Landon K.Verified
It was amazing I got it out of the box and that’s when I caught eye on the great deal I was getting.it was good quality and can get the job done
Mystery Knives ReviewsSee store reviews
Mystery Switchblade Box™
Halie H.Verified
I ordered these on a Friday and I was super excited to get them! The free shipping said 5-7 days I believe but I got mine that following Tuesday! So I was very impressed with shipping, and the quality of the knives are very good! I already have some other boxes I wanna get, 10/10 recommend. You won’t be disappointed!
Mystery Butterfly Box™
Daniel M.Verified
I always wanted an OTF karambit so I ordered one and couldn't be happier. I like the styling of the handle. The blade is nice with the 2 tone. I'll order more knives for sure.
OTF Mystery Box™
Jonathan G.Verified
Nice and heavy great handling, and very sharp, the price is crazy considering how well made these knives are, and not to mention the thrill of not knowing what you’re gonna get with these mysterious knives. 100% recommend to everyone that likes quality knives at an affordable price.
Mystery Stiletto Box™
Gretchen W.Verified
I bought three separate boxes as Christmas gifts for the men in my family. I was pleasantly surprised with the quality and variety. Can't wait for them to be opened.
Switchblade Mystery Box™
Karlos J.Verified
This was my first time ordering from Mystery Knives and I can confidently say that the quality of the knives is unmatched! I would recommend this to anyone who is looking to expand their knife collection. 10/10 would recommend!
Mystery Butterfly Box™
Aleandro N.Verified
This is my first mystery knife box and I loved every second to the order being placed to me opening the packaging. I got these awesome look knives 10/10 will buy more boxes! :)
Mystery Butterfly Box™
Skyler L.Verified
Was blown put of the water with this experience! Great shipping time and great quality in a knife! I bought this as a present and they receiving person was astonished with the product will buy again!
Mystery OTF Box™
Kale H.Verified
I ordered the stiletto automatic mystery box and loved both the knives I received! One had a black pearl handle and the other a light wood handle. Both blades are sharp and shiny. Will be ordering again for sure!
Stiletto Mystery Box™
Anthony O.Verified
Really cool knife! I was honestly not hoping for a switchblade, but it's a mystery box. I'm also totally stoked about it. Nothing like those cool switchblade combs we got as kids in the 80's to look cool. Definitely worth the price, I'm happy. Going to have to try out one of the other boxes next payday.
Mystery Knives Box™
Ethan D.Verified
Hey whoever is reading this know i did the same as you and checked reviews before buying something. I can say that this is honestly a fantastic website to get mystery knives from. originally in my purchase i expected multiple knives but there are different tiers to the quality of the knife. I got a 9/10 on the rarity and managed to get the exact kind of knife i was hoping for. for $40 i got a $110 OTF karambit. 10/10 experience, i was very surprised when i saw it, and i will definitely be buying...
Mystery Knives Box™
Anthony P.Verified
I honestly thought they were not gonna be as good as I saw. When package arrived it had some weight to it and so that threw out the plastic knives thought. These knives are well built and solid and definitely sharp very good quality. I would definitely order again.
Mystery Knives Box™
Kenneth M.Verified
Was looking for a good OTF knife. Found mystery knives and was impressed by the selection and price. Placed my order the same day. I receive my knife and could not be happier. Great price, great quality. Will be placing another order
OTF Mystery Box™
Luke B.Verified
I love how the whole knife feels, the weight is amazing, the edge was a little dull for my liking but I can fix that easy, but overall it's a beautiful knife
9B5-112LBGYDP
Darwin G.Verified
Very happy with my mystery box the two knives I received were above and beyond what I expected if you want quality knives mystery box is the place to get them
Switchblade Mystery Box™
Jacob R.Verified
Fantastic mystery box. My better half was hoping for a karambit, she wasn't disappointed! I was pleasantly impressed with the quality and can't wait for my next box to come!
Mystery Fixed Blade Box™
Reed G.Verified
I have ordered two mystery boxes and I highly recommend them! Great quality and very cool knives. I’ve just started collecting and I can’t wait to get some more 🔥🙌🏻
Mystery Knives Box™
Atticus M.Verified
Amazing customer service I had a problem and they were very nice and assured me my problem will get fixed and knifes that I got are very cool and I plan on getting more.
Mystery Knives Box™
Matthew S.Verified
Got a few premium mystery boxes for myself and as gifts. All have been great and been alternating using them at work daily. Gift was well received as well! Packaging has great presentation and overall has been a very fun experience!
Mystery Knives Box™
Luis Angel V.Verified
I love mystery knives boxes, they are always unique and very well priced, it’s like having a birthday present every month of the year, I have yet to be disappointed with they sent me!
