Ethan E.Verified
Delicious!!!
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"They were awesome and everyone that I shared..."
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsSee product reviews
Dawn B.Verified
I was very happy with the brownies
Purchased item
Order Protect
"They were wonderful and big"
Yeidy D.Verified
Good
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"It's was tasty good 👍"
Mynden H.Verified
I will 100% be ordering again!
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"They were exceptional! The perfect amount of..."
John A.Verified
I've been loving all the different month boxes. I know it's hard to ship them faster but some of my boxes came in 3-5 days and some boxes came in 6-8 days. I've noticed the 3-5 day brownies that were shipped we a lot more fresh
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Only complain I have is that this is the seco..."
Andrea M.Verified
Everything was amazing!! I’ll be ordering more! I also share this business with my family and friends as well!
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Everything was great"
Johnny C.Verified
They reimbursed me on my brownies that I didn’t receive and I really appreciated that! Thank u
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"These were so delicious now I really wanna t..."
Jaimee H.Verified
Maybe a bit more communication that they have gotten around to your order. I had to keep checking back to see if the payment went through and if my order shipped. It took almost 2 weeks to ship. I finally got an email saying hey it’s on it way. So something after a week saying don’t worry we didn’t forget we are making your order special. Just so I know I’m not crazy.
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"So good! Will be offering these again. We fou..."
Malcolm A.Verified
I'll try other stuff. Moderation is key here.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Strawberry Cookies were sweet. I liked them f..."
Ryan V.Verified
No
Purchased item
Order Protect
"It was great."
Michael H.Verified
DEEEEEEEELICOUS
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Got the brownies 2 days ago and my entire hou..."
Greg M.Verified
Quality didn’t match price.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Two brownies were stale, another was soggy."
April I.Verified
Quick response, great support, Delicious product
Purchased item
Vegan Box
"Got these for a work function and everyone lo..."
Christy C.Verified
No
Purchased item
Order Protect
"They were a big hit with my son and his fello..."
Lynette M.Verified
When ordering would like to know estimate of arrival before placing order or pick date for delivery.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"This was a gift. He said when he heated the b..."
Garrett S.Verified
I hope the fudge is still coming
Purchased item
Order Protect
"The brownies were just as good as they looked..."
James J.Verified
I love how big these Brownies are! I bought a bunch of flavors because that Facebook ad totally got me, and they were all so good. I liked some a lot more than others (I cried when the last strawbarry cookie was gone) but I ate every single one. The only reason I didn't give them five stars is because of the Twix brownie. It didn't taste like Twix at all, and honestly, it hurt my feelings, lol. They were still pretty good though. The prices are a bit high, but I totally get why. Good stuff!!!
Purchased item
Terrifically Twix 4-Pack - January Flavor of the Month
"The Twix ones were ok. They were tasty, but d..."
Matthew P.Verified
Thank you
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Just as expected!"
Misty G.Verified
No
Purchased item
The 2026 Starter Pack
"Love all the brownies. Great flavor!"
Amar R.Verified
Perfect
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"It was great!"
Melissa E.Verified
Will likely order again
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Love them."
Curtis J.Verified
No
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"They were the best brownies I ever had. I ate..."
Matthew E.Verified
Ok
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"Brownies were dry and bland. Trying heating t..."
Katherine E.Verified
There are more flavors I can't wait to try on my next order!
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"The brownies arrived in a timely fashion and..."
Stephen D.Verified
Best customer service! thank you so much! I recommend trying their brownies to everyone!
Purchased item
No Bake Buckeye Bombs
"amazing!"
Claudio C.Verified
No
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Great"
Alexander B.Verified
Loved all the flavors. Wasn’t hesitant in ordering another box
Purchased item
Order Protect
"It was great. Loved the brownies so much I or..."
Meta R.Verified
Would order again
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Everything was delicious"
Kurt S.Verified
.
Purchased item
The 2026 Starter Pack
"💯 delicious"
Norman P.Verified
I may purchase way too many of these in the future and can truthfully say it is the best thing I’ve had from this company!
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"These brownies are so legit great!"
Grant A.Verified
Very mediocre nothing special was super excited originally but just a big let down.
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Not very impressed, everyone online made it s..."
Becky O.Verified
I would buy again
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Beautiful presentation."
Kei'ellis S.Verified
Thx for giving me a sweet tooth for y’all amazing brownies
Purchased item
Limited Edition Fan Favorite Box
"It was really good I’m so happy I bought sum..."
Bill P.Verified
Expense. Slow to ship. That would be ok if the brownies were good. Even passable would have been fine. These went right in the trash!
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"These things were tasteless!"
Andrea F.Verified
Definitely add a real chocolatey brownie to the 4 pack of "regulars"
Purchased item
Build Your Box
"Definitely loved Cookie Monster and The Dark..."
James G.Verified
Fresh products great taste the whole family loved. It will definitely order again.
Purchased item
The Classics - Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Cups
"So good tasty and fresh"
Logan Z.Verified
The site was cool, there were moments where it would not respond to touchpad on phone
Purchased item
Order Protect
"Cool, fluent shipping"
Michelle S.Verified
Amazing customer service and products.
Purchased item
Fantastic Four Pack
"First time Customer. Definitely enjoy the bro..."
Julia C.Verified
Delicious and not too sweet.
Purchased item
Grandma’s Chocolate Chip Cookies
"Some of the best chocolate chip cookies I’ve..."
Brynne A.Verified
Bland and doughy
Purchased item
The Classics - Cookies and Cream Fudge Brownie Cups
"Chocolatey and delicious"
Buckeye Brownies store reviewsVisit store