Preston M.Verified
Easy to order and order came within the week.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"They were great! Kids loved them too. Loved T..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsSee product reviews
Michael M.Verified
Delivery issues paying extra and reaching out ant told the issues was mine.
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"I paid extra for 2 day air and it took 5 days..."
Anthony B.Verified
I wish there were more properly labeled
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I wish that they were labeled on all the brow..."
Dennis P.Verified
Brownies were meh. Nothing else from me.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"U couldn't pay me to eat these again. Maybe m..."
Daniel D.Verified
Great company. Received in perfect condition and fairly quickly so happy with the results.
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"The cups were good. A bit too chocolatey for..."
Bob S.Verified
Nope
Purchased item
Snickerdoodle and Chill 4-Pack
"These Snickerdoodle and Chill brownies are to..."
Tawana M.Verified
From order to delivery, it took too long for a perishable. I paid for expedited shipping. How would they have tasted if I hadn't?
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The brownies are bad. They just don't taste..."
Thomas H.Verified
No good
Purchased item
Order Protect
"No good"
Kelsey M.Verified
Na
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Cookies were good. Too much cookie though."
Melissa T.Verified
Would definitely buy again
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Absolutely delicious!"
Patrick F.Verified
The brownies are great. I think my order took longer to get because of the winter storm.
Purchased item
Terrifically Twix 4-Pack - January Flavor of the Month
"Great brownies."
Jody S.Verified
100 % amazing company! Can't say enough good things about the company. Great products and wonderful people running it. I highly recommend Buckeye Brownies to anyone who loves brownies, blondies or cookies. They don't disappoint!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I kept seeing advertisements for buckeye brow..."
Benjamin A.Verified
Delicious
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Excellent"
Kristin P.Verified
Love them
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The brownies were amazing!!!!"
Stace P.Verified
This was heavenly! So delicious!
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"I would share pictures but this went fast and..."
Anthony P.Verified
Obsessed
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"Letâs just say these are so good my girlfrien..."
Adam R.Verified
Love the brownies
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Perfect"
Shawn B.Verified
Awesome flavor
Purchased item
The 2026 Starter Pack
"Awesome!"
Joe E.Verified
My review speaks for itself. All four individuals that split the items, hated the items. Add in the high cost and it was a total miss.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Honestly as a whole they just weren't very go..."
Lacey Y.Verified
Keep up the good work.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Delicious but just a ton of brownies. Would b..."
Adam W.Verified
Other than soggy fruity pebbles it was good. I already ordered more.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"The fruity pebbles were soggy. The other 3 we..."
Humberto L.Verified
đ
Purchased item
Order Protect
"đ"
Tracey P.Verified
They came faster then I thought they would.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I would love to show pictures but my family a..."
Ellen C.Verified
Ordering on the site was easy. However, I did not find the products themselves to be very good. The large brownies were fresh but lacking in flavor. I did not find them to be worth the purchase price. In fact, the freebie brownies I received courtesy of a promo code tasted better than the ones I actually purchased.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Shipment arrived intact."
Todd B.Verified
We can appreciate the idea behind them. However, they arrived so crumbly and dry, we worried about eating them and how old they were.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"I'm sorry. We threw them away, so I can't tak..."
Davron B.Verified
Great
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Great stuff pebbles and cream changed my life..."
Roger P.Verified
All good
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Brownies were fresh and amazing!!!"
Brad O.Verified
Brownies were dry and didnât look anything like the marketing ads on Facebook. The fruity pebbles was moist in the middle but very blandâŚin fact all of the brownies were pretty bland. They tasted a lot more like cookies from the texture than a brownie at all. Dry cookie taste. Tried a couple bites of the 4 pack and threw out 75% of them. Kids, myself, wife and in laws tried them and didnât like. My kids didnât even finish the small 1 inch pieces we gave them. Disappointed after waiting for a week to ship. Wouldnât recommend. That said you guys do a great job of advertising just doesnât translate based on the order we received anyway.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Brownies were dry and didnât look anything li..."
James V.Verified
:(
Purchased item
The 2026 Starter Pack
"I honestly thought they would be better.
May..."
Darnell W.Verified
Keep up the good work
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Me and my daughter loved every brownie and ca..."
Melani M.Verified
.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The brownie part is great. The top layer is s..."
Katie R.Verified
Disappointed âšď¸
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I was really disappointed
I read such god re..."
Steve Z.Verified
I did not feel the brownies had much flavor at all, and the only flavor really came from the toppings. I would not purchase again.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I did not find any of the brownies had much f..."
Yael W.Verified
Brownies tasted fresh and I like how each is individually wrapped.
Purchased item
Limited Edition Holiday Pack
"The chocolate was amazing. Really loved the c..."
Karen W.Verified
N/a
Purchased item
Order Protect
"I did not like the texture of the brownies, a..."
Roderic S.Verified
Great product, absolutely delicious đ
Purchased item
Order Protect
"All four brownies were absolutely delicious...."
Michael L.Verified
Nope great experience
Purchased item
Limited Edition New Yearâs Surprise Box
"Excellent flavor on all brownies will be orde..."
Breseane R.Verified
Everyone should try at least once.
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Just delicious. Love trying different build y..."
Matt D.Verified
great!
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"very good! the fruity pebbles and churro repl..."
Christine T.Verified
Love the no bake
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"They were good"
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsVisit store