Francis S.Verified
Easy and can’t complain
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"Overall I’m not really dessert type but for b..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsSee product reviews
Daniel C.Verified
Pretty slow delivery. But over all the company communicated well about delays.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
"Tried heating them up but she really didn’t e..."
Michael A.Verified
overcooked hard was not thrilled probably not re-order
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"over cooked and hard was not thrilled with th..."
Alan F.Verified
Experience was fine. Lead time from order to delivery was pretty long, but that’s to be expected. Product was disappointing. Especially after all the hype and time to anticipate.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Beautiful looking and great concept but no de..."
Rick K.Verified
Transaction was painless.
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Great communication, answered any questions t..."
Carrie L.Verified
Excellent service!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I sent these as a gift. I added the personali..."
Sandra W.Verified
Product arrived in a timely manner and were packaged safely. They ware just way too sweet. I could not eat them
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"They were so sweet I could not eat them I too..."
Chris B.Verified
Amazing
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"Awesome. Cant submit a picture or video as I..."
Andrew R.Verified
Good
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"Yummmmm"
Brandi H.Verified
Easy
Purchased item
Mr Buckeye 4-Pack
"I just wasn't impressed with the taste. They..."
Yvette M.Verified
Shopping experience was good product was not good.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The overall taste of them was not good at all..."
Amanda P.Verified
Shipping and packaging was great! Yummy quality treats!
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"It is a wonderful treat. Well made and a grea..."
Julie D.Verified
Awesome flavors. Great quality. 10/10 would recommend
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Very good"
Gina T.Verified
My son was thrilled! Loved all the flavors
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"My son loved them!"
Carson F.Verified
Took a long time to get here and brownies were a little dry maybe because of it
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Ehhhh"
Holly S.Verified
It was great
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Will order again"
Melissa F.Verified
Smooth delivery. Easy to rewarm. Fun treat
Purchased item
The 2026 Starter Pack
"The brownies were deliveries quickly. This wa..."
Andre H.Verified
Everything is delicious and the portions are worth the price
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Don't force me to buy order protect"
Katalina T.Verified
So good! Arrived package very well! Will definitely order again!
Purchased item
Limited Edition February Box
"So good! Arrived package very well! Will defi..."
Derevaughn H.Verified
.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"A bit more cake/cookie than brownie.
Could u..."
Jennifer S.Verified
Ordering and the time it was delivered was good
Purchased item
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
"Maybe it was a fluke but they were very dry"
Joe S.Verified
It took about 12 days to get them only downside of the order
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The brownies taste good very nice sized nice..."
Bailey D.Verified
Shopping wise it was easy to navigate
Purchased item
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
"I was definitely thinking they would be bette..."
Anthony T.Verified
A little high on the brownies but it was delicious. We enjoyed them very much. I'd like to try other things that you offer.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Would've added a video if I had gotten this b..."
Joseph S.Verified
N/A
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"N/A"
Nicole G.Verified
Not sure they are worth the price. They all taste pretty close to the same. They aren't bad, just ok.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Brownies are meehhh. Shipping seemed like it..."
David M.Verified
Good customer service!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"They were great!"
Trish B.Verified
Fast ,fresh delivery!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Nice n big,heavy, and yummy!! A bit rich, but..."
Donnie N.Verified
Delicious and quick ship
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"Tastes great"
Manual A.Verified
It was good 👍.
Purchased item
Limited Edition February Box
"It was good 👍."
Chelsee N.Verified
Dry, too much, lackluster and flavorless despite their bulky appeal. Way too much going on in the brownie took away from flavor depictions.
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Brownies did not have much flavor and were dr..."
Dan H.Verified
Everyone was amazed !!!!!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I know 2.5 lbs is a lot but holy cow!!!!"
Dani A.Verified
It was easy to order.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Valentine’s Pack
"The limited edition Valentine’s Day flavor pa..."
Stephanie T.Verified
Easy shopping and great products
Purchased item
Order Protect
"My package was delivered safe and sound"
David H.Verified
The items were dry
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"They were very dry and unenjoyable."
Andrew S.Verified
Was really easy to pick what I wanted and was so good that I’ll be ordering again in the near future
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"Was really good to eat will be ordering again"
James N.Verified
Took longer than expected for shipping
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Do not see the benefit"
Tom S.Verified
Best brownies around!!!!!
Purchased item
Rush Baking
"Best brownies ever!!!!!! Had to hide from kid..."
Cathleen M.Verified
Will buy these again. We want to try more flavors.
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"They were a wonderful gift for my husband. Th..."
Christina M.Verified
See previous comment.
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"Sent these to my sister and she LOVED them! I..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsVisit store