Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Visit store
Customer video review of Build Your Box
Eliseo F.Verified
I love the excitement and hate it at the same time 😆 I mean waiting for the reveal of the new Brownie flavors of the month, Buckeye Brownies is the best including all the other tasty sweets 😋 yall offer. My order starting with the Peanut butter fudge cups so delicious build my box with all the Brownie flavors I picked perfection and im sad to see them go but the Biscoff cookies were 🔥 I can't wait hardly wait for my next order to come in!
Build Your Box
Customer photo review of COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - WEEKEND SPECIAL
Matthew B.Verified
First time buying Buckeye Brownies and I will definitely be back! Bought a 4 pack of this flavor cause I have been eyeballing them for a while. Pulled the trigger and definitely a 10/10! What you want out of a Cookie Monster flavored treat. The Cookie Monster cookie dough made it for me!
COOKIE MONSTER 4-Pack - WEEKEND SPECIAL
Customer photo review of Butterfinger AF 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 6/11
Kyle C.Verified
Really, really tasty! The peanut butter and butterfinger infused cookie dough was amazing and the crumpled bits of Butterfinger and snack sized Butterfinger was an awesome touch as well! Would highly recommend!
Butterfinger AF 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 6/11
Customer video review of Limited Edition Fathers Day Box
Erica S.Verified
these brownies are out of this world! so gooey, NOT TOO SWEET, but very unique!!! i absolutely loved the father’s day bundle. the MVP- oreo one was incredible! also the apple one was amazing with vanilla ice cream!!!! i absolutely love each flavor and can’t wait to buy more. you can physically taste each bite of everything they add into these. and there massive so i can always have for multiple nights after dinner for a late night treat. 10/10 recommend
Limited Edition Fathers Day Box
Customer photo review of Build Your Box
Joe S.Verified
Always love the build your box my go to is always the snickerdoodle and chill, trying the almond crunch one bite was amazing, I love everything about these brownies absolutely nothing like them out there.
Build Your Box
Customer video review of Pick Two
Braden A.Verified
Love the classic brownies snickerdoodle and chill, and Mr.buckeye. Gotten them quite a few times throughout the last 4 or 5 years and they are always super moist and delicious.
Pick Two
Customer photo review of Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Adam M.Verified
I got the 4 pack, Birthday bash for the month of March. I put the brownie in the oven, how it was recommended. The flavor and everything was amazing, gooey and delicious!
Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Customer photo review of The Classics - Fudge Cups Bundle+1
Ivan W.Verified
The fudge cups are one of the best things ever created by Buckeye Brownies. Never get rid of them. As you can see, I don't miss an opportunity to combine them with other Brownies. It's a fudge overload!
The Classics - Fudge Cups Bundle
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Jonathan W.Verified
I knew I was in for a treat, but damn. Those were delicious. And I appreciate how hassle free and quick it was to cancel and redo my order when I chose the wrong option. Definitely will be ordering again.
Order Protect
Customer video review of Order Protect
Ava H.Verified
the best brownie i’ve ever had in my fucking life i’m deadass so sprung on this shit good god please make a box with like ted velvet cookie monster butter my Bischoff and either oreo cheesecake or the blueberry cheesecake one please GOD i’m yearning for more
Order Protect
Customer video review of Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Ivan W.Verified
I finally found my all-time favorite brownie. The birthday cake is my #1! Tasting chocolate fudge, white chocolate, vanilla cake, and cookies n'cream flavors all in one brownie was too addicting. Please bring it back Buckeye Brownies😭! Or better yet don't before I fill my freezer with them. I need to lose weight😅.
Birthday Bash 4-Pack - MARCH FLAVOR OF THE MONTH
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Barbara H.Verified
We have ordered many times, and each time, before we thought of taking a pic, the box was eaten. This time we captured it just before diving in, as shown in picture. Build A Box is our favorite - we get to try new and old!
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Brandon H.Verified
This now our 3rd box of the brownies and I think we have tried all of them except the lemon! We couldn’t be more please with them. They are out favorite sweet treat.
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Order Protect+1
Phillip D.Verified
Brownies, Lemon Bars and Cookies were all amazing. I would like to see more chocolate chips in the cookies, however. (Custom Order????) The surprising thing about these brownies is they are not too sweet. They are very well balanced. I will say that they are heavy. I'd say just the 4 brownies alone felt like 3 lbs!!!!!! Will definitely buy again. Thank you.
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Build Your Box
Dallon M.Verified
First time doing the build your own box and the experience was amazing super easy to do and it was really neat to customize with a certain brownies. I hadn’t had yet every time I come back experience a stellar. keep it up Buckeye brownies, and can’t wait to see the new creations. You create for the time to come.
Build Your Box
Customer photo review of Order Protect+1
Michael S.Verified
Brownies arrived quickly, and super fresh. The brownies were absolutely delicious. They exceeded my expectations by a significant amount! Flavor was phenomenal and quality was amazing. Heavy , delicious brownies which are bound to make anyone smile afterwards.
Order Protect
Customer video review of PB PARADISE 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 4/10
Ivan W.Verified
The best Peanut Butter experience I've had. The PB paradise is a top 5 all time brownie for me. Words cannot the describe the lovely smell when I opened the box to all that peanut butter.😍
PB PARADISE 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 4/10
Customer photo review of No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Manuel R.Verified
The past 40 years of my life I have not enjoyed or desired or eaten peanut butter. Got these no bake Buckeye bombs for free with a special that Buckeye was running in July 2025. Gave it a try and now I’m addicted to peanut butter. Guess my taste buds changed finally, either way thank you Buckeye for the special promo or I probably wouldn’t have given peanut butter another try. Just ordered the peanut butter fudge cups and I loved those too!!!
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
Customer photo review of Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Lily K.Verified
Got these for my boyfriend for Valentine’s Day and he loved it! Always see people enjoying them on social media and knew we had to give them a try!! All 4 brownies were gone in less than a week! Would 100% buy again!!
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
Customer photo review of Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Sierra C.Verified
Wow. I LOVED the sweet potato brownie! I wish I could've bought and entire box of job at that. Te others were also excellent. I will buy again but I hope they do sweet potato every year.
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Kelly B.Verified
The brownies arrived in perfect condition!! Very impressed with packaging. They were absolutely delicious, the flavors like no other brownie that I have ever had. So unique, we enjoyed every bite. Also, such a good value, due to the generous size we were able to share and enjoy over several days! I will definitely be ordering again, can't wait!!!
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Order Protect+1
Deanna P.Verified
The early morning social media ads got me, and I have zero regrets. These brownies and blondies were incredible, and everyone I shared them with thought so too! I can’t wait to try more flavors!
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Add A Custom Note
Gracie W.Verified
The shipping, FAST! The box, HEAVY! The brownie size, BIG! The flavors, DELICIOUS, RICH, LIGHT, SWEET AND SALTY! My husband and I are now going to order some every month. Definitely worth every penny!
Add A Custom Note
Customer video review of The Experience Bundle
William M.Verified
Buckeye Brownies – A Post-Show Tradition Worth Every Bite As a competitive bodybuilding couple, my wife and I are extremely selective about what we eat—especially after weeks of disciplined prep. We first discovered Buckeye Brownies at the Lieberman Show (Natural Ohio NPC Mutant) in Avon, Ohio, and it was a total game-changer. Since that moment, Buckeye Brownies have become our official post-show treat—a new tradition that we look forward to just as much as stepping on stage. After months of s...
The Experience Bundle
Customer photo review of Rush Baking+1
Anthony L.Verified
Absolutely the best brownies I have ever enjoyed so I had to share them with my sister in Alabama … even though my wife and kids got mad at me 🤪🤪🤪
Rush Baking
Customer video review of Order Protect
Erica S.Verified
BROWNIES WERE MASSIVE!! so gooey and tasty, i love the oreo one! they surprisingly were not very sweet! enjoyed them post show from a body building competition. will definitely order in the future because they are very good! 10/10 recommend
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack+1
Raylena L.Verified
Shipping takes a bit BUT the brownies come fresh a and soft. All were delicious but my favorite was the sweetie pie, so oogey and delicious. Can't wait to see what comes out for Christmas. Thanks for the amazing brownies Zach!
Limited Edition Thanksgiving Pack
Customer photo review of Fantastic Four Pack
Erica S.Verified
The brownies are really good. They are so huge! I was not expecting that like that. I placed them in storage properly before photos but they looked so good when they arrived. They also smelled like fresh baked brownies when warmed up in the oven. I very surprised, grateful, and pleased with this purchase.
Fantastic Four Pack
Customer photo review of Build Your Box
Natalie W.Verified
To say I am now an addict is an understatement. Cookies, BUCKEYE BOMBS, minis, and the ultimate half pound brownies were ALL phenomenal. Easy to store for later, reheat for fresh from the oven goodness, or let come to room temp and still be AMAZINGLY taste and soft, so impressed. I have been a customer of several global brand sweet treats and these put them to shame. (No names need to be mentioned). To top it off, I contacted them as a first time customer to figure out the shipping process and ...
Build Your Box
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Manuel R.Verified
The 2025 Memorial Day pack was full of great flavors this year. The cornflake crops and almond sugar were the top two. Will be picking these flavors up again when they are back in rotation.
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Kimberly O.Verified
These brownies were fantastic. I wasn’t a fan of the no bake Buckeyes, they were more a peanut butter cup inside of oats, but all 3 of the brownie flavors I tried (perfect pistachio, samoas, and The Gift). Fantastic. Will def order again. The brownies are 4 servings in 1.
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Order Protect+1
Darrillyn B.Verified
They came so far and we're amazing! My kids were climbing over each other to get more. My husband was plotting on mine because I wasn't eating them fast enough. Can't wait to order them again!
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Build Your Box
Anushka E.Verified
These brownies were amazing!!!! They came the day before Valentine's Day, which was great, and my husband and I enjoyed every bit of them. Will definitely be ordering them again.
Build Your Box
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Joseph V.Verified
We love that we love loving these brownies! Our order also included the cookies and the fudge brownie cups. Everything flavorful, great soft brownies with different textural elements to mix things up. Even had to order some for my Mom for her birthday!
Order Protect
Customer photo review of Order Protect+1
Shari M.Verified
All I can say is WOW!! First time we ordered and these brownies did not disappoint! The flavors, the texture, and, oh my goodness, the size!! The day after we got them, I placed an order to ship to my mom! Fantastic! Don't wait, just order now!!!!
Order Protect
Customer video review of Build Your Box
Joe S.Verified
The build your box is one of my favorite builds getting to choose all the different brownies that are up for grabs my favorite is the snickerdoodle and my number 2 has to be the ooey gooey butter cake, the flavors in them are second to none but I am more of a blondie person than chocolate.
Build Your Box
Customer photo review of Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Nicholas N.Verified
I’ve been wanting to try Buckeye Brownies for a few years, and once I saw the Fan Favorite pack I knew I needed FINALLY order them…well now I wish I would have ordered the years ago! Simply the best custom brownies I’ve ever had, you will not be disappointed in these, a MUST TRY!
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
Customer photo review of Limited Edition February Box
Clayton S.Verified
I ordered a few boxes for my family to enjoy for Valentine's Day to do something different and unexpected. I definitely underestimated the size of these things! When my wife picked up the boxes, she thought it was a gauge gift because they were so heavy! "No way these are brownies!" Sure enough Brownies the size of bricks! They were absolutely fantastic. Moist, flavourful and the perfect gooey texture when warmed up. Without a doubt 100% recommend and will be ordering again!
Limited Edition February Box
Customer photo review of Order Protect
Danielle S.Verified
Bomb! First time having Buckeye and I am raving! They look exactly as they do online packed with flavor. The red velvet is my favorite but at first was a bit dry until the second bite. Chewy and even better warmed up. Santa’s surprise buttery and sweet along the MVP and Mr Buckeye all 10/10 Best damn brownies ever!
Order Protect
Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store