Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys Reviews - 141 Reviews | shipwrecktreasuresofthekeys.com

Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys ReviewsSee store reviews

Visit store
Customer photo review of 1715 Fleet Artifact - Musket Ball Shot in Custom Galleon Mount
Kevin C.
I am very excited to have a piece sunken treasure! The necklace is beautiful! I am a treasure seeker as well . I have been metal detecting in the New England area for approximately 20 years. Thank you for the opportunity to share the amazing treasure that you have found.
1715 Fleet Artifact - Musket Ball Shot in Custom Galleon Mount
Customer photo review of San Jose Panama Shipwreck 1631 - 8 Reale - Grade 5
Matt P.
Very pleased with the service and care that was put into my purchase with Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys. Onett & his team are the best in the business! Can’t recommend them enough. Love my new San José treasure coin.
San Jose Panama Shipwreck 1631 - 8 Reale - Grade 5
Customer photo review of Custom Ring created with pure Atocha Silver (from an Atocha Silver bar) with Atocha Copper Inlay.+1
Jeremy F.
This was just what I was looking for, in a wedding ring. A simple but elegant ring with a great historical backstory. This beautiful ring fit the bill perfectly. And you were so kind to make getting a replacement easy when I accidentally ordered the ring a bit too small for my hand. Thank you!
Custom Ring created with pure Atocha Silver (from an Atocha Silver bar) with Atocha Copper Inlay.
Customer photo review of Nuestra Señora de Atocha - 8 Reales - Grade 3 - Assayer "T" - (1618-1622)+1
Roger H.
Just wanted to share my experience of having dealt with Mr. Onett and Shipwreck Treasures of the keys. Every time we’re in Key West, we always swing through and see some of their latest creations and all the beautiful jewelry they have. I’ve made several purchases from them and brought many of my friends Who have bought from them as well. It’s always a pleasure. I would highly recommend purchasing anything from them and always stop by when you’re down in Key West. They have always been helpful a...
Nuestra Señora de Atocha - 8 Reales - Grade 3 - Assayer "T" - (1618-1622)
Customer photo review of Atocha Shipwreck - 4 Reales -Grade 3 - Mexico Mint - Partial Date -16(XX)
Dianne W.
Scott and Onett were great and took great care of me. My husband loved the coin I was able to surprise him with. They are the best! If you get to Key West, you should absolutely stop in and see their store!
Atocha Shipwreck - 4 Reales -Grade 3 - Mexico Mint - Partial Date -16(XX)
Customer photo review of Ancient Greece - AR Drachma - Alexander the Great - Circa 305-281 BCE - Presented in a 14K Bezel with an Italian leather bracelet.
Kenneth L.
We stopped into Shipwreck Treasures in Key West and had an excellent experience with Dan. He was welcoming, knowledgeable, and genuinely enthusiastic about the items in the shop. No pressure — just great conversation and a real appreciation for history. A bracelet with an ancient-style coin immediately caught my eye. Because of my military service and time overseas, pieces with historical symbolism tend to resonate with me, and this one drew me in right away. Dan was patient, helpful, and made t...
Ancient Greece - AR Drachma - Alexander the Great - Circa 305-281 BCE - Presented in a 14K Bezel with an Italian leather bracelet.
Customer photo review of Ancient Greek - Poseidon (Hieron II) - Syracuse, Sicily - AE Bronze - Circa (275-215 BCE)
Ann S.
I love the ring and history, wish it would have came with a ring box. Even more so, a ring box shaped like a treasure chest. The staff were friendly, and knowledgeable, I already was familiar with the shipwreck but not this coin. I am a fisherman and fell in love with it the moment i saw it. The entire store was nice.
Ancient Greek - Poseidon (Hieron II) - Syracuse, Sicily - AE Bronze - Circa (275-215 BCE)
Customer photo review of Limited Edition - Atocha Silver Bar Pendant -14K Gold Mount
Eric P.
I 100% love the mini Atocha bar. I saw it while in the store in KW, but passed. I decided to get it after and purchased online. Easy and shipped quickly. I pared it with my 4 reale Atocha coin and the bezel even matched which was a plus.
Limited Edition - Atocha Silver Bar Pendant -14K Gold Mount
Customer photo review of Shipwreck of the Nuestra Señora de Atocha - 8 Reales - Grade 2+1
Dustin P.
I am so pleased with this purchase. Daniel was so helpful from the start. I am not not one to purchase something of this value over the phone and have it shipped. However Daniel truly put me at ease. He texted me detailed photos of the Atocha coins, their history and all their original documentations. He also discussed with me all of their safeguards that are in place with shipping. This is something I have truly wanted for years and I am so glad I called Ship Wreck Treasures of the Keys. Thank ...
Shipwreck of the Nuestra Señora de Atocha - 8 Reales - Grade 2
Customer photo review of La Capitana Shipwreck - 8 Reales - Date: 1654 - Assayer: "E" (1651-1679)
Roger H.
Shipwreck treasures of key west is a top notch resource to purchase your next treasure from!.. I have purchased multiple pieces from them and always stop in and say hello to see what’s new when I’m in key west. They have the knowledge and experience for all your questions to help you pick the perfect treasure and it all comes with a friendly smile and no pressure atmosphere. Do your self a favor and go see them!😎
La Capitana Shipwreck - 8 Reales - Date: 1654 - Assayer: "E" (1651-1679)
Customer photo review of 1715 Fleet Shipwreck - 2 Escudo - Lima Mint - Dated 1710 - NGC graded MS 62.
Jason K.
Mr Onett Johnson is first class all the way! His team was able to mount the coin to my request and they knocked it out of the park! Minor hiccups in between but Mr Johnson made things right. Highly recommend Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys. This 1715 shipwreck doubloon will be family heirloom for my kids and I am glad Mr Johnson and his team part of it!
1715 Fleet Shipwreck - 2 Escudo - Lima Mint - Dated 1710 - NGC graded MS 62.
Customer photo review of Ancient Greek - Poseidon - Syracuse, Sicily - AE Bronze - Circa 275-215 BC
Gabriela P.
We had a good time in your shop when we bought that beautiful ring. The service we got in your shop was excellent. Thank you so much. We enjoyed it and had a lot of fun. Warm regards, Gabriela and Kai
Ancient Greek - Poseidon - Syracuse, Sicily - AE Bronze - Circa 275-215 BC
Customer photo review of Ancient Widows Mite (Coin of the Bible) - Circa 103-76 BC - Pendant in Sterling Silver Mount (Sterling Silver Chain included)
Jane W.
Odell & his staff are great. Whether you’re looking for a piece to remind you of Key West or you’re looking for a gift or just to treat yourself… shop w/Shipwreck Treasures. I love the necklace & matching earrings. I wear them casually & for business. The earrings are sterling & light enough that my lobes are not sagging. Great story & witnessing tool behind the widows mite as well. 🩷 Jane
Ancient Widows Mite (Coin of the Bible) - Circa 103-76 BC - Pendant in Sterling Silver Mount (Sterling Silver Chain included)
Customer photo review of Limited Edition - Atocha Silver Bar Pendant - Silver Mount
Victor T.
I slept on the Silver bar wrapped in 14k, so I went with the 925 round wire, the flat was sold out. So lesson learned, don’t sleep buy! Was not expecting it to come with a 925 chain, very impressed. I’m interested in another round of 14k wrapped bars. Can’t wait to hit the showroom.
Limited Edition - Atocha Silver Bar Pendant - Silver Mount
Customer photo review of Aquamarine Ellipse Ring
T B.
I stumbled upon this ring in the store and fell in love with it the moment that I slipped it on my finger. It's such a unique and one of a kind piece with my daughter's birthstone.
Aquamarine Ellipse Ring
Customer photo review of Atocha Shipwreck 1622 - 4 Reales - Grade 3 - Assayer T (1618-1621)
Mary Lee R.
I had the pleasure of working with Anita. She helped us find the perfect piece of history. She was friendly, knowledgeable and patient. I honestly love my piece. Thank you so much Anita!
Atocha Shipwreck 1622 - 4 Reales - Grade 3 - Assayer T (1618-1621)
Customer photo review of The Sacred Pendant -14K gold - diamond accented.
Helen J.
The pendant is exquisite and one of a kind...A remembrance of our Key West visit & time spent with Ornett, the owner. Best customer service ever!
The Sacred Pendant -14K gold - diamond accented.
Customer photo review of Ancient Roman - AE Bronze - Theodosius II - Circa (402-450) CE
Sandra P.
Onet is so wonderful to work with. He helped so much to find the perfect coin for our daughter's birthday present . The coin is Amazing!! Thank you Onet!! Sandra
Ancient Roman - AE Bronze - Theodosius II - Circa (402-450) CE
Customer photo review of Compass Rose Pendant w/ Sterling Silver Chain
Jessie H.
Customer service is above and beyond. I absolutely love this and appreciate such a fine piece of jewelry. Thank you.
Compass Rose Pendant w/ Sterling Silver Chain
Customer photo review of Atocha 1622 Shipwreck - 2 Reales - Grade 3 - Assayer- Not Visible - Presented in a 14K Gold Mount accented with a Tanzanite gemstone
Jeffrey F.
Great staff and selection. Extremely knowledgeable about the coins and the specific wrecks. Reasonable priced compared to another store in the area.
Atocha 1622 Shipwreck - 2 Reales - Grade 3 - Assayer- Not Visible - Presented in a 14K Gold Mount accented with a Tanzanite gemstone
Mark B.
Very informative and helpful in understanding the history of the wrecks as well as some of the history and background of the artifacts. Also the understanding of the recovery process. A good value overall.
Coins of the Lost Galleons
Dan M.
Scott and Dan were remarkably kind and incredibly informative about all the pieces in the shop. In October of 2024 my wife and I just happened to walk in. We had no idea what we were walking into. Scott spent over an hour guiding us through the different items and giving us a history lesson while doing it. When we returned in October of 25 we made a point to make a significant purchase because of the time spent in 2024. My wife is so happy with her piece and so am I.
Ancient Judea - AE Prutah - Circa 30 AD - Pontius Pilot as Governor - Jerusalem Mint
Erin P.
What a gorgeous piece of history! My husband absolutely loves it. Thank you for the quick shipping and ease of ordering. I'm certain we'll purchase more items from you in the future. Thank you again!
Ancient Crusader Coin - Bohemond VI - Circa (1252 - 1268) CE
Carey C.
Met onett the owner while in a trip to key west and bought numerous pieces from him. Always friendly good quality merchandise and will even ship to you live the customer service
Limited Edition - Atocha Silver - Spanish Cross Pendant
Michael G.
I was BLOWN AWAY by the amazing service, professionalism, good communication, and kindness!!! I could not believe the SPECTACULAR, added gift that I received after sharing that I was purchasing an item to create a treasure chest for a family party!!!! You guys are THE BEST, and I hope to do business with you again soon!!! A+++++ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
1715 Fleet Artifact - Musket Ball Shot
Kelsey H.
Very exciting to have such a fascination piece of history! I appreciate the small thank you card included with my order and the information card about these musket shots was very informative. The shipping was fast and my order was very well packaged. I'm happy that I found this company and I plan to be a returning customer.
Shipwreck Musket Ball Shot - Shipwreck unknown - Circa 1738 - Possible Pirate shipwreck
Isabel G.
I bought a coin for my husband as an anniversary present and it could not have been more perfect! I’m from Chicago and went off website pictures. From clear images to smooth shipping, the whole process was fantastic. We absolutely loved the coin necklace and it also came with a certificate. Thank you so much! ☺️
Ancient Greece - AE Bronze - Poseidon "King of the Seas". Circa (275-216) BCE
Melissa H.
I have about 30 pieces I bought from Dan and their staff! I would never go anywhere else. They not only have the most beautiful pieces but the knowledge they have of each piece is unbelievable! It's an investment you will never regret! Thank you guys see you soon❤️
Widows Mite - Biblical coin minted in Judea during the time of Christ. - Sterling Silver Earrings
Jonathan S.
great book my son loves it and Dan of Shipwreck Treasure was amazing! He was kind, had interesting things to show and share, and very patient with my 4 yearold in his shop!!!
Where do pirates go on vacation? Children’s Book
Jacob H.
The staff was absolutely fantastic to work with and extremely knowledgeable. I did quite a bit of shopping for coins while in Key West and they were by far the most willing to work with me and what I was looking for.
El Cazador Shipwreck - 8 Reales - Dated 1783
Elissa R.
This place is wonderful! An incredible selection for any price point. The owner is helpful, personable, and worked with me to find the perfect gift that my friend absolutely loved. Definitely recommend!
San Jose Panama Shipwreck 1631 - 8 Reale - Grade 5
Karen M.
I bought this beautiful pendant as a gift for my mother in law. The lady in the shop was extremely pleasant & helpful. I bought a second pendant , also beautiful & good value for money. These were brought back to Ireland and were much admired & appreciated. I would highly recommend this shop.
One of a Kind Agate Pendant in Sterling Silver Mount
Mark L.
Listen, buying coins in KW is a risky business. I have a huge collection of coins. You don't buy in KW looking for a deal. But the team was professional and nice. I got a minor discount from the asking, but most importantanly, I got the coin i wanted. Could i have save a few bucks? Probably but this coin will be with me for 30 yrs or more and then passed on to my son which is an easy decision for me. Lastly, we have several Atocha coins that are grade 1. We are much bigger fans of the E...
El Cazador - 8 Reale - Dated 1783 - Grade Mint
Cynthia E.
Very nice. Just the right size, not too big and not tiny. The detail is perfect. It looks like the ones that the fishhook is the clasp, a worrisome feature, but it actually has a traditional clasp so it’s secure.
Sterling Silver Fish Hook Necklace
Scott G.
Wonderful piece of jewelry. Saw this in store but did not purchase at the time. Ended up buying it online and had a great experience with the ordering process. Item was shipped quickly and arrived in perfect condition. Highly recommend this shop.
Ancient Greece - AR Diobol (1/12 Stater) - Minted in Melitos, Ionia - Circa: 550-494 BCE
Melissa K.
This was a 70th birthday gift for my mother who loves this story from the Bible and coin jewelry so this was perfect for her. She loved it and said she wants to wear it every day!
Widows Mite - Sterling Silver Tear Drop Mount - Sterling Silver Chain included
Charlene P.
This is a fun set to bring home to remember our time in the Keys. The box is nice quality and the items work well as one would expect. We did have a bit of an issue taking it through TSA in our carry on. If you have checked bags you can save yourself the hassle.
Old World Maritime Navigation Replica Set w/ Storage Box
Customer photo review of Authentic Spanish Cob Coins - 1/2 Reales - Potosi Mint - Mounted in custom 14K - Ear Ring set
Ann H.
I have always loved very old coins...the history and artistry involved in hand stamping coins, and knowing the coins have been on the ocean floor in shipwrecked trade vessels or treasure ships just makes them more interesting. I was able to track my purchase on line and was happy with how quickly they arrived. The earrings are lovely and are just as described.
Authentic Spanish Cob Coins - 1/2 Reales - Potosi Mint - Mounted in custom 14K - Ear Ring set
Beth S.
I got 2 items for a good friend, and I deeply appreciated the time you all spent with me finding something within my budget, which was not large. I was not belittled and didn't feel out of place, and was able to find 2 things my friend thinks are really cool. I cannot thank you enough for helping me find a great gift!!
Ancient Roman Coin - AE Drachm - Circa 400 CE
Shipwreck Treasures of the Keys ReviewsVisit store