Buckeye Brownies Reviews

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsSee store reviews

Kiely A.Verified

The strawberry is to die for fr, I was so pleasantly surprised. Havnt tried the crumb cake but I’m hoping it ranks w the strawberry. I’m exited to try it blueberry muffin brownie when it drops again- I missed the deadline w it this year but when it comes out again I’ll be on that so fast

Build Your Box

Michelle W.Verified

These were delicious! I bought them after seeing them all over social media and they did not disappoint. I did a little taste test. My fave was the MVP and then The Buckeye, but I liked all of them. I cut them all into smaller pieces and have been eating them for a week and put part of them in the freezer to savor later. Tasty!

Order Protect

Customer photo review of The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Carl B.Verified

I never review purchases but I’m making an exception for BB. Me, my wife and my son make a production every time we get a new box of flavors. I’ve even sent a box to him in college so he can continue to rank them with us at home. I think we are up to 20 different flavors, but probably more. We taste test each one and rank each box/flavor. The best box by far is the Fall Box, no weakness in any brownie. The best brownie flavor overall is the Chocolate Sundae, by far. I am begging for that ...

The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups

Derek B.Verified

Have been wanting to try the Buckeye Brownies for a while now but finally committed to an order when the special flavor involving Twix was released. Ordered that and the Mr. Buckeye 4 pack because I'm a huge fan of both Nutter Butters and Reece's Pieces. The boxes that the brownies came in were much bigger and heavier than I was expecting. I realize that they advertise how heavy the brownies are, but it was certainly something else actually holding them! I appreciate they they arrive in four se...

Order Protect

Mikey K.Verified

Order came just as I ordered. I have not tried anything yet, I am on a massive cut, started a bulk recently and when my coach gives me the ok then I will dig in! But everything looks fantastic

Order Protect

Customer video review of Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box

Lothario W.Verified

All of the flavors were great. Cookies and Dream was my favorite. I wish the Appley ever After had more of the mini apple pie filling. The terrifically twix was terrific lol. I’m not a big fan of pumpkin pie but the Pumpkin Crumb cake was good as well.

Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box

Customer photo review of Fantastic Four Pack

Beverly B.Verified

I purchased Buckeye Brownies Fantastic Four Pack as a Christmas gift for my son-in-law, who absolutely loves sweets. Judging by the photo, I think he’ll loves the brownies. Everyone in the family was offering to help him “smile”the Nutter Butter brownie. I believe he then hid his box of brownies behind the television. I do not see sharing in the future… Lol. (There were 25 of us) Always proud to support local small businesses. I look forward to ordering Buckeye Brownies for many occasions in 20...

Fantastic Four Pack

Floyd S.Verified

I have to share because there are 3 of us and the brownies are too big to hide. Snickerdoodle is one of my favorites. Red velvet is so good should keep that year round.

Order Protect

Customer video review of Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Jeffery K.Verified

The snicker and the Twix brownie are to DIE for. Some of the best brownies they have ever made. The Halloween pack is 10/10 they nailed it with this one.

Limited Edition Halloween Pack

Robert D.Verified

Absolutely perfection you dont know how happy I always am to eat these brownies im so happy I found this comeback in 2020 and let me tell you ill never go back to old little one flavor brownies cause these are to good to try anything else ever again!

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of Sweet Celebration 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 12/8 GUARANTEED

Kevin R.Verified

A party in every bite 🎊🎉. The brownie itself was soft, chewy, and delicious at the same time. The hot fudge sundae pop-tart added lots of flavor along with the birthday cake Oreos and rainbow sprinkles. It’s a celebration that I’m never gonna forget.

Sweet Celebration 4-Pack - CLOSEOUT - WILL SHIP 12/8 GUARANTEED

Susan S.Verified

I ordered as a surprise for my husband who was drooling over a Facebook advertisement. He said he wished they were local. They tasted amazing! Ted Velvet and Mr.Buckeye disappeared the quickly.

Order Protect

Kiely A.Verified

Rly like ur fruit brownies like the strawberry triple berry- those have been my fave so far- they don’t dry out as quickly as the others. This order was weird tho- I got wut I think was a complimentary box w a butter butter brownie, an Oreo cheesecake brownie, and two more I can’t rly remember. I didn’t order that, just the triple berry box w 3 triple berries & a strawberry crunch cake. I can’t eat the peanut butter one & I don’t love Oreo but hey it was a nice gesture, I’m not complaining :...

Build Your Box

Suzette H.Verified

Well, I ordered 2 biscoff and 1 other box. Same issue as before only got one of each. I reached out and heard back immediately. I asked for a refund since it was a limited edition item and dint want to mess with a replacement. They are delicious though and would order them again! I received my refund immediately and a discount for my trouble. Feel a little gun shy now.

Order Protect

Jennifer R.Verified

i’m Best brownies ever. So yummy and moist. so love that I got pick out different flavors for each square and bring a bit of Ohio which is home to our new home out of state.

Order Protect

Nicole H.Verified

Being from northwestern PA originally I was excited to see a little company from near my area. When my brownies arrived I dived right in and OH My! They are delicious!

Order Protect

Customer photo review of Pumpkin Crumb Cake 4-Pack

Ann D.Verified

The pumpkin brownies were delish! The pumpkin cups are the bomb!!! They would both make a great alternative to boring pumpkin pie at Thanksgiving. Your family/guest would love you!

Pumpkin Crumb Cake 4-Pack

Alex C.Verified

My all time favorite flavors are Cookie Monster and cookies and milk, those combined with dutches delight and Jolly gingerbread, was probably my favorite build your box I’ve ever ordered!

Build Your Box

Ladyt C.Verified

The box live up to everything. Everybody who came by my house, saw the box took a piece, took a bite and that’s what I was left with. I’m definitely going to be ordering again with you soon.!!!!!

Order Protect

Customer photo review of The Ultimate Biscoff Bundle

Jason S.Verified

I’m not a Biscoff fan. I bought these for a coworker that let me sample both the brownies and the cookies. And let me tell you these brownies were absolutely delicious and the cookies were on point. Not a surprise coming from buckeye brownies every thing I’ve ever had has been amazing.

The Ultimate Biscoff Bundle

Simon F.Verified

I am so excited to try this after my bodybuilding show, I’ve been looking forward to it, unfortunately I can only try one at a time but for each one I’ll make a video of my reaction tasting it since this is my first order of brownies from yall! 🙌🏽 I’d love to be part of the team if yall accepting anyone !

Order Protect

Shayla M.Verified

Love my brownie box! My favorite way to eat them is warmed up with a scoop of ice cream and a lil marshmallow or chocolate syrup!!! Yummy, so good! We love ordering from here amazing people, place, with fantastic brownies!

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Back To School Box

India E.Verified

I really enjoyed this box. All the flavors were really good, but the Cosmic brownie and PB&J ones were amazing. Hope these flavors show up more in the future. I'd recommend this product.

Limited Edition Back To School Box

Customer photo review of No Bake Buckeye Bombs

Jesse R.Verified

What can I say to My Favorite Things smashed together peanut butter cups and no bake cookies! No way you can go wrong with this very unique snack. Absolutely delicious and worth every penny! Packaged well shipped in a timely manner. Definitely a five-star experience!

No Bake Buckeye Bombs

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box

Jesse R.Verified

The flavors were out of this world. The brownie themselves was everything brownie should be moist flavorful in these were very unique! Package very well shipped in a timely manner. And the creativity in coming up with these flavors was genius! Definitely a five-star experience!

Limited Edition Fall Favorites Box

Dakota V.Verified

Just went through one heck of a body building season & i made sure I celebrated with the best brownies I’ve ever had! Located in Texas, it was so worth it

Build Your Box

Cameron C.Verified

Everything was amazing I was expecting to eat the whole thing but it was a bit too sweet after 24 weeks of prep. Would love to see a protein packed brownie with 30-100g per brownie 🤞🤞

Build Your Box

Barbara H.Verified

This shows how we ATTACKED the box. My husband loves your brownies, and I don't tell him what I ordered until we get them. Then, I give him tastes of each, with explanations of contents. We are addicted to these brownies, and they come so fresh.

Order Protect

Dallon M.Verified

They order protect is always a great standard to have in. My mind is at ease, knowing that my delicious brownies will arrive without any imperfections and or damages to the box and it makes the whole experience that much better when opening up to see the wonderful creations.

Order Protect

Jeffery K.Verified

All 4 of the brownies I got were amazing. The chocolate cheesecake brownie was my favorite but teddy velvet was a close 2nd. You couldn’t go wrong with any of the 3!

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

Amanda B.Verified

My family and I really enjoyed these brownies!! They are huge! Definitely worth the money spent. Cannot wait to try some More!! And they weren’t overly sweet. Which we loved!! Perfect!!

LIMITED EDITION CARNIVAL CRAVINGS BOX

Customer video review of Limited Edition March Madness Pack

Shaun N.Verified

The March Madness pack might’ve been my favorite pack to date! The unique flavor combinations, the mouth watering formulations of cookie dough flavors and the light sweetness without the overpowering sugary taste are just a few things I love most about these bad boys. Oh, also did you know each brownie is a 1/2 pound! 👀 ⚖️ They’re HUGE! I’m a brownie fanatic and I can confidently say these are the best I’ve ever had (don’t tell my mom bc she makes some pretty elite brownies, haha). I will be o...

Limited Edition March Madness Pack

Jordan E.Verified

Great brownies high quality ingredients definitely lived up to the name a lot more sweeter than expected but after reaching my weight loss goal they were definitely a good treat

Order Protect

Morgan B.Verified

They arrived SO fast and tasted amazing even after being in the fridge. I didn’t have a microwave or oven available to heat it up but I really didn’t even need it. I can’t wait to order more 🥹

Order Protect

Kristina G.Verified

I ordered a Build Your Own 4 pack and could NOT have been more pleased with my brownies! I took one to a bodybuilding competition and had so many other competitors ask if it was a Buckeye Brownie. And it was the perfect treat to have after the competition and share with my team!

Build Your Box

Eliseo F.Verified

I love the build your box on the last week of the month it allows us to mix up the Brownies if we didn't like one of the flavors 😋

Build Your Box

Customer photo review of Limited Edition Celebration Box

Trisha G.Verified

They were so good that I am rationing them! I ate half and saved the remaining in the freezer until I get back from my trip! This was the second box of Buckeye Brownies I ordered, and it is even better than the other one which was absolutely fantastic!

Limited Edition Celebration Box

Barbara H.Verified

I love the build your own box experience. I prefer blonde based brownies, and my husband loves chocolate. So, I can customize it! THESE ARE THE BEST BROWNIES. TRY THEM.

Build Your Box

Customer video review of Brown Butter Biscoff Cookies

Eliseo F.Verified

Man im addicted to Buckeye Brownies, im a little sad that the Buckeye Club ended it was pretty cool to not have to reorder every month and get points as well. Im still buying every month and looking forward to the new baked goods!

Brown Butter Biscoff Cookies

Brittany W.Verified

Got the celebration pack for after my bodybuilding show. All the flavors were amazing. My favorite was fruity pebble, then blueberry, peanut butter recess cup then the cookie dough. Definitely gonna heat any of the ones with chocolate next time.

Order Protect

Buckeye Brownies ReviewsVisit store