’ve ever had! Definitely made a second order not even a week later
Build Your Box
Keith
I saw these brownies advertised on Instagram. I don't like a lot of baked goods made in the supermarket, and I'm not a patient baker in the kitchen. The brownies were amazing, and the peanut butter/chocolate combo are an excellent combo. Surprisingly, they weren't sickly sweet - a balanced sweetness. I will definitely order again!
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
Shelby S.
We were gifted a Buckeye Brownie at our body building show and it was the most amazing thing I think either of us had tasted. Ordering another (or several) for our next one too! Its our new tradition!!
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Victory H.
Got these for my boyfriend’s birthday and he and I absolutely loved them. I recently placed another order for him as one of his gifts for our anniversary. Unfortunately the shipping address wasn’t correct for some reason so I got a notification saying it was returned to the sender. I emailed buckeye brownies and they responded the next day redelivered the package for free as well added rush baking for free as well. Only thing I had to pay was the shipping fee but that wasn’t a problem at all. Th...
Build Your Box
Kelly R.
I haven't taste them yet (Body building competition in 2 1/2 weeks) but my husband tasted them and said they are delicious 😋 I'm sooo excited about taking a big bit out of all 4 when I get off the stage ☺️ I will be ordering again soon
Limited Edition Memorial Day Box
+4Melinda R.
These brownies are really delicious and they are really soft. This was my first time buying. These brownies and my family and I love
them. The shipping was very fast. I will be purchasing again.
M&M Express 4-Pack - April FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Michael M.
Always told myself "I'll order one day" and boy am I glad I ordered the March Madness Pack. Absolutely SMACKED!!! Smacked to much, I ordered the Easter Pack at 11:50 the Friday they were available!!! Buckeye Brownies has a forever fan and the Reviews will keep coming
Limited Edition March Madness Pack
+1Savoy W.
I've tried the brownies which were great but the no bake buckeye bombs are my absolute favorite. The chocolate oats and peanut butter together, I ate them by myself. It's so thick you can cut it in half, but my gluttony wouldn't allow me to do that.
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Rochelle K.Verified
I was super excited when they came, I was more excited the fantastic condition they were in. When I finally took a bite ( after nuking it for 15 seconds) I was HOOKED. I am a HUGE chocoholic and was over the moon over these.
Build Your Box
Antwan J.
These are some big A$$ brownies best brownies hands down my favorite so far is Mr buckeye I just feel like that fruity pebbles brownie I just ordered is gonna be my top #1
Pebbles & Cream 4-Pack - October Flavor of the Month
Robyn S.
These brownies are absolute delicious cold, hot, room temp, 110 degree car melted it doesn't matter. Still so good. I ordered 6 and they generously sent me 8. The extras aren't in the photo but we were beyond delicious. We were very satisfied and greatful for the timely order. Thank you Buckeye!
Fantastic Four Pack
Bao P.
These were the best brownies I’ve had so far! The quality, flavor, and thickness of it was so amazing I had to order the Christmas Pack! Can’t wait to do another review!
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Alya A.
The Halloween and trick or treat packs were THE BEST packs ever!! I was so sad that I couldn’t order them again on the clearance due to the time difference in my country. I will always be waiting for the flavors to come back in another pack!
Order Protect
Jessica B.
Came way faster than expected and very delicious! Definitely sweet enough for me while also having pretty complex flavors for a brownie! Would totally buy agin for a special occasion.
Fantastic Four Pack
Juan P.Verified
man them brownies was something else each one of them was unique in every bite was sensational will definitely have to get another 4 with different flavors 👍🏼
Order Protect
Dustin V.Verified
Build your own box is perfect to order all the favorites in one. This is buckeye Bombshell and is one of the best peanut butter creations Zach has made.
Build Your Box
Jamey W.Verified
Amazing taste. Addicting as well! I ordered these on impulse for after my national level bodybuilding show! They helped pack 30 lbs on me over the last week😂
Limited Edition November Box
Dustin V.Verified
The cookie monster is so great. Chocolate brownie with oreo and cookies throughout. Warm it up to have it gooey and it is a brownie you could eat everyday.
COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month
Manuel R.Verified
The Buckeye bombshell was the star of the show! Love the peanut butter and chocolate brownies the most. All of the flavors were amazing. Love Buckeye Brownies.
Build Your Box
Ivan W.Verified
Had a fun time eating these. I wanted to compare the cookie flavor variations and the Milk & Cookies was definitely the winner. Please keep being that one back.
Order Protect
Ralfeal T.Verified
Really Good Brownies! I am a repeat customer and I can’t wait to try the next round. Fast delivery and I recommend. Give them a try!
COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - August Flavor of the Month
Sarah M.Verified
This was the perfect birthday dessert for my boyfriend - every bite was more delicious than the previous one! will definitely be ordering again!
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
+1Elizabeth W.Verified
This was the third time I’ve gifted Buckeye Brownies to my sister and her family! Each time they say they love the brownies and enjoy trying the different flavors!
Order Protect
Emily T.Verified
I got these for my boyfriend’s birthday. These brownies were the only thing he wanted and the order was made and shipped quickly! He loved them! Delicious!
Rush Baking
Tiayrra G.Verified
I think so far the Hot Fudge Sunday brownie is the best one at least until I try the strawberry shortcake
Order Protect
Tyruel S.Verified
Everything was great! Not too sweet very gooey to my liking. 10/10 definitely would order more. Fruity pebble was my girlfriend and I favorite flavor.
Order Protect
Michael S.Verified
The brownies are huge, and every bite is delicious! We love the flavors. My order is already nearly gone. Highly recommended.
Order Protect
Amanda P.Verified
Easily the best tasting brownies after my first show of the year!! HIGHLY recommend warming them in the oven, they're to die for
Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box
Katelyn L.Verified
Literally the best thing I’ve ordered from this website (and I’ve ordered a lot of things!). Absolutely delicious, I need to order more asap!
The Classics - Pumpkin Roll Blondie Cups
Keone F.Verified
Some of the best brownies I've ever had. The peanut butter smores is my favorite, My girlfriend loves The MVP brownie. Definitely satisfied
Order Protect
Annette W.Verified
They are so big and delicious I shared mine with 3 people. I have had the strawberry crunch. Also the campfire
Order Protect
Jahtay B.Verified
It was amazing and also it lived up to its heights and I would most definitely buy more in the future
Build Your Box
Sheila A.Verified
All of them was amazing!!! Heating them up made them perfect, love they give instructions on how to do it.
Build Your Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store