Jon J.Verified
Soo good! Our favorite was the peanut butter and if we had to choose a least it would be Grandma's cobbler. But overall, really good. Glad we got to try this limited edition batch.
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews
Limited Edition Cheesecake Box
Eliseo F.Verified
OMG Im so amazed by the creation of these Buckeye Brownies, i have even joined the Buckeye Club now to be able to try the new monthly flavors and never miss out!
Order Protect
Diana S.Verified
Delicious…tastes exactly like carrot cake..,…you could even see the grated carrot in the dough. The cookie dough was so soft and moist and those candied giant pecans sent it over the top!
BUGS BUNNY 4-Pack - National Pecan Day Special
Michelle D.Verified
Sweetie Pie was the favorite, that one went fast. Kettle My Cornbread came in 2nd. Over all, the brownies were amazing & the Thanksgiving Pack was a success in my house.
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
+1Steven S.Verified
...I have to treat myself to Buckeyes Brownies every so often. This last box was everything!! Anytime you guys mix chocolate with peanut butter and throw in those extra goodies it's a win 🏆 I can't wait to order again soon.
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Amanda F.Verified
We sent these to our kiddo during mid-terms! He said it was too much for him to eat alone, so his buddies got a treat too! They gave all the flavors rave reviews! It was a hit!
Fantastic Four Pack
Chelsea R.Verified
This was a post body building show treat! Pooped it in the air fryer for 5mins. Really liked terrible twix, cookie crumble, and cosmic brownie the most. Will definitely order again!
Limited Edition March Madness 4-Pack
Marisa B.Verified
I've had all but the new York cheesecake brownie previously. This is a box of our favorites and am looking forward to trying the new one. They all have been delicious and recommend them to friends and family.
Order Protect
Aeneas S.Verified
they’re great tasting brownies! I personally loved the layers they all had which gave it a bit more texture to enjoy. also came in a day earlier than I expected so that just days there shipping is great
Order Protect
Nick G.Verified
The cosmic craze was the first thing I had after getting off the stage from my first bodybuilding show. Let me tell you, this was the best thing to have! Definitely worth the wait!!
Build Your Box
James P.Verified
Loved it!!! 1st order with you guys I sent to my son in college. He talked about how good everything was so I placed an order just for me and man was he not lying! Top quality all around. I started with the Triple Berry Pie thinking I would like it the least, boy was I wrong, Rated 10. Next I went with Campfire Crunch, Rated 7.5. Crazy Caramel Pecan, Rated 9. Last but not least Peanut Butter Perfection, Rated 12!!! Best was mostly definitely saved for last!
Order Protect
Noah H.Verified
Having these brownies for the first time was an amazing experience! Mr. Buckeye is a peanut butter lover's dream, The Gift is a actual gift in brownie form, Snickerdoodle & Chill is a real comfort brownie on a Saturday night, and The MVP is the Michael Jordan of the whole Fantastic Four! Definitely getting more of these delicious brownies really soon!
Fantastic Four Pack
Taylor R.Verified
Its was SOO GOODD! It started off with my coworker buying and sharing with his teammates every month and it made me just want to order some just for myself! Well worth it and i have been telling my love ones to give these brownies.
Order Protect
Gerald L.Verified
I’m a long-time chocoholic with a passion for new flavors. Saw your facebook and said i’d try a sample. These are some of the best brownies I’ve ever tasted. The four flavors I ordered are outstanding. As you can see from the pictures, you can’t eat one at one setting to really appreciate it. You must eat one of the flavors only when call for. Sometimes a chocolate, sometimes a carrot cake. I eat my brownies by 1-inch section so I can appreciate them longer. I’ll make my next selection soon. Yo...
Build Your Box
Danielle S.Verified
Absolutely fire! Came fresh and well persevered. First time ever having Buckeye and it was worth it. The brownies are chewy and packed with flavor. Ted velvet was a bit dry the first bite but after it got really chewy and moist. The Santa’s suprise was good for a blondie and I’m not a big blondie person but that was my exception with them little Debbie cakes. I’m obsessed and definitely going to order again on the future. Thank you!
Build Your Box
Sena P.Verified
Omg I was low key "stalking" my mail man 😂 waiting. I was so excited to get them seeing everyone online trying them so I said let's go! They arrived on-time and when I tell you we didn't wait we hit the microwave for that long few seconds and it was amazing. My son took the buckeye and left lol. Thank you so much. I will order again!!
Order Protect
Aaron M.Verified
I've been curious to try these brownies ever since I started seeing them appear on social media. Just their appearance got me excited with all the different flavors and unique blends mixed together. When I received my variety pack, then most certainly didn't disappoint! The taste was amazing and the texture was perfect, with its soft center and crispy/crunchy outer layer.
Order Protect
+4Ashley H.Verified
Delish! My family loved all the brownie flavors. We got the valentines box, and I think the biscoff was our favorite of the 4, followed by dark night and butterfinger. But all were delish, even the bonus cookies and cream cups! And they are perfect when warmed up a little. Highly recommend.
Order Protect
Justin M.Verified
I'm never going to be skinny. These are amazing and I love supporting the small business. Everything looks great and so far tastes amazing. Our family is fighting over whose is whose even when I bought 15 different items.
Order Protect
Lydia R.Verified
Probably one of the best combinations I have had yet! Every one was so good and had fantastic flavor combinations! I would definitely get this box again! The new peanut butter ganache was excellent! It was also the first time I had the milk and cookies one which was one of my favorites from the box!
Limited Edition February Box
Steven S.Verified
This is my third order and this time around the dark knight and the tasty tagalong stood out above the rest. Anything with chocolate and peanut butter I'm an absolute fan of. Will definitely order a fourth, fifth, and sixth time especially with Christmas coming.