Mystery Knives Box™
Nathan P.Verified
I found your page on tik tok and i fell in love with all your knife box's and had to get one! After buying 4 box's i love my collection i have built from the mystery boxes i bought. I love my summer blue knife, spooky knife's and all the other's i have gotten. I will definitely buy more in the future! :)
Spooky Knives Box™
Joseph H.Verified
I love opening these mystery boxes! The knives are always sharp and at the price point these boxes well worth every penny. I can't wait to order my next one!
Mystery Knives Box™
John N.Verified
I bought the Karambit Mystery Box and absolutely loved it. They even gave me a free knife and a 25% off coupon! I’m so glad I got to support this small business and I will definitely be buying more!
Mystery Karambit Box™
David B.Verified
This knife is not only really coo but it is very solid and appears to be very well made! It is also very sharp and the clip on the knife holds it in place in my pocket very securely.
I love it and have already made my second purchase of a double mystery box!
Thank you guys for not disappointing me and for selling these high quality knives at very reasonable prices .
OTF Mystery Box™
Joseph H.Verified
This was a very cool mystery box with some mini otf knives that came very sharp out the box. I had a question for customer service and they responded promptly with helpful advice. I'm already awaiting my next mystery box.
Mini Mystery Box™
Carter P.
I got these two beautiful stilettos my parents bought me for christmas top tier quality and are very nice. I recommend buying this box i originally thought it came with only one but it comes with two per box!
Stiletto Mystery Box™
Aj D.
I got exactly what I wanted the order came in 5 days bc I got the special shipping which was perfect the only little thing is that one of the knives just dont swing the best but I still absolutely love it will definitely buy again. If I had the money.
Butterfly Mystery Box™
Owen C.Verified
Got two really nice knives and both were genuinely good quality and very sharp. Went in expecting low quality and came out with knives I will continue to love and use!
Mystery Knives Box™
Mathew W.Verified
Package was delivered on time as expected was more than excited about the two knives that I received definitely not something I'm used to but well worth the money would recommend to a friend or family member
Butterfly Mystery Box™
Raven S.Verified
I am going to be completely honest, I wasn’t expecting much with getting the mystery box. But, I was pleasantly surprised with the knives I got in the mystery box. Idk if I just didn’t read but I wasn’t expecting 2 knives in the box so I was happy. especially for like $23 (plus tax), 2 knives is a great deal, and they were even heavy duty. Very well may purchase another box in the future.
Mystery Knives Box™
Cooper N.Verified
It was pretty good, knives were good quality, good size, and looked good, but it looked like it was used a tiny bit, knifes came dusty and I saw moisture, (I don’t know if it was from me or it was just there) but I like my knife and I don’t want to return them.
Mystery Knives Box™
Jef S.Verified
i got such awesome knives!! i love the stone washed blade of the black one, and handle has all these subtle grooves that accommodate my grip so nicely! and the blue one looks like a diving kinife, feels like a g10 handle, and i love the blue camo blade so much! i am so excited, it's like little kid excitement lol!
Fixed-Blades Box™
Heather R.Verified
My wife got this for me as a gift and it was so much fun to open and the knives are awesome! I was worried about the quality but they are great! Can’t wait to get another box!
Mystery Knives Box™
Jack W.Verified
Loved the knives! Great quality and just what I needed. The only thing I’d ask is for them to be a little more sharpened but I can do that myself. Great company
Fixed Blades Box™
Arlee M.Verified
Bought 2 boxes. When they showed up I bought 3 more. I like collecting knives but it’s hard to choose one. Unless it’s a mystery :) came sharp, oiled, packed nice. Good stuff. 10/10 recommend
Mystery Knives Box™
Ian B.Verified
I’m a first time buyer and man when I say these knives are made well that’s an understatement. These knives are built DIFFERENT. The person who makes these knives means quality. Me and my brother love them. They a perfect size in hand and not too heavy or light, Just right. I will definitely be buying from this site again.
Stiletto Mystery Box™
Chris M.Verified
We ordered the 2 butterfly knives mystery box and was pleased with both knives we received. Very sharp and quality is pretty good. The one thing that stands out is the latch. In past experience with butterfly knives the latch is always loose and and never hold. My son and I constantly play with it like a fidget spinner and still holding strong. Buying OTF next.
Butterfly Mystery Box™
Cory S.Verified
First experience was super fast and received my knives in 3 days! I was so happy I ordered 15 more knives! I plan to buy more after that. Price is extremely fair for the uniqueness in my opinion.
6-Pack Sampler™
Timothy H.Verified
I've already shared my feelings. I loved my knives except I received two knives that I specified I did not want. The good news is that you are sending me replacements. Thank you.
Switchblade Mystery Box™
Rosemary O.Verified
I ordered this for my husband who is obsessed with knifes I know he wanted the otf knuckle blade but he was just as satisfied with this one! Hopefully he gets his knuckle blade next time !
Mystery OTF Box™
Mystery Knives ReviewsVisit store