Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Customer photo review of Buckeye’s Birthday Box

Brittany S.Verified

I've been wanting to try Buckeye Brownies for awhile after seeing them online. My birthday is in August, so I thought it would be perfect to try the birthday box first. My mom and I have shared two of the brownies so far. We love them (Peanut Butter Paradise is my favorite so far). They're delicious and probably the best brownies I've had. Will definitely be getting more in the future!

Buckeye’s Birthday Box

Customer video review of Fantastic Four Pack

Christopher V.Verified

Probably the best balanced brownies I’ve ever had. And heating them up for a bit after keeping them cool is such a delight. Just know I’m gonna order more soon.

Fantastic Four Pack

Lily K.Verified

Got the limited Valentines Day box for my boyfriend! He loved it so much and it was a great surprise. Had always seen these big beautiful brownies on social media and knew we had to try! Was worth every penny! Will definitely be buying them again!

Order Protect

Kevin T.Verified

Self control with these beauties is a helluva thing. I got the Buckeye Bombs and couldn't snap a pic with how they disappeared with the swiftness. Had the Mr Buckeye after I snapped these with some milk & bourbon.....the rest is history. Can't wait to lose my resolve again and dig into another morsel

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Fantastic Four Pack

Michelle A.Verified

Arrived quickly and in great condition. I immediately put 3 in the freezer and tried one. The 3 in the freezer didn't last the week! Delicious, unique and lovely presentation.

Fantastic Four Pack

Alycia M.Verified

I had trouble ordering cause of user error and emailed them and they got right back to me they were helpful and nice! My browines are so yummy they came in the timing that they said on the website and they came un damaged I would definitely order from here again 🤗

Build Your Box

Dylan P.Verified

This was so good, I shared with my memaw and girlfriend and have only bought more, I’m a bodybuilder of sorts and having a cheat day where I save over 5k cals worth is used to look towards eating all of this brownie deliciousness!

Order Protect

Elliott, C.Verified

Buckeye brownies were absolutely delicious! Very fast shipping and the best brownies I’ve ever had in my life. I had the birthday box and they were super fresh and so moist!!

Buckeye’s Birthday Box

Mathew L.Verified

It was delicious! Loved them all except for the pumpkin one… forgot the name… it was good it just wasn’t great to me and could’ve been a bit more sweet. Other than that all 10/10 to me! :)

Order Protect

Customer photo review of The Classics - Lemon Pound Cake Blondie Cups

Manuel R.Verified

The lemon pound cakes had an amazing taste with plenty of zest. Had to make a 2nd order because everyone in my house loved them so much. Buckeye Brownies is always killing it with their great flavors.

The Classics - Lemon Pound Cake Blondie Cups

Alissa B.Verified

Best impulse purchase ever. I kept seeing these ads on Instagram. The box arrived 2 days after I received the email that my order was baked and ready to go. The first little bit I cut off and heated up, I didn’t follow the 10 second microwave recommendation and the brownie’s consistency was more like a cake. Definitely don’t heat for longer than 10 seconds at a time! The nutter butter peanut butter brownie was my favorite! The other flavors were not what I would have chosen, but all 3 of the oth...

Fantastic Four Pack

Tina T.Verified

Delicious. I have ordered before and stock them in the freezer, but when I saw the flavor was pistashio I had to buy it again. Pop into to the microwave and it tasted as if it came out of the oven. I'm not usually a huge fan of blondies, but the pistashio blondie is my fav so far out of all the brownies. Price is high but worth it.

Pistachio Box

Keven A.Verified

Honestly the best brownies I ever have. Especially this months flavor!!!! Super delicious and the flavors are on point. The biscoff is a little dry but other than that 10/10 AMAZING!!!!

Order Protect

Ivan W.Verified

The oatmeal creampie is my favorite blondie this year!😋 White chocolate, vanilla, cinnamon, it all came together. Since it is already oatmeal theme, maybe experiment with having raisins in it next time. Otherwise, I kind of wish I had money and space to get multiple boxes.🙂

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Fourth of July Box

Raul L.Verified

First time trying these and they were fantastic!! The berry flavor was my favorite. The fruit tasted very fresh and the texture was great. I fell in love with pecans because of this brownie. Campfire was my son’s favorite, and peanut butter was rich and delicious as well. Excited to keep trying more varieties of these.

Limited Edition Fourth of July Box

Amy M.Verified

We love the brownies. In fact, all that we have left is one of the wrappers. I plan on buying more as these were really tasty and definitely made fresh before delivery. Even after freezing the last two they still tasted fresh after thawing out.

Pick Two

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box

Josh B.Verified

These brownies are HUGE! They taste amazing and weigh over half pound and couldn't finish but half of a brownie in one sitting. I find they are best warmed up since I keep mine in the refrigerator a quick 20 seconds or so and they are ooey gooey 😋

Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box

Josh B.Verified

These brownies are absolutely amazing. I'm always ordering new things to try and very rarely order from some place multiple times before trying something new but I'll definitely be ordering more from here.

Order Protect

Alicia M.Verified

I bought these for my mom and brother for Christmas. Don't get me wrong, they LOVED the brownies; my question is, are two of them the same? Two of them looks the same in the photo

Build Your Box

Mariely V.Verified

I thought the brownies were pretty great. I liked the peanut butter smores a lot, the toasted marshmallows were good. I didn't like the cherry one as much as the others because the chocolate chip and cherry tasted a little bit off. But other than that, I like the brownies.

Order Protect

Customer video review of Sweetest Day Bundle

Ashley N.Verified

Sweetest Day Bundle/Halloween and Trick or Treat Pack…by far one of the BEST desserts I’ve had in a long time! This was my first order and I’m already hooked…I’ll definitely be becoming a regular customer now 😅

Sweetest Day Bundle

William B.Verified

All 4 brownies were super tasty! I did not find them to be dry overall and they all had distinctive flavors. I’m wondering if it’s possible that you have more regulars/constants on your menu - namely the mother’s circus one and the churro one.

Build Your Box

Robert M.Verified

So I received my brownies and was immediately blown away by their beautiful presentation and girth. When my fiance and I started eating them it was magical. The Brownies Were Absolutely Delicious! They were so good we decided instead of eating one whole brownie and then being too full to try the other ones that we would try smaller pieces of all four brownies. Totally Awesome Decision because we got to taste all four of them right then and there. They were all so delicious and well made! The tex...

Fantastic Four Pack

Adam M.Verified

My second time ordering and was just as good as the first! Two of my new favorites are the PB Paradise and the Pebbles and cream. I liked how you could customize the box. Will be back for a third time soon!

Fantastic Four Pack

Jonathan R.Verified

I ordered way too much that I had to give more than half of what I order away to prevent excessive weight gain. 10 out of 10. They taste amazing. Would never order them again :)

Order Protect

Valerie T.Verified

i usually dont like the rainbow confetti sprinkles but they tasted so good on these brownies and werent too overpowering. the oreo one was mine and my bfs favorite that we wanted the last bite of. great with milk too. will definitely buy again 😋🤎

Fantastic Four Pack

Nicole H.Verified

Best brownies my husband and I have ever had! Way worth the wait and the money!!! Our favorite one was the Snickerdoodle and Chill!! We could eat a box of them! Thanks again!!!

Order Protect

Amari J.Verified

At first I was concerned due to no update on order information but it ended up coming fast once discussed with the owner. Personally I like the texture and taste of the brownies but can also understand how others don’t and consider it overhyped. Although if you ask me, we will be buying again from time to time.

Order Protect

Marques L.Verified

They were all great but i would have to say my favorite one was the dutch one i liked it more when i didn’t bake it just because it was too gooey for me when i did but when i ate it how it was packaged that chocolate explosion was unmatched.

Order Protect

Dominique W.Verified

Review of Buckeye Brownies: Oreo Brownie (Day 1) Rating: 6/10 This one’s great for chocolate lovers, especially when you heat it in the microwave for about a minute. It turns wonderfully gooey and sweet. My family enjoyed a piece, too—it’s like a rich blend of chocolate cookie and Oreo. However, I noticed a slight “storage” or “box” taste that held me back from rating it higher. I really wanted this one to wow me more, but instead, it left me in a bit of a “chocolate coma” without total satisfa...

Fantastic Four Pack

Customer photo review of Halloween Bundle Pack

Vladimir V.Verified

I got this for a co-worker for his birthday because his my sugar baby and he loved it. Everything was amazing and so good even after 2-3 days. We shared with all our co-workers and they are hooked. Thank you again for the amazing service and delicious selections!

Halloween Bundle Pack

Michael G.Verified

I got the holloween pack. Super delicious I can’t lie. Worth the money for the portions they come in. I will definitely purchase again. Dark knight was my favorite out of the all. And the peanut butter one was a hit fosho.

Order Protect

Eric T.Verified

All of them were amazing! Very dense, a little piece goes a long way. Great flavors, tasted even better after putting it in the oven for it to get nice and gooey🤤

Order Protect

Crystal G.Verified

They were delicious! I LOVE that they're not too sweet (except Oreo) and were mellow. I would purchase again. The flavors are delicious and I enjoyed trying them all. The portions are huge and will last a long time unless you're serving them at a party. :)

Fantastic Four Pack

Nolan S.Verified

My wife is gluten free so we’re limited on treats for her. So I found these guys a while ago and have ordered from them several times. The gluten free brownies are awesome. Not only is the product good, but their customer service is super responsive. I had a shipping error on my part needing a fix, and they responded within the hour. I’ll continue to be a regular for sure

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Limited Edition March Madness Pack

Dallon M.Verified

The March madness pack has been one of the most tasty and delicious brownies packs so far this year. The lemon haze by far has been my favorite one out of the box next to the cosmic craze and then the terrifically Twix is always a great one and the coffee cake crumb was next level.

Limited Edition March Madness Pack

Customer photo review of The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups

Phillip D.Verified

Of the package I received, these cups were the ones I was really waiting for and man did they not disappoint!! Again, they weren't too sweet and just the right size to share with a friend. 10/10

The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups

Customer photo review of Limited Edition February Pack

Michael A.Verified

I saw these on tiktok and wanted to give them a shot because they were getting a lot of positive reviews. My wife and I loved the blondies more! The oatmeal and the circus animal brownie were best warmed up in the oven! I really wished I didn't miss out on trying the Sinful Cinnabon Brownie. I saw that video when it wasn't available anymore. Fingers crossed it comes back!!

Limited Edition February Pack

Customer video review of Limited Edition Back To School Box

Ivan W.Verified

This was the pack of the year for me! You all took the best of the previous boxes and put it in one box. I was very excited about it from release, and quite frankly...I'm still excited just thinking it about.

Limited Edition Back To School Box

Tina T.Verified

The brownies are huge. There almost the size of my head. There absolutely delicious. Soft, chewy and not overly sweet. Pop them in the microwave for a few minutes and they taste as if it came out of the oven. Will definitely buy again.

Fantastic Four Pack

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store