Milky Tomato Reviews

Milky Tomato ReviewsSee store reviews

Customer photo review of Cute Lil Clown Socks!

Korin S.

NOTE: OKAY SO! I bought these a bit less than a year ago (It's been around 250 days!) on the Etsy shop before realizing that this site existed! So, I figured, why not post a review about how they've held up? They've held up super well! A bit of pilling, but that's to be expected- ignore the slight staining on the soles, that's my bad haha (wet area problems am I right? Stuff just soaks RIGHT in). The color is still super vibrant except for maybe the cheeks (photo taken in warm lighting, white...

Cute Lil Clown Socks!

Customer photo review of Punk Skellie Keychains!

Justa W.

Love my Keychains, ive had them for a few months, my guitar Keychain had snapped off somehow so I have him jamming out in my car window, the skull is part of my personal keys set(blurred those out tho) quality is great and I love seeing them everyday, thank you!

Punk Skellie Keychains!

Customer photo review of MORE Sparkly Long Cow Stickers!

Joyce N.Verified

Absolutely adorable, and it arrived quickly with free bonus stickers! Solid protective but not wasteful packaging. Answered questions in a timely manner :) Looking forward to ordering again. The sparkles are so perfect, not over the top and just wonderful.

MORE Sparkly Long Cow Stickers!

Customer photo review of Angel & Devil Ghost/Echo & Ophelia Window Stickers

Morgan K.Verified

these applied so easily! id attach a picture but the tint on my car's backseat windows is slightly too dark to give them justice on camera :( i love them either way! so cool

Angel & Devil Ghost/Echo & Ophelia Window Stickers

Customer photo review of Halloween Clown Stickers

Georgia W.Verified

as amazing as always!! stickers are super nice and high quality, shipping was surprisingly fast (I live in the UK) plus the extra stickers to make up for the shipping are also super nice and makes ordering so much more worth it!

Halloween Clown Stickers

Customer photo review of Sticker Mystery Packs!

Victoria B.Verified

Alll of these stickers are soo cute!! And I love the fact that the stickers chosen correlated to the rest of my purchased!! They are so big and well detailed i love it ^^

Sticker Mystery Packs!

Customer photo review of Runaway Ghosts Lanyard

Emma H.Verified

I LOVE it!!! It’s so adorable stylish and pretty durable for like a wallet, keys, keychains or anything thing else! Again I love it and plan on using it a lot more often!

Runaway Ghosts Lanyard

Customer photo review of Christmas Ghosties Mini Prints 4x5"

Logan I.Verified

I've wanted to but something from here for a while and all the prints and others came out super nice and good quality (this is gonna be for all of them because I'm tired and don't feel like being unique)

Christmas Ghosties Mini Prints 4x5"

Customer photo review of Milky's Creative Cafe

Amity X.Verified

AMAZING AS ALWAYS!!! I'm really excited about the berry bush sheep (they're the reason I finally got into sticker club) and Sammy is creepily precious with all his questionable food! I will say the star glitter surprised me because I wasn't expecting it (it go everywhere lol) but I always appreciate the confetti (I might have started a confetti jar). Service is great, quality is great, and Jam is the bestest. Can't wait for next month <3

Milky’s Creative Cafe

Customer photo review of Dino Party Sticker Sheet

Rexi S.Verified

They are a good size and just absolutely adorable 10/10 would DEFINITELY recommend and how can you say no? It’s cute it’s awesome ITS DINOSAURS!!! You should definitely buy this

Dino Party Sticker Sheet

Customer photo review of Droopy Eye Girl Small Sticker Book

Emma K.Verified

i just got my order with all these items and i’m in love with it all! the sticker book is amazing quality and the sticker paper inside has kept my stickers perfect, i 100% recommend to anyone looking for a good sticker book <33 i’m ordering again soon🫶

Droopy Eye Girl Small Sticker Book

Customer photo review of Ghost Date V3 Sticker Sheet

Aurelius

Came as expected, Good quality for price, came inside of the sticker book packaging to avoid damage. My personal favorite of them all. :) They are a bit thicker and harder to get off the page than stickers I am use to(You kind of have to use your nail), which did make me feel like I might rip them. I will say it is more of a good thing than a bad thing, once you get used to it.

Ghost Date V3 Sticker Sheet

Customer photo review of Large Vampire Enamel Pin!

Alexis

i knew the pin would be large, but it really is so big and eye-catching. it has a thick edge with three pins on the back that keep it attached even after jostling my bag around. i’ve ordered stickers from here before but this was my first time getting a pin and i’m very happy with its quality!

Large Vampire Enamel Pin!

Customer photo review of Teeth Pills Stickers!

Mackenzie J.Verified

I LOVE THEMMM!!! im so happy with my stickers i put the teef one in my sketch book that i also go from here! i will be getting more when i have more money.

Teeth Pills Stickers!

Customer photo review of Circus Daydream Pencil Pouch

Ruby M.Verified

Although it was a little bit smaller than i had expected it to be, it works amazing! I use this to carry art supplies whenever im on the go aND I LOVE THE DESIGN AND STYLEE SHDBDHSHFVS 10/10 this product slayed

Circus Daydream Pencil Pouch

Customer photo review of Red Mushroom Ghost Sketchbook

Paula G.Verified

The paper is so good and soft to work with! And the book itself is the perfect size and so pleasant to the touch, definitely one of the best sketch books I've had!

Red Mushroom Ghost Sketchbook

Customer photo review of Circus Daydream Reusable Sticker Book

Erika R.Verified

So happy with it. When i saw these for sale, i knew i had to get one because i needed a way to display all my stickers because I'm too scared to stick them on something yet.

Circus Daydream Reusable Sticker Book

Customer photo review of Blue Mushroom Ghost Enamel Pin 2in

Elliot B.Verified

I collect enamel pins so I would say I’ve got a pretty good eye for quality and I gotta say this pin is excellent quality! Good clean fill on the enamel, the detail is stunning and t is a perfect edition to my collection!

Blue Mushroom Ghost Enamel Pin 2in

Customer photo review of Milky's Creepy Corner

Alexia A.Verified

I'm late to review, but pleased with my order as always! This was a gift for a friend—I had it shipped directly to her. She was thrilled! Ordered on February 29, and arrived on March 6. From Texas to Utah.

Milky’s Creepy Corner

Customer photo review of Space Ghost Duo Credit Card Skins

Kris L.Verified

i would take a picture of it but i don’t want anyone having my debit card info lol. BUT I LOVE IT SO MUCH! it makes me happy when i get to pull out a fun card.

Space Ghost Duo Credit Card Skins

Customer photo review of Moth Witch Stickers

Liz B.Verified

So cute I got it for my friend cuz she had a Rosie maple moth that recently died and she loved it so much and look at it it’s so cute

Moth Witch Stickers

Customer photo review of Adopt a Star Baby Plush Blind Box

Alastor G.Verified

This is my son, my baby, my child, I love them so much I named them Mythos and I take them with me to work because they make me smile sm

Adopt a Star Baby Plush Blind Box

Customer photo review of Star Baby Large Plushies - Preorder

Kat D.Verified

I love them so much, so so sooo soft and fluffy these are the most precious and soft plushies I’ve ever had, I have gave them nicknames which are Ourble for the sleepy eye one and Sqinklely for the regular eye one and I love them so much and my tv stand proudly shows off the minis

Star Baby Large Plushies - Preorder

Customer photo review of Angel of the Eyes Sketchbooks

Loralai G.Verified

The book is literally my favorite sketch book of all time!! the design was perfect and the paper has a nice feeling to it! If I wasn’t broke I would buy 5 more!!❤️❤️

Angel of the Eyes Sketchbooks

Customer photo review of Star Baby Camera Keychain Picture Frame

J G.

I had gotten the keychain when I was in San Japan in 2024 or 25, I was really indecisive for this one or the Cherry Blossom one. But after buying it and having it hooked on my pants hook or on my bag with other merch I’ve gotten during the same day of convention, it has been with me throughout time and I have been very glad that I’d invested into it. ^_^

Star Baby Camera Keychain Picture Frame

Customer photo review of Fast Food Snake With Text Tote Bag

Tuesday

I fell in love with this design the moment I saw it! I adore the food snakes as a whole, but this bag being a whole meal with the silly little phrase is just perfection! The fabric feels really sturdy and is even better quality than I could've asked for! Really excited to use this cutie!!

Fast Food Snake With Text Tote Bag

Customer photo review of Virtual Sea Pet Desk Mat!

Rosie O.

MilkyTomato's Sea Creature mousepad has such a whimsical design! It arrived much sooner than I anticipated, and surprised me with lovely star confetti and stickers included. The mouspad itself is large and encompasses much of my desk. It seems to be printed on a higher quality, thicker mousepad material. I have no doubts that this mousepad will last a long time. The art is clear and crisp and the colors are delightfully vibrant. This mouspad is particularly special to me as I was in the stream c...

Virtual Sea Pet Desk Mat!

Amalgam

I'm super happy with my starbaby! Little Theophania (or Theo, or Tiff) arrived in great condition, they're just. So cute. My little ourple creature 💜 Would absolutely buy this again.

Adopt a Star Baby Plush Blind Box

Customer photo review of Clown Sea Slug Stickers

Circusmoth

I'm so happy oh my god! Look at these cute little babies! They're so cute, literally my favorite things (sea slugs and circus) combined into one! Best art ever. Might be a little biased though 😅 Other than that, the creator is like the sweetest person everrr, you get constant updates on the state of your package, shipping was pretty quick, and I even got bonus stickers for free🥹 it was so sweet. Like look at those silly gummy worms, and I adore the clown they have as like the main logo. Omg, and...

Clown Sea Slug Stickers

Customer photo review of Milky's Cute Club

Jenna G.Verified

Okay so I love this! There was a problem with the charges at first but the customer service team was AMAZINGLY helpful!! These are definitely going to be the highlight of my month and the secret store is INCREDIBLE! I would definitely recommend 10/10!

Milky’s Cute Club

Alexandra P.Verified

I love it so much! The fabric is so soft and it's so cute. I thought that I would be bothered by the rattle, but it's quiet enough to not be a bother, yet loud enough to make me wanna shake it. I got the pink one (her name is Cherry) and I'm definitely looking to get her a friend soon.

Adopt a Star Baby Plush Blind Box

Therese E.Verified

Wonderful experience ordering from you, had some issues with tracking the package. When it arrived it still said “preparing order” but it arrived in great condition. And I loved all the products!

Sticker Mystery Packs!

Customer photo review of Mothman Enamel Pin

Miss E.Verified

It’s such a cute lil pin! It’s reflectiveness means it looks like a different colour depending on the lighting and that -for me- just leans into the fun cute cryptid vibe ^^

Mothman Enamel Pin

Rosa G.

aaaa everything is so so cute! i got the purple star baby which is the exact one i wanted so i was very happy! everything is so nice and cute and amazing quality honestly. all the freebie stickers were so nice too! i wasn’t expecting so much so i was pleasantly surprised to see so many <3

Adopt a Star Baby Plush Blind Box

Kat D.Verified

I love all the stuff I can get with the cute Club! The pin was way bigger than I expected and the star babies holding hands is so cute! The candle cats are super cute glad I bought the subscription in time to get them!

Milky’s Cute Club

Customer photo review of Cute Little Clown Plushies - PREORDER

Leo N.Verified

This silly clown has changed my life… Before getting this beautiful joyous clown I was simply a shell of a glorious individual, too scared to do anything… BUT I FRET NO LONGER!! This clown has found a way into not only my heart, but my soul. Scared to say hi to that creepy neighbor? SQUEAK THE CLOWN!! Worried about that mysterious flying object in the sky? SQUEAK THE CLOWN!! Truly brilliant.

Cute Little Clown Plushies - PREORDER

Customer photo review of Mystery Sticker Sheet Packs!

Chrystal T.

Bought this again because I love them so much!! Gave me the same stickers as last time but, they gave me a 50% refund which is amazing!! Definitely buying again!!!

Mystery Sticker Sheet Packs!

Customer photo review of Mothman Sweater Weather Stickers

Maxx R.

My girlfriend and I split the stickers, she got the ones on the bottom and I kept the ones on top. I put them on the case for my iPad, and I am in lovee.

Mothman Sweater Weather Stickers

Customer photo review of Cute Space Ghost Stickers! : V5

Sarah S.Verified

I got 7 things from MilkyTomato and they all turned out wonderful! Many freebies too!! I love all of my order I’ll def be ordering again! I had troubles with my delivery and the package was sent back to them due to my mail facility but they were very quick to send it back my way! Super nice and amazing products!

Cute Space Ghost Stickers! : V5

Customer photo review of Cute Ghost Stickers! : V1

Sushi M.Verified

The stickers feel so nice and smooth! I still haven't decided where they're gonna go, but I get very excited every time I think about it! Definitely purchasing some more soon!! 💛💛

Cute Ghost Stickers! : V1

Milky Tomato ReviewsVisit store