Limited Edition Halloween Pack
Shuayb Y.Verified
Cookie Monster 9.5
PB Paradise 10
Pebbles and Cream 9
Churro Caramel Cream 10
Was a great Bday present for me. Highly recommend Buck Eye Brownies for anyone on a temporary sugar hunt.
Order Protect
Jaré C.Verified
These brownies are absolutely delicious! I have a hard time deciding which flavor is my favorite, they are all so good. I like some of them chilled in the fridge and others are best heated up. The flavors are so creative and I love the build a box option.
Build Your Box
Antionette W.Verified
I would say they were great but I'm not the overly excited type. So I'll say they was aight. I mean, I only took a little bite, so I don't have much to go off. As you can see in the photo, there is still a lot of brownie left. I didn't lick my fingers... that many times. It was maybe 2 or 3 times. Im sure I didn't lick them 4 times. Wait, maybe it was 4. Idk, all I know is... one of them tasted like a paper napkin. I don't even use napkins, so... Anyway, I might not order again. Unless... they b...
Build Your Box
Robert D.Verified
Always amazing, incredibly delicious, nothing can compare, it's a explosion of deliciousness in your mouth it sends shivers and fireworks in your body these are the best brownies in the world i said what I said come at me! I'll fight all the haters cause these babies are out of this world. And the perfect treat on my cheat days!
Build Your Box
David F.Verified
I highly recommend ordering from Buckeye brownies. We have only ordered from them twice, but everything we got has been absolutely delicious, large enough to share with others and have plenty leftover, and easy to store and reheat. We especially love the playful brownies that they make like the terrifically Twix, the snickerdoodle, and confetti cake that we tried over the holidays. The strawberries sensation cookies are absolutely delicious, but our favorites are the fudge brownie cups. Both the...
Order Protect
+1Brianna M.Verified
I was not the biggest fan of these flavors in particular. I did enjoy the one with pecans in it though, I would definitely order it again. One criticism I would like to add is that it could be a bit less dry.
Order Protect
Jessica V.Verified
The brownies and cookies are fantastic. Not over these sweets and really enjoyable. I cut each brownie into fourth so I can manage how much I’m actually gonna eat and I can share with the family. The one with the Reese‘s pieces on top is by far my favorite, the snickerdoodle so far has been not as flavorful maybe just a lighter taste of snickerdoodle, but I still enjoyed it.
Order Protect
Christian L.Verified
Ate the first half of the brownies with my wife Valentine’s Day eating the second half tonight on date night and the fudge cups were gone throughout the week! Will order again!
Order Protect
Dallon M.Verified
Every time I order, it’s very easy and seamless to purchase my desired sweet treats. Every time I get them anticipation and wait of having them delivered. experiencing, the Buckeye brownies is always an experience in my household, and we always love to share with others. Everyone is surprised on how flavorful and amazing everything taste And we keep coming back every month wanting more.
Order Protect
India E.Verified
Delicious. I must have missed whenever the churro brownie was avaliable before, but I can definitely see why it was included in this fan favorite box. I wish that Ted Velvet would have been included, but still a solid collection overall that I'd recommend.
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Brian D.Verified
I have the M&M Teddy Graham mix on video, but the peanut butter and jealous was even better. It's an explosion of flavors and textures I now crave. These brownies are ridiculous! Now I watch videos of other people eating them. I haven't had a healthy addiction like this in a while. I say healthy as in robust. These are so good it's insane. I'll get more. Every flavor is bomb.
Limited Edition September Pack
Damiana M.Verified
The brownies were delicious and perfect ! Not only was the product amazing, the customer service cannot be beat! I ordered a box to be sent to my out of state body building show and I was worried I wouldn’t get them on time. I sent an email expressing my concern and they were so quick to respond and make sure my brownie box was going to be shipped to me promptly and arrive on time before I stepped on stage. I am absolutely ordering from them again just from the amazing customer service I receiv...
Buckeye’s Birthday Box
Sheila H.Verified
All the brownies were delicious. My absolute favorite was the smores, I'm so sad that it was a limited item along with cookie monster.. I really hope both get brought back, I'd buy 2 each!
Build Your Box
Katherine M.Verified
These were so good that I ate 2 of the 4 brownies before posting my review!! I've yet to try the s'more or the caramel pecan yet but its getting close to it!! The other 2 i chose was the snickerdoodle and the sprinkle one. Those 2 were Devoured immediately!!
Build Your Box
Katherine M.Verified
These were so good that I ate 2 of the 4 brownies before posting my review!! I've yet to try the s'more or the caramel pecan yet but its getting close to it!!
Limited Edition Fourth of July Box
Isaac M.Verified
The peanut butter paradise is a must try if you like peanut butter. Scott's favorite was probably my 2nd favorite flavor of the pack, I love coconut. Definitely best warmed up in the oven.
Build Your Box
Andrea U.Verified
Brownies were excellent! The only problem is that my order confirmation didn’t tell me which flavors I had selected so I’m not entirely sure which ones I ordered. Some I could figure out based on pictures from the website but others I’m not 100% sure! It would be nice if the website had pictures with descriptions. I definitely will be ordering again, they were all delicious!
Build Your Box
Yolanda A.Verified
These brownies are so good, so far I have taken one bite out of each brownie and I have only finished the birthday cake one so far but I plan to start on the snickerdoodle one next. It's insane though, straight out of the pack on delivery without warming them up first they already were moist and tasted great.
Fantastic Four Pack
Denise K.Verified
Sent this box to my 1st year college student as he started the first week of classes. He was so happy with the selection of items, and the flavors of the product. He put most in his freezer, as it was A LOT for 1 person, but has been slowly enjoying them as the semester continues.
The Experience Box
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